Blair Witch wasn't scary though. I'm almost possitive the intent was to be scary. But you're right, most people laughed at it. That doesn't make for a very good horror flick. So if I watch it with comedy in mind, I'm sure I'd like it.
Sixth Sense was intended to be scary. I did not find it scary in the slightest. I think I jumped at one point, but I don't even remember when that was. I saw it as a very very VERY sad trajedy. That poor boy had to deal with dead people for the rest of his life. That's so incredibly sad. No one should have to do that, especially a child.
Now, Mothman Prophecies was neither scary, nor funny, nor a trajedy. Maybe a sob story, but it wasn't really even good at that. I was impressed that they made the man try so hard.
The Game was a good movie ... right up to the end. At which point I was really pissed.
All those movies about "I know what you did last summer" and the other stupid one with the butcher knife dude ... nah, I laughed at those too. The girls were mostly hot though - that was enjoyable. Too bad they couldn't just cut their close off instead of cutting them to pieces completely.