After 23 hours or so, credits rolled on Gears of War E-Day and I have thoughts.
On the technical side it's one of the most detailed, expansive, and demanding games I've played; it pushed my PC hardware hard and actively tried to kill my CPU (and everyone else's!). The gameplay has not changed much since the original formula and that's OK, as every game of the franchise has tweaked things a little, but the core remains the same. The new enemies, weapons and mods and management options were quite good.
Now, on the story side I think it's a bit underwhelming and underdeveloped. As a veteran Gears player, I know what transpired on E-Day, but how it is portrayed here is not what I imagined after all these years. While our protagonists and their leadership are blind to the Locust intentions, we who have played through the franchise already know, so there are no major surprises here. For a while there is a subplot about a commander rescuing VIPs over the general population that only leads to a reference for the first game, with no further consequences or impact to the game (lame), and while the new characters Mags and Lucas have some charm, their stories are also quite underdeveloped (not that there is too much depth in general in Gears' games to begin with), and the final boss is rather weak for the hype it had been building.
IMO, we probably didn't need a Marcus and Dom story here, and a fresh set of protagonists would've worked better (Hoffman, Anya, Adam Fenix...)
They have hinted they will make other games in the timeline before the original, but what will they cover? After all they ended incinerating most of the surface from orbit!
At some point the game starts to become exhausting, if not repetitive, while fighting wave after wave or the Locust horde, so by the end I felt relief, rather than pure enjoyment. I think an 8/10 score is fitting, and I will replay it in the future, as I've had with all other Gears games.