- 4,602

- Mexico
I watched Disclosure Day on an IMAX screen this past Sunday, and then I rewatched Saving Private Ryan (Bluray) at home.
Disclosure Day is good and entertaining, as Spielberg still knows how to get a hold of the audience until the very end, but of his alien-themed movies, this is barely better than War of the Worlds, and nowhere near as iconic as Close Encounters of the Third Kind and E.T. I will give it 7/10 and will probably rewatch it when it hits the streaming services.
While the middle still drags a bit between the explosive D-Day assault and final battle, I paid closer attention to corporal Upham's running subplot, and its really a narrative hidden in plain sight with its own arc and resolution.
Shakespeare in Love winning the Oscar for best picture that year is one of the biggest travesties in the history of the award... Anyways, Saving Private Ryan is 9.5/10, and my second favorite Spielberg movie.
Disclosure Day is good and entertaining, as Spielberg still knows how to get a hold of the audience until the very end, but of his alien-themed movies, this is barely better than War of the Worlds, and nowhere near as iconic as Close Encounters of the Third Kind and E.T. I will give it 7/10 and will probably rewatch it when it hits the streaming services.
Now, on rewatching Saving Private Ryan, the gap from peak Spielberg to good Spielberg is considerable! (Good Spielberg is still superior to 80% of films out there though.)Now, there is a detail that could dramatically change what you feel about the movie if you play along:
After the truth comes out (after all the chasing) the weather report lady/improvised news anchor played by Emily Blunt is about to convey to the audience the message whispered to her by the alien, then the screen goes black. That can completely change the tone of the movie, depending on what you imagine the message is.
While the middle still drags a bit between the explosive D-Day assault and final battle, I paid closer attention to corporal Upham's running subplot, and its really a narrative hidden in plain sight with its own arc and resolution.
Shakespeare in Love winning the Oscar for best picture that year is one of the biggest travesties in the history of the award... Anyways, Saving Private Ryan is 9.5/10, and my second favorite Spielberg movie.
Last edited:
