Would you rather?

  • Thread starter Thread starter motortrend
  • 22,046 comments
  • 1,124,458 views
-> Things are going very quick here!! :scared:

BT -> ...

US-Jetta v. Elantra -> Ugh, I just can't get rid of the fact that the regular US-spec Jetta is a downgraded/decontented version (ie. torson-beam v. IRS & red v. amber rear turn signals) of the Euro-spec version (except the underwhelming mk.VI GLI). And the Elantra sedan is far too common here in Vegas. So I pick NONE of them!

GT3-Spec Race Cars -> As far as I like the Matech-Ford GT due to rarity...I'll pick a car that will give me the least headache. My choice is the 997 GT3 R.

Passat v. Fusion -> There is no way I will pick a Hybrid, EVER! Even if its not the Euro-version, I'll take the Passat.


I see where you're coming from, I'll wait for a Sport trim IRL. But don't get me wrong, I kinda like the F30 3-Series, can't wait for the M3 version and see what it can do, but I still want to get a E30-E92 M3 though. Nothing beats those 3s. ;)
^ I've driven the F30 328i Sport, it was a very decent kit! So decent infact you wouldn't mind the 335i anymore! I think the F35 M3, would be very good. But being an E46 M driver, the last M3 I will consider would be the E90 M sedan...I see it as the (somewhat) true successor to the E39 M5. ;)

The only new BMW I can't stand is the 6-Series :yuck:. That Gran Coupe looks weird after seeing it around here in the Southern Highlands and the Henderson area in Vegas :indiff:.
^ On the contrary, while I don't like the regular F06/F12/F13. I really do like the the F06 M6, so much that I'd pick the M6 GC over the F10 M5!

I hope they do a coupe version like the E63/64 M6 Coupe, if not I'll take a 2010 M6 coupe over this 6 Series any day.
^ I'm sorry, but I would never pick the E63/64 M6, ever. ;)
 
Jetta: Neither one would be my choise but i have to go with the Jetta.

Aston Martin V12 Vantage GT3: It was hard choice but my heart said take it.

Passat: I have to go with the Passat, not too keen with Fusion.
 
Fusion, please! I drove a 1st gen Fusion with the base (160hp) 4 cylinder, and it was very good. Had plenty of power (don't laugh), handled well (don't laugh), and got very good MPG (at least compared to the 16-19mpg we get in the F150s and Town Car). Also, it was comfortable (just as much space in front as the F150s and nearly as much space in the back), it rode nicely, and it was quiet.

[patriotism]
A lot of people (at least here in 'Murica) go with German or Japanese cars over American cars, because it's apparently the obvious choice. That may have been the case from the late 80s to about 2005 (2009 for Chrysler products) but American cars are better than they have ever been and are more than capable of outdoing foreign competition. [/patriotism]


Edit: I should clarify that I'm not saying the Passat is a bad car, I'm sure it's very good. I've been in modern VW's (2013 Beetle Turbo and 2013 Eos) and they were pretty good. I really liked the Beetle, but the Eos was incredibly overpriced. They were asking just over $40,000 for a small car with a few small options on it. Also, they had some hard plastics in obvious places (I'm sure the Ford does, as well) but otherwise were very nice to be in. In fact, if I went non-American for a car, I'd probably choose VW (or possibly Honda).
 
Last edited:
[patriotism]
A lot of people (at least here in 'Murica) go with German or Japanese cars over American cars, because it's apparently the obvious choice. That may have been the case from the late 80s to about 2005 (2009 for Chrysler products) but American cars are better than they have ever been and are more than capable of outdoing foreign competition. [/patriotism]

Totally agree, it's sad that some people dont consider them. We get the Cruze and Epica over here and I think they're good.

Now, Jaguar XK 4.2 (low miles) ...
xk-lead.jpg

Or Mercedes SL55?
sl55amg.jpg

Both are wonderful GT cars with good power and a relative bargain now, cant lose either way.:)
 
motortrend
The jag looks a little dated, while the Benz looks even better than the new one. Benz it is!

Yeah i agree. Though the Jaguar does sound amazing. I still have always liked the Benz more. Tough choice though
 
Passat vs. Fusion: I'd easily take the Fusion as it's a good car. My mom has the previous generation in hybrid form and it's really excellent and gets great mileage in the city (where she does 95% of her driving). Also Ford at least tried to style it, the Passat just looks like a generic car.

Jag vs. Mercedes: The Jaguar XK, ever since I've seen one, I've wanted one.
 
Jaguar XK 4.2 vs. Mercedes-Benz SL55 AMG

I'd take the SL55 AMG. The XK looks very majestic but I suppose it's much more comfort-oriented. Yes, it's got lots of compelling personality and traits; a quite fast grand tourer that will also provide a relaxing long-distance cruise. The SL55 AMG's ride may be less supple than that of the XK but I think it's faster and much more exciting to drive, while still delivering more than decent amount of comfort, making it more appealing to me as a whole. However, I think if it was XKR vs. SL55 AMG, I would take the XKR instead.


Volkswagen Passat TDI SEL vs. Ford Fusion Hybrid Titanium

I've heard lots of very, very positive things about the new Fusion models, but, well, the current-generation Passats aren't that bad either. I'd take the Passat, it's got a reserved, dignified look I'd classify as highly suitable for a mid-size sedan, while still looking classy in a modestly minimalistic way. Not too bland either, unlike the base model of the current-generation Jetta. The new Fusion may look fresh but the face exudes a prominent impression as if it's saying "I'm bada**" to me, or something along the lines of that. Too much vibe for the looks of an everyday sedan.


Volkswagen Jetta SE (US-Spec) vs. Hyundai Elantra Limited (someone posted this before my post of GT3 racing cars, but I haven't answered it)

I'm never really intrigued in Hyundai and I'm more into VW, but the current Jetta models seem to be not so good. (excluding the GLI variant, which actually I've been thinking of getting) Some auto journalists even say that the current Jetta is not even as good as the previous Jetta. Too much cost-cutting involved. I'll take the Elantra. Hyundai now is a much better automaker than it was ten years ago, anyway. No need to worry about its build quality.


GT3-spec racing cars to race in the 2012 FIA GT3 European Championship (my post)

First of all, I'd actually get the DBRS9 out of the thinking. Even though it looks terrific, Aston Martin and Prodrive hadn't really been upgrading it over the years. I think it's outdated and it's unlikely to win races when put against the newer cars.

I kinda doubt the capability of the Vantage GT3 either. Yes, it's more up-to-date than the DBRS9, but, still...not convinced

I have a lot of trust for the R8 LMS. Often ended up near the front of the grid and it seems to be a very well-balanced machine, judging from its road-going counterpart. (I know they're different in the end; the R8 LMS doesn't even have the four-wheel drive system which was in the road-going R8s that were praised for their all-round maneuverability, but I believe they have some connections) I suppose it's easier for drivers of varying skills and experiences to extract the maximum potential of this car than the others in the list.

But, anyway, at the end of 2011, Audi announced the more updated R8 LMS ultra. It should have the driving characteristics of the original R8 LMS but with every little bit made better, eh? A prime contender to be chosen as the team's machine.

Alpina B6 GT3 - interesting, but...no. If I didn't remember wrong it was quite competitive at the beginning of one of the 24 Hours Nürburgring races, but it dropped places towards the end.

BMW Z4 GT3 - looks sensational! One of the best-looking in the list, and it had been rather successful too. I would consider this.

Sareni United Chevrolet Camaro GT3 - I don't really have faith in it. They could have gotten it right, but using a muscle car as the basis for a GT racing machine doesn't sound good, even though this racing version is stripped down and fitted with such intense aerodynamic package.

Ferrari 458 Italia GT3 - to me it's got the best look, but, yes, I can't decide from looks. However, it had won a race in the 2011 season and the driver who drove that winning car went on to get the drivers' title. I would consider this.

Matech-Ford GT3 - it's got looks that hark back to its Ferrari-eating ancestor. But this is not the 1960s. Plus, I'm not too familiar with its competition history either.

McLaren MP4-12C GT3 - I'm very convinced about its capability. But I hadn't seen much of it being utterly successful before 2012. Perhaps better to leave it first?

Mercedes-Benz SLS AMG GT3 - it was competitive in the 2011 24 Hours Nürburgring and a team that ran these cars won the 2011 GT3 season. I would consider it.

Nissan GT-R Nismo GT3 - well, if this was a racing series with the road-going models, this would sound like a very good choice. But somehow its GT3-spec racing variants weren't very successful. Not convincing.

Porsche 911 GT3 R (997) - who would not consider a 911 as a racer? No need to discuss its capabilities in any way here.

Reiter Lamborghini Gallardo LP600 GT3 - it could get near the front but Lamborghini as a whole never really cared much about racing. I wouldn't race it. Yes, this racing version is more of Reiter's work, but I never heard the previous Reiter Gallardo winning often anyway.



In the end, after some more thinking, I would get the R8 LMS ultra for the team!
 
Volkswagen Passat TDI SEL vs. Ford Fusion Hybrid Titanium - Fusion. Mainly because hybrid (TDI isn't bad though) and because it looks better.

Jaguar XK 4.2 (low mi.) vs. Mercedes-Benz SL55 AMG - The Jaguar isn't even an R and the Merc is an AMG. I'm going with the Merc.
 
Totally agree, it's sad that some people dont consider them. We get the Cruze and Epica over here and I think they're good.

Now, Jaguar XK 4.2 (low miles) ...
xk-lead.jpg

Or Mercedes SL55?
sl55amg.jpg

Both are wonderful GT cars with good power and a relative bargain now, cant lose either way.:)
'

Merc! My CLK 55 AMG has similar wheels, too! :D
 
The Jag vs Merc was tough, but after thinking about it, I'm definitely choosing the SL55 AMG. I love AMG!
 
XK VS SL55

I'm not too keen on either of these. From the get-go, I always thought the Jaguar looked a little cheap almost, especially from the rear, though the most recent facelift is very nice. The original XK has always looked more Jaguarish, somehow. It looks more unique, no other vehicle quite looks like it. I think the interior looks bland as well. Though I used to like them, I find the R230 SL to be boring these days, the exterior isn't all that interesting, and the interior while nicer than the Jaguar is still sort of bland these days. I much prefer the new SLS-inspired interior and I even like those new squarish headlights. This comparison isn't quite fair though, an XKR would be more fit, though even then I'd still take the SL55, because I'm just not that fond of the pre-facelift, second generation XK.

2005 Audi Allroad 2.7T - 62,500 Miles - $22,000

Audi-allroad_quattro_V8_4.2_2005_photo_01.jpg


2008 Volvo XC70 3.2 - 42,000 Miles - $22,000

Volvo-XC70_2008_photo_1b.jpg
 
That's hard! Both are nice, but I've a feeling that the volvo is just a bit better, so XC70 it is.
 
The volvo is newer but the allroad is cooler. Audi it is. I don't think I'm attracted to the recent volvo vehicles (with the exception of the polestar ones) so yeah they get pretty much discarded automatically.

Now a volvo that I think is pretty cool but sadly we never got the Manual tranny
850R 1 owner 80K miles great condition and auto tranny
30592334452.342168332.IM1.05.565x421_A.562x421.jpg

VS
E36 M3 sedan with an auto transmission 122K miles in good condition and also auto transmission.
30595411192.342071353.IM1.04.565x421_A.565x377.jpg


This was a very hard choice for me, which would have been muuuuuuch easier if the M had a manual, I'll still go E36 though.
 
For my Comparo of XK vs SL55, I wanted to gauge the appeal of the non R Jaguar, but I guess power reigns supreme at the end of the day. :)

Personally I'd have the Jag. Been in one and had a chance to prod the gas good.
Love the way it looks, sounds and power is adequate.
Lotta leather and luxury too though the plastic on some parts dosent match the rest of the interior.

I'd take the Volvo XC70 vs the Audi Allroad (newer, more handsome imo and I love Volvo interiors).

My choice would be the Volvo 850R vs the E36 M3 (Rare and represents a period when Volvo went touring car racing. Good sleeper is just a bonus. And I find it's boxy-ness appealing)
 
Passat TDI vs Fusion Hybrid
Gee Doog, I wonder where you came up with that idea :p But seriously, I'd go with the Passat. Better gas mileage and more reasonable looks. I'm also not a fan of that My Ford Touch stuff.

Jag XK vs Mercedes SL55
I'd go with the Mercedes in a heartbeat. I've never been a Jag person.

Audi Allroad vs Volvo XC70
Volvo. My family used to own a Volvo V50 and we loved it. I've had a soft spot for Volvos since.

Volvo 850R vs E36 M3
Again, Volvo. If the M3 was a manual, I would've chosen it.
 
Volvo vs Audi - Audi because I like Audis.

Volvo vs BMW - Volvo because that BMW looks dated in white with those wheels plus, the Volvo is more rare.
 
-> Yup, everythings flying now...

XK 4.2 v SL55 -> I've never got attached to the XK at all ever since, so the SL55 for me.

Allroad 2.7T v XC70 3.2 -> Charming as the Allroad might be. I just don't want to deal those suspension problems thats been plauging all 1st gen A6 Allroads. I'd pick the XC70.

850 R v M3 -> Both auto? Neither of them then...buuuuut the 850 R has that collector/car show presence to it.

:)
 
850R VS M3

If the 850R were a wagon this would be much easier, because this is one of those rare cases where I actually prefer the wagon to the sedan. As a sedan, the 850R doesn't quite work for me. I think it's nice, but I don't think it's right. The overall design is too boxy and traditional for what is quite a good sports sedan I hear. It looks a little too gussied up, or tacked on, but still not a bad looking car. I'm not keen on the squarish interior though. The E36, while dated, is still not a bad looking car, and old BMWs are quite appealing. Not to mention the E36 is regarded as one of the best Bimmers, right up there with the E30 and E46 and E39, which is no small thing. Provided it's in good shape I'd readily take it and use it as a daily driver (I hope I'm not paying the insurance), though I'd have to get a new sideskirt for it; the stock ones just look weird.

2013 Honda Fit Sport - Brand New - Approximately $17,000

2012_Honda_Fit_Sport_--_11-10-2011.jpg


2010 Honda Civic LX-S - 4,000 Miles - $17,000

honda-civic-facelift-2009-1.jpg
 
I'll have the 850r only because im not a fan of the e36 shape.

And il take the jazz/fit. The new civic looks funny. Il stick with the original ones like the ek/eg/ef/ea
 
Last edited:
The Vanishing Boy
^ I've driven the F30 328i Sport, it was a very decent kit! So decent infact you wouldn't mind the 335i anymore! I think the F35 M3, would be very good. But being an E46 M driver, the last M3 I will consider would be the E90 M sedan...I see it as the (somewhat) true successor to the E39 M5. ;)

Hmmm.... Gotta drive one soon then, I remember when the 335i was the best one up till the F30 328i Sport. Even with this guy, I want to see the other "semi-M3" aka 335i would feel :). And after what I heard about the E90 Sedan in terms of power and performance, you and alot of other people are right about the E39 M5's successor is the E90 Sedan. The car's can be a monster while being somewhat civil. Which is a nice balance when compared to the C63 AMG, but the Benz is something else though. ;)


The Vanishing Boy
On the contrary, while I don't like the regular F06/F12/F13. I really do like the the F06 M6, so much that I'd pick the M6 GC over the F10 M5!

^ I'm sorry, but I would never pick the E63/64 M6, ever. ;)

Well different strokes for different folks though. But the E63/64 is somewhat sleek and intriguing in my eyes though. Maybe it's the car's eyes (headlights).

Back on topic:

Passat vs. Fusion: I have heard good things about the cars, I'll take both though.

XK 4.2 vs. SL55 AMG: The AMG wins hands down! Let's try to give it a upgrade here, maybe 650hp?

A6 Allroads vs. Volvo: I'll pass on these two.

Volvo 850R vs. M3 E36: Tough choice here, I like them both....... I'll take them both. :D

Fit Sport vs. Civic LX: Give me the Fit Sport and some extra cash to modify one. Been thinking about building a Type S Fit or a Type R version since one of my friends have a Fit.
 
Back