Would you rather?

  • Thread starter motortrend
  • 22,046 comments
  • 1,101,340 views
For the long as hell list that Vspec decided to make; The 1996 Dodge Viper GTS, it's one of my favorite cars of all time. 2nd Place: Ford GT & 3rd Place:Porsche 911 GT2 (993)
 
Silvia v Celica GT-Four- Gimme the GT-Four because rally car. And I've always loved them.

For the next one, give me the Supra. First of all, 2JZ and also would be easy to maintain especially compared to the others. And it looks cool.
 
Honda Integra Type-R (DC2) vs. Honda Civic Type-R (EK9)

I'd rather have the EK9

Dodge Viper GTS vs. Chevrolet Corvette Z06 (C5) vs. Shelby Series 1 vs. Ford GT vs. Nissan Skyline GTR V-Spec II Nur R34 vs. Toyota Supra Twin Turbo JZA80 MK4 vs. Mitsubishi 3000GT VR-4 vs. Honda NSX-R NA2 vs. Porsche 911 GT2 993 vs. Venturi 400GT vs. Lotus Esprit V8 GT SE

This is a huge list of awesome cars, but I'd rather have the Ford GT

Would You Rather

2006 Bentley Continental Flying Spur USED/59,148 MILES/$72,900
32482840680.351281023.IM1.30.565x421_A.565x378.jpg


Link To Actual Car: http://www.autotrader.com/cars-for-...EDAN&listingId=351281023&listingIndex=5&Log=0

OR

2014 Mercedes-Benz CLS550 NEW/MSRP:$72,100
2013_mercedes-benz_cls-class_sedan_cls550_fq_oem_2_500.jpg
 
That is tough. The Bentley has more presence and maybe more luxurious, but the Mercedes is new and it's not like it blends in or has a crappy interior... CLS550 for me. Would be an easier choice if it was an AMG.
 
1967 Ford Mustang GT390

Engine: 390ci (6.4L) V8
Horsepower: 320 @ 4,800rpm
Torque: 427lb-ft @ 3,200rpm

173149_6a9a2eddb5_low_res.JPG



vs


1967 Pontiac Firebird 400

Engine: 400ci (6.6L) V8
Horsepower: 325 @ 4,800rpm
Torque: 410lb @ 3,600rpm


67firebird-red-rr800c.jpg
 
Benz. This CLS is a rare case when I prefer a new car rather than an older one.

Mustang. If the Firebird would be a Camaro, this would be a tougher choice for me, but I like Pontiacs less, I don't know why.
 
1967 Ford Mustang GT390

Engine: 390ci (6.4L) V8
Horsepower: 320 @ 4,800rpm
Torque: 427lb-ft @ 3,200rpm

vs

1967 Pontiac Firebird 400

Engine: 400ci (6.6L) V8
Horsepower: 325 @ 4,800rpm
Torque: 410lb @ 3,600rpm

The Firebird looks like a Camaro... anyways, I'll go for the Bird;-)
 
-> ...
Okay, so all these are brand new and around 70-80K Euros:

RS4

RS5

S6

S7

A8

^ I could automatically pick the RS4 (especially the Avant you posted there), but it doesn't feature a M/T, so the RS5 it is.


Okay, would you rather have the Ford Escort RS Cosworth or Audi RS2?
^ Why wouldn't I pick the RS2!?

Audi (quattro) + Porsche (tune) + Avant = Perfection!


1993 Ford F-150 SVT Lightning 5.8L

Horsepower: 240
Torque: 340

vs

1990 Chevrolet Silverado 454 SS 7.5L

Horsepower: 230
Torque: 385
^ I rarely see a 454, so that is my choice!


1990 Lamborghini Diablo

OR

1991 Ferrari 512 TR
^ As much as I adore the Testarossa, I like to be scared :censored:less. So I pick the Diablo VT.


2013 Infiniti JX35 3.5L V6, AWD, MSRP: $42,650

OR

2013 Toyota Sequoia SR5 5.7L V8, 4WD, MSRP: $42,455
^ Not everyone will agree with me here, but I'll pick the Sequoia. I like purpose built vehicles and I've driven it (it drives more like a Sienna than a Tundra). What you placed in the comparo was the RWD so I adjusted it for a fair fight.


Okay, here's my next one:

Mercedes-Benz C 63 AMG Coupe or BMW M3 e92 Coupe
^ I'd pick the E92 simply because I can opt with a M/T. :indiff:


I'm back with another one, the theme is once again german sport coupes from the same manufactures:

Mercedes-Benz 190e Evolution II or BMW M3 Sports Evolution (e30)
^ I pick the E30 hands down, as this specific car will be on the manga I'm writing! :D


Heres one....


2014 Ford F-150 4x4 Tremor

Engine: 3.5L EcoBoost V6
Horsepower: 365
Torque: 420 lb-ft

2004 Ford F-150 2WD SVT Lightning

Engine: 5.4L Triton V8 Supercharged
Horsepower: 380
Torque: 450 lb-ft
^ I'd pick the Tremor easy, I just love that EcoBoost! And more practical as a daily driver.


2013 Ford Mustang Boss 302 or 2013 BMW M3 GTS
^ BOSS 302. I drive cars to have fun, not to stress my self for that 00:00:001 off my clock. Plus M/T is a huge bonus! :)


2002 Ferrari Enzo

OR

1993 McLaren F1
^ Silly dude, Enzo is for kids! The Mac is the real Daddy! Pointless comparison IMHO. :indiff:


Another super saloon showdown;

1996 BMW M5

vs

1996 Jaguar XJR

vs

1993 Lotus Carlton

vs

1995 Audi S6
^ The Audi is too sterile (and ugly). The Jaaaagggg only belongs to Beverly Hills. The E34 M5 while special, it lacks balls somewhat. The Carlton is way more special, faster, and menacing!


That said, let me come up with a new one (I hope)...

318 ti

or

Cosworth Escort
^ Unfair comparo IMHO. But the Cossie wins this one...unless...

BMW-M3-Compact-E36.jpg


bmw-e36-m3-compact-655x482.jpg


M3-ti-article-2-655x893.jpg


:sly:


1965 Pontiac GTO]

OR

1968 Dodge Charger
^ GTO easy! Sure the Charger is sexy, but the GTO simply wants to kick you bottom!


Anyway; Nissan Silvia Spec R Aero (S15) or Toyota Celica GT-Four (ST205)
^ S15 Silvia no doubt. The Celica simply looks so wrong somewhat despite on what it can do...


Honda Integra Type-R (DC2) vs Honda Civic Type-R (EK9)
^ The ITR easy, simply because I used to own an Integra ('92 DB2 GS-R).


Here is mine WYR, but it's gonna be a long and tough one. Since I'm on my iPod, it's gonna be kinda long, so bare with me....


Dodge Viper GTS SR-II

vs.

Chevy Corvette Z06 C5

vs.

Shelby Series 1

vs.

Ford GT

vs.

Nissan Skyline GTR V-Spec II Nur R34

vs.

Toyota Supra Twin Turbo JZA80 MK4

vs.

Mitsubishi 3000GT VR-4

vs.

Honda NSX-R NA2

vs.

Porsche 911 GT2 993

vs.

Venturi 400GT

vs.

Lotus Esprit V8 GT SE
^ The NSX-R without even thinking twice or thrice, such an underrated car with amazing results! My 2nd pick would be the 993 GT2, then the Ford GT(44), and lastly the Venturi. ;)
 
Charger vs GTO: Charger. It has more presence.

Silvia vs Celica: Celica for me. It has better point-to-point pace

DC2 vs EK9: I'll have the DC2 because it has more sporting character. The EK9 is just another generic 90's hot hatch.

Big selection: I'll have the GT without question.

GT390 vs Firebird: I'll take the Mustang because Bullitt and Steve McQueen.

Bentley vs Merc: Bentley. It's more luxurious, more powerful and way faster.
 
Last edited:
Benz. This CLS is a rare case when I prefer a new car rather than an older one.

Mustang. If the Firebird would be a Camaro, this would be a tougher choice for me, but I like Pontiacs less, I don't know why.

I've always prefered the Pontiac to the Camaro honestly.
 
1967 Ford Mustang GT390 vs 1967 Pontiac Firebird 400: I have always had a soft spot for 60´s Mustangs and their styling.

2006 Bentley Continental Flying Spur vs 2014 Mercedes-Benz CLS550: The Bentley is more special but its pretty old and has pretty high miles. I have never liked the CLS but in the other hand its brand new. Hmm, this is hard although i like the Bentley my brain says take the CLS.
 
Rage Racer
GTO vs. Charger
Charger! An epic legend. GTO is actually a legend too, but not as epic as Charger IMO.

Silvia vs. Celica
S15. The drifting legend. :bowdown:
And speaking about 4WD cars, I'd choose something better than the GT-Four.

Honda Integra Type-R (DC2) vs Honda Civic Type-R (EK9)
Integra

VspecZR1GT2RS89
DC2 Integra vs. EK9 Civic Type R: Tough one, eh? Well I'll go with the DC2 and build that B18C up!

Here is mine WYR, but it's gonna be a long and tough one. Since I'm on my iPod, it's gonna be kinda long, so bare with me....

Dodge Viper GTS SR-II

vs.

Chevy Corvette Z06 C5:

vs.

Shelby Series 1:

vs.

Ford GT:

vs.

Nissan Skyline GTR V-Spec II Nur R34:

vs.

Toyota Supra Twin Turbo JZA80 MK4:

vs.

Mitsubishi 3000GT VR-4:

vs.

Honda NSX-R NA2:

vs.

Porsche 911 GT2 993:

vs.

Venturi 400GT:

vs.

Lotus Esprit V8 GT SE:

Me, I'll go with the R34, because RB26. The Viper comes 2nd and Supra 3rd.
*scrolls down, sees the first four. Ponders on which one. Accidentally scrolls down further to see his all time favorite cars... WHY?!?!?!?!?*
Anyways, Supra first, then Venturi, then the Glorified Beetle.

Xavier2342
Honda Integra Type-R (DC2) vs. Honda Civic Type-R (EK9)

I'd rather have the EK9

Dodge Viper GTS vs. Chevrolet Corvette Z06 (C5) vs. Shelby Series 1 vs. Ford GT vs. Nissan Skyline GTR V-Spec II Nur R34 vs. Toyota Supra Twin Turbo JZA80 MK4 vs. Mitsubishi 3000GT VR-4 vs. Honda NSX-R NA2 vs. Porsche 911 GT2 993 vs. Venturi 400GT vs. Lotus Esprit V8 GT SE

This is a huge list of awesome cars, but I'd rather have the Ford GT

Would You Rather

2006 Bentley Continental Flying Spur USED/59,148 MILES/$72,900

Link To Actual Car: http://www.autotrader.com/cars-for-sale/vehicledetails.xhtml?zip=85024&endYear=2006&vehicleStyleCodes=SEDAN&showcaseOwnerId=83093&startYear=2005&firstRecord=26&engineCodes=12CLDR&engineCode=12CLDR&searchRadius=500&bodyStyleCodes=SEDAN&listingId=351281023&listingIndex=5&Log=0

OR

2014 Mercedes-Benz CLS550 NEW/MSRP:$72,100
Flying Spur
Slashfan
1967 Ford Mustang GT390

Engine: 390ci (6.4L) V8
Horsepower: 320 @ 4,800rpm
Torque: 427lb-ft @ 3,200rpm

vs

1967 Pontiac Firebird 400

Engine: 400ci (6.6L) V8
Horsepower: 325 @ 4,800rpm
Torque: 410lb @ 3,600rpm

Firebird, cuz Pontiac.
 
2006 Bentley Continental F.S. vs 2014 Mercedes-Benz CLS550; I think I'll go with the CLS. I'm starting to really like the Mercs.

1967 Ford Mustang GT 390 vs 1967 Pontiac Firebird 400; Mustang GT.
 
'Stang, no question

2013 Ford Fusion Gen6 Marcos Ambrose Ford
13-INDY-9.jpg

OR
2012 Ford Fusion Gen5 Marcos Ambrose Ford
12-CMS2-9.jpg

OR
2013 Ford Mustang Nationwide Marcos Ambrose Ford (650 HP 3200 lbs.)
nascar-montreal-ambrose.jpg
 
Pontiac GTO vs. Dodge Charger - GTO, one of my favorites. I like the Charger, but not as much.

Nissan Silvia Spec-R Aero vs. Toyota Celica GT-Four - If I could get my hands on a Silvia, I would. So that.

Honda Integra Type-R vs. Honda Civic Type-R - If it's that Civic, then Civic. If it's stock, Integra.

Dodge Viper GTS vs. Chevrolet Corvette C5 vs. Shelby Series I vs. Ford GT vs. Nissan Skyline GT-R V-Spec Nur II vs. Toyota Supra TT vs. Mitsubishi 3000GT VR-4 vs. Honda NSX-R vs. Porsche 911 GT2 vs. Venturi 400GT vs. Lotus Esprit V8 GT SE - Between the Viper, GTR, Supra, NSX, and Esprit, I'm gonna go with the R34 (although they're illegal here.)

Bentley Continental Flying Spur vs. Mercedes-Benz CLS550 - CLS, the Bentley has too much bling for me.

Ford Mustang GT390 vs. Pontiac Firebird - Bird, easy.

Ford Fusion Gen6 vs. Ford Fusion Gen5 vs. Ford Mustang - Fusion Gen6, I just like the styling better.

United%20States.png

2006 Ford GT
ford-gt-05.jpg


United%20Kingdom.png

2012 Aston Martin Vanquish
1024px-Vanquish_%287494591756%29.jpg


Japan.png

2010 Lexus LFA
2012_lexus_lfa_press3.jpg


Germany.png

2006 Porsche Carrera GT
Porsche-Carrera-GT-ale1152-25059893-1200-960.jpg


Italy.png

2013 Ferrari 458 Spider
800px-Ferrari_458_Spider.jpg
 
Last edited:
Oh man, that is really tough. It's a complete tie for me between the Vanquish and LFA, with the Carrera GT and 458 close behind.
 
Jahgee1124
'Stang, no question

2013 Ford Fusion Gen6 Marcos Ambrose Ford

OR
2012 Ford Fusion Gen5 Marcos Ambrose Ford

OR
2013 Ford Mustang Nationwide Marcos Ambrose Ford (650 HP 3200 lbs.)
Umm..... umm.... aaah... *eenie meenie meiny moe* 2013 Ford Mustang Nationwide Marcos Ambrose Ford.
GranTurismo916
Pontiac GTO vs. Dodge Charger - GTO, one of my favorites. I like the Charger, but not as much.

Nissan Silvia Spec-R Aero vs. Toyota Celica GT-Four - If I could get my hands on a Silvia, I would. So that.

Honda Integra Type-R vs. Honda Civic Type-R - If it's that Civic, then Civic. If it's stock, Integra.

Dodge Viper GTS vs. Chevrolet Corvette C5 vs. Shelby Series I vs. Ford GT vs. Nissan Skyline GT-R V-Spec Nur II vs. Toyota Supra TT vs. Mitsubishi 3000GT VR-4 vs. Honda NSX-R vs. Porsche 911 GT2 vs. Venturi 400GT vs. Lotus Esprit V8 GT SE - Between the Viper, GTR, Supra, NSX, and Esprit, I'm gonna go with the R34 (although they're illegal here.)

Bentley Continental Flying Spur vs. Mercedes-Benz CLS550 - CLS, the Bentley has too much bling for me.

Ford Mustang GT390 vs. Pontiac Firebird - Bird, easy.

Ford Fusion Gen6 vs. Ford Fusion Gen5 vs. Ford Mustang - Fusion Gen6, I just like the styling better.

2006 Ford GT

2012 Aston Martin Vanquish

2010 Lexus LFA

2006 Porsche Carrera GT

2013 Ferrari 458 Spider
458 Spider.
 
Mk. II Ford Fusion Nascar vs Mk. III Ford Fusion Nascar vs Ford Mustang Nascar; It's Going to be the Mk.III Fusion for me.

Supercars: Porsche Carrera GT
 
1972 Buick Riviera

Engine: 455ci (7.5L) V8
Horsepower: 245
Torque: 380 lb-ft

72_Buick_Riviera_DV_05_BR_016.jpg


vs

1973 Mercury Montego GT

Engine: 460ci (7.5L) V8
Horsepower: 275
Torque: 385 lb-ft

jacksgt.jpg
 
Back