Would you rather?

  • Thread starter Thread starter motortrend
  • 22,046 comments
  • 1,272,556 views
BMW M4 vs Audi RS5 - I will take the RS5, modern BMWs disappoint me. The styling is just out of the window and M cars just aren't drivers' cars anymore. Audis have always been in my good book though, and their styling has gradually improved over the years. Audi it is.

1. RS5
2. M4
 
BMW M4, in Estoril Blue please. Why? Because the M4 is RWD, it has a straight 6, and it's vastly better looking. The Audi is just too bland and generic, and not as good to drive.
 
Ooh really? I thought it had a v8 from the e90
 
Golf R, it looks so much better and would probably be a bit more civilised. Plus, AWD.

NSU Ro80! :drool: So cool.

Golf VI R. Faster, and probably just as nice.

RS5. The M4 is hideous and awful and kill it with fire.
 
Conbon14
Ooh really? I thought it had a v8 from the e90
Click to expand...

BMW is ditching the V8 from the old M3 and going back to straight-6 power for the M4
 
BMW M4 VS Audi RS5

I'd take a C63. :lol:

But seriously, I'd take the RS5, simply because saying M4 doesn't sound right compared to saying M3. Also, the M4's interior looks the same as it does in a 1 series!
 
5 Cars vs. A perfect world - The 2nd choice, I don't think anyone is evil enough to pick cars instead of thinking of the whole world...

Results:
1. Earth
2. 5 Cars

Volvo 480 vs. Volvo 340 GL - The 480, the 340 would probably be a pain to maintain.

Results:
1. Volvo 480
2. Volvo 340 GL

Volkswagen Golf R vs. Ford Focus RS - 2 of the best modern hatches, if not the best. This is going to be hard...but I'll pick the R because it's more of a sleeper, while the RS just completely shows everything off (which I kind of like, though).

Results:
1. Volkswagen Golf R
2. Ford Focus RS

5 Cars vs. World - Still the 2nd choice.

Results:
1. World
2. 5 Cars

Daf 66 vs. NSU Ro80 - Easily the Ro80, because rotary.

Results:
1. NSU Ro80
2. Daf 66

Volkswagen Golf VI R vs. Volkswagen Golf VII Performance Pack - The Golf VI, the VII looks too futuristic.

Results:
1. Volkswagen Golf VI R
2. Volkswagen Golf VII Performance Pack

BMW M4 vs. Audi RS5 - That M4 looks like they threw the F30 M3 in the garbage, took it out, and decided to call it the M4. So I'll take the RS5.

Results:
1. Audi RS5
2. BMW M4
 
BMW M4 vs Audi RS5; I like the look of the M4, so I'll talke it over the RS5.
 
Golf GTI over Golf R. The GTI is probably more fuel efficient.

I'll take the M4, if I really have to have either.

citroen-ds-1971.jpg


or

jaguar-mkii.jpg
 
Oh you're kidding. That's impossible. In a pinch, I'd have the Jag, even though it's objectively much worse.
 
I'll have the Mk2 Jag over the DS. The Jag is just that much cooler, plus it even raced in the early days of British Touring Cars. The DS is only good for comfort.
 
Mk.VI VW Golf R vs Mk.VII VW Golf GTI; the MK.VI Golf R.

Citroen DS vs Jaguar Mk.II; The Jaguar, I like the look of it more than the citroen. Also, because it raced in the early days of British Touring Car racing.
 
New Jaguar XF, 240 bhp diesel V6, well equipped, ~£40,000

12_jaguar_xf.jpg


Or

Jaguar MK II 3.8 Manual, £30,000 plus ~£10,000 for the ineveitable maintenance and repairs.

$(KGrHqF,!rMFEOjO)qfiBRJi+eLqO!~~_12.JPG
 
I'll have the XF as well.
 
Jaguar XF V6 Diesel vs Jaguar Mk.2 3.8L MT; The XF, because it's easier to live with.
 
Neither, if I had to pay for them.

I could probably afford a 2000 Ford Fiesta or something if I REALLY wanted a car, but I can make do with saving money and sticking to my bicycle and the train! (Or hitching a lift with someone else, of course!)
 
Zyla
We live in America, so we'd be paying in dollars. And I'll take the XF diesel.
Click to expand...

"We" will very shortly be "you."
 
Roger the Horse
Neither, if I had to pay for them.

I could probably afford a 2000 Ford Fiesta or something if I REALLY wanted a car, but I can make do with saving money and sticking to my bicycle and the train! (Or hitching a lift with someone else, of course!)
Click to expand...

I think he means if you had the money for either car, would you buy either?
 
If I had the money, the XF, out of the two, but really if I had that money I'd have better things to use it on than a luxury car. I'd just buy a Skoda.
 
Citroen DS vs. Jaguar MkII - I love the DS, but I love the Jaguar a bit more.

Results:
1. Jaguar MkII
2. Citroen DS

Jaguar XF vs. Jaguar MkII - XF, easier to maintain.

Results:
1. Jaguar XF
2. Jaguar MkII
 
The Mkii is a legend and I'll have that. I also have a soft spot for older cars, as good as the XF is. It's close but that's my choice.
 
Sexy Citroen vs. Jaguar something: I'll have the sexy Citroen. That thing is just sexy. The Jag is just meh.

XF v. another meh Jag: I'll have the XF. Simply because it will be easier and nicer to have.
 
GTI, M4, old Jag, and XF.
 
1991 Subaru Rex VX Supercharged
3rd_Subaru_Rex_1.jpg


or

1997 Daihatsu Mira TR-XX Avanzato R
Daihatsu_Mira_TR_-XX_012.jpg


If you want to pick neither, just skip the question.
 
Daihatsu. It's newer, for starters. Looks better, and isn't Daihatsu owned by Toyota?
 
Back