Would you rather?

  • Thread starter Thread starter motortrend
  • 22,046 comments
  • 1,114,684 views
I'd love to own a bike and don't like the cr-z that much but I would find 3 of the same bikes useless and impractical so I'd have to go with the CRZ
 
I'd love to own a bike and don't like the cr-z that much but I would find 3 of the same bikes useless and impractical so I'd have to go with the CRZ

You can do what you want with the other 2, it's just that for the price of 1, you'd get an old Accord, so I had to make it fair somehow.
 
Bopop4
You can do what you want with the other 2, it's just that for the price of 1, you'd get an old Accord, so I had to make it fair somehow.

In that case the bikes sell 2 buy an e36M and keep one, much better than a crz
 
Yeah, that would be a good idea.
I should've made the bike in question this though.
051011top-i.jpg

:drool: :drool: :drool: :drool: :drool: :drool: :drool: :drool: :drool: :drool: :drool:
 
Luminis
Well:

Brand new 2012 Toyota GT86 (27,000€)

vs.

Used 2007 Subaru Impreza WRX STI (40,000 miles, 27,000€)

Ugh...... Ummm........ The lightweight, RWD and fun to drive 86 or the AWD, boxer flat 4 and STi built Imprez.................. Both please! :D

gamerdog6482
Yawn. We need a new one! How about Nissans galore!
Infiniti G37:

Nissan 370Z:

Another one?!? But since one is more luxury and the other one sport. I'll take the G37 this time. I've heard the VQ37 in the G37 and it sounds amazing.

Tahli462
BMW X5 (E70)

Vs.

Infiniti FX37

I'll take the X5 since I like this BMW SUV. The newer ones are meh :yuck:.

Dooglers8
Audi Q5

BMW X3

Mercedes-Benz GLK

Lexus RX

Volvo XC60

Acura RDX

I'll take the Benz GLK and modify into a beast.

gamerdog6482
How about...

Ford GT40 road car, or

Ford GT. Take your pick!

Ugh, another one plagues me?! :crazy::lol:

A classic GT vs the new GT........ GIVE ME BOTH! :D

Jahgee1124
New Lancia Stratos

vs.
Brad Keselowski Special Dodge Challenger 392

I'd take the Challenger, because the Stratos is a disgrace to the classic one.

Hmmm.... I love the Challengers but a Stratos? Espically the new one......... Even though I don't like the front but I'll take the Stratos, because carbon fiber body. ;)

GranTurismo916
New one:

Nissan Skyline GT-R V-Spec N1 R34

or

Nissan GT-R R35

I'm about to pull my hair out...... Even though they are illegal, but I'll take the R34 N1 and have him as a track only car. I'll buy a R35 later.

Don't get me wrong, the CBAR35 are impressive in their own right (The AMS GTR and Cobb Tuning), but when a older Skyline is present, always KPGCs, DRs, HRs and R32-R34 for life! :D

Bopop4
For 25-30k. It's the battle of the gas guzzling 2-strokes versus the smart, fun little CR-Z.

3 Yamaha RZ500s, (for equal price :lol:)

A new Honda CR-Z.

I would have to go with the RZ's for this one.
The CR-Z is very appealing to me as a fun little car, but the chance to own the rare, sexy, and brutal RZ500 is too tempting.
A 90hp bike is one thing but when you make that power with 4 smoker cylinders then it gets real fun.
I'd make one into a 170mph trackbike, one into a stock streetbike, and one would be sitting in my living room. :D

(The only way that I could've gotten a good car for price compared to a bike is if the bike was an MV F4 RR, and you'd have to be stupid to pass one of those up.)

I don't like the Yamaha, but I'll take the CRZ. Ever heard of Bisimoto's, Spoon's, J's Racing's CRZs ? :sly:

But if the bike was that F4RR, different story.
 
GT40 vs GT? GT40 because original is just better, although may be a bit of trouble when I get too tall to fit in :lol:
Stratos vs Challenger? Stratos every single damn time, why in the world would I want a chintzy Dodge over it?
R34 vs R35? R34 because I've always had a soft spot for it, must be because of 2Fast2Furious but regardless.
 
R34, I am very biased against the R35.
(Goes into rant about weight and electronics...)

For 25-30k. It's the battle of the gas guzzling 2-strokes versus the smart, fun little CR-Z.

rz500-3.jpg


3 Yamaha RZ500s, (for equal price :lol:)

cr-z10.jpg


A new Honda CR-Z.

If you put any bike against any car I will take the car every last time.
 
Apparently in the rush to post in the last few hundred replies, we've all forgotten the rules.

Since the thread title is not explanatory enough I will explain how this "game" works.
1. You post a new car that is currently on sale or will be shortly and an older car which has about the same value bought used.
2. The next poster(S) can discuss why they would choose what they chose and whenever someone else comes up with an idea they go back to 1

New car vs. old car of equivalent price.

Only the FT86 vs '07 Impreza has actually hit the mark in the last 100 posts. Even just going for one or the other (given that motortrend relaxed it a bit for a Porsche example in early days), you only really get the R34 vs R35 (new vs. old) and the Testarossa vs. Countach (equivalent price) cars.

If this is just going to become a "post two cars and say which you'd prefer thread", we're going to have a bad time.
 
In that case, I'll adhere to the original rules, and offer a new 'would you rather':
New Jaguar XJL Supersport, $115,000
jaguar-xj-supersport.jpg


OR

used Bentley Arnage, 15-20,000 miles, around $100,000
bentley-arnage-t-05.jpg
 
The Jag is the better car IMO. It's more advanced, a better car to drive and just as luxurious as the Bentley.
 
Last edited:
Bikes v CRZ- I'll go with the CRZ since I don't like bikes.

Lamborghini Countach v Ferrari Tesstarossa- I'll take the Ferrari, I've never been a huge fan of the Lamborghini.

Jaguar XJL v Bentley Azure- I'll take the Bentley because I don't like the look of the Jaguar.
 
Back