Would you rather?

  • Thread starter motortrend
  • 22,046 comments
  • 1,101,340 views
I think I'd get much more use out of the Merc over the Jaaaaaag. I'd take the Merc and spend the difference on a Lotus Elise CR for weekend fun. :D
 
F-Type vs E550

The Jaaaaaaag please, I saw one today for the first time. I thought it was pretty in pictures I had seen, they aren't a patch on it in the flesh.
 
F-Type all day long.

Just looks so much better, it's a convertible for those 2 days of decent weather we have here and I can tell people....I have a Jaaaaaaaaaag.
 
Team THRT Drift
80G used car
Click to expand...

80G? As in $80,000? The Ferrari is only $2,000-$3,000 more than the Vette, not $30,000 more...


As for your comparison, I'd easily go for the F-Type. It has more power. It looks better. And that's really all that matters. :sly:
 
Fast saloon comparo:

Mercedes E63 6.2 2010

BMW M5 (F10)

Cadillac CTS-V Manual sedan 2010 (with a supercharger pulley upgrade, ~600hp)

Audi RS4 sedan (B7)

Cost no object which would you own?
 
Easily the E63. I drove a 2009 E63 (the same car as the 2010 if I'm not mistaken) and it was just absolutely amazing.
 
xXKingJoshXx
80G? As in $80,000? The Ferrari is only $2,000-$3,000 more than the Vette, not $30,000 more...

As for your comparison, I'd easily go for the F-Type. It has more power. It looks better. And that's really all that matters. :sly:
Click to expand...

Did I say 80G?????

Oops..

phil bell
Fast saloon comparo:

Mercedes E63 6.2 2010

BMW M5 (F10)

Cadillac CTS-V Manual sedan 2010 (with a supercharger pulley upgrade, ~600hp)

Audi RS4 sedan (B7)

Cost no object which would you own?
Click to expand...

Audi RS4. If the Caddie's looks weren't so hideous, I'd go for the Caddie.
 
Without a shadow of a doubt the E63. M156 is sex to the ears and while there is of course trinkets one may not want, it has everything one needs.
 
JAHHAJ
Audi RS4 as in my opinion you can't beat an Audi interior unless its a Bentley or a Roller.
Click to expand...

Or a Pagani… or a Bugatti… or a Koenigsegg… anyway. F10. Why? Because I actually like them.
 
Shouldn't it be a RS6 instead of a RS4?

Anyway, I'd take the RS4.

The E63 has that stupid foot operated parking brake so it's out.

The M5 has an electric one which frankly, is even worse.

The CTS-V is something that we don't get here.

So I'm just left by default with the RS4.
 
-> ...
phil bell
The Versa actually exists in Singapore, but with a different name...
Click to expand...
^ It's called the Tiida, right? ;)


phil bell
Besides I was on mobile and just tossing out a quick comparo, dosent matter much.
Click to expand...
^ Overall? The Fiesta has the best lineup out of all of them, from the 1.0L to the EV, up to the soon to be legendary ST. So the Fiesta is my pick.


phil bell
Fast saloon comparo:

Mercedes E63 6.2 2010

BMW M5 (F10)

Cadillac CTS-V Manual sedan 2010 (with a supercharger pulley upgrade, ~600hp)

Audi RS4 sedan (B7)

Cost no object which would you own?
Click to expand...
^ What a boring list IMHO. All sedans, yawn.

-> If the RS4 not an Avant, auto ignore for me.

-> The jackhammer is tempting, but like the Audi above, no Estate, no bueno.

-> I'd rather get the M6 Gran Coupe over the M5, so the F10 is out.

-> Like the AMG and the RS4, my CTS-V of choice is the Wagon. But even with that, I'll pick the CTS-V. This Caddy will bring you buckets of laughs more than these Deutch cruisers. Plus M/T is always a plus!
 
I would personally take the E63 actually. Its not obscenely overpowered, that na V8 is has real character, and I actually like the way it looks in and out.

The so call "slush-box" isnt bad either, lightning quick upshifts and rev matched down do the job.

Ive liked the 2010 E63 ever since it debued, it along with the C63 and CLK black are the genesis of when AMG started to make their cars genuinely dynamic imo.

 
Jaguar F-Type S vs. Mercedes-Benz E550 4MATIC - F-Type, but I'd probably total it because there'd be drool all over the pedals.

Mercedes-Benz E63 AMG vs. BMW M5 vs. Cadillac CTS-V Supercharged vs. Audi RS4 - E63, just the best car there.
 
Jazz vs. Vios vs. Versa vs. Accent vs. Fiesta
I think I'd rather have the Fiesta

'13 Clio vs. '12 2008 GTI vs. '13 Fiesta ST
I'm going to go out on whim and choose the '13 Clio just to shake things up.


'97 Mazda MX-6 LS vs. '97 Honda Prelude Si
I don't know much about these cars but I've always liked this Prelude bodystyle. The MX-6 looks ok and is probably a just as fun to drive, but I'd rather have the Prelude.

'14 Corvette Stingray vs. '08 360 Modena
I like both cars but in the long run I'd be happier with the Corvette.

'14 Jaguar Type-F V8 S vs. '14 Mercedes-Benz E550
I'll take the Jaguar in hopes that is sounds just as good as the XKR-S.

M5 (F10) vs. CTS-V (2nd Gen) vs. RS4 (B7) vs. E63 (w212)
Although the M5 has the most potential amongst it's competitors, I'd rather have the CTS-V. However, if money were no object and I could modify either car while maintaining their current engine configuration (i.e. NA vs. Forced Induction) then I'd take the M5.


Aussie Utes
Man I wish Ford and GM would have brought these trucks to the US.​

2008 FPV Falcon F6 Ute
FPV-Falcon_F6_Ute_2008_800x600_wallpaper_02.jpg


or

2007 Holden VE Ute SS V
Holden-VE_Ute_SS_V_2007_800x600_wallpaper_0e.jpg
 
FPV Falcon F6 Ute vs. Holden VE Ute SS V - I'm not into the whole Aussie mania thing, but I'll choose the FPV because it's newer and looks less bland.
 
Thanks so much for making a new comparison! I've been wanting to make one, and even tried a few times, but couldn't think of any.

I'll have the Holden. Never been a fan of Australian Fords for some reason.
 
xXKingJoshXx
Thanks so much for making a new comparison! I've been wanting to make one, and even tried a few times, but couldn't think of any.

I'll have the Holden. Never been a fan of Australian Fords for some reason.
Click to expand...

No problem, I've been lurking for the past few days and had some catching up to do... lol
 

Latest Posts

Back