Would you rather?

  • Thread starter motortrend
  • 22,046 comments
  • 1,112,695 views
1970 Dodge Charger vs 1970 Ford Mustang; I think I'll pick the charger. Mainly because I'm not a fan of the look of the 1970 mustang (the front end specifically). I wish they kept the face of the 1969 Mustang, it looked better.

Lincoln Continental vs Cadillac El Dorado; the Lincoln.
 
Bodyguard
I think you're right, I immediately noticed the rear of the car to be more boxy. It still looks good, but it's lost that flare.
Click to expand...

Based on the '65 Coupe.

1970%20Mustang%20Grande.jpg


vs fastback

009.JPG



All they did was extend the roofline.
 
Ford Mustang vs. Dodge Charger - This is a hard one for me, I love both of these cars. But I'm going to go with the Charger. If the Charger was anything else, I'd take the Mustang.

Results:
1. Dodge Charger
2. Ford Mustang

Lincoln Continental Mark IV vs. Cadillac Eldorado - Conti, I hate that generation of the Eldorado. :yuck:

Results:
1. Lincoln Continental Mark IV
2. Cadillac Eldorado

Anyway, I haven't done a comparison in a while.

2011 Ford Ranger XLT
2011-ford-ranger-2wd-reg-cab-112-xl-angular-front-exterior-view_100321916_l.jpg


or

2011 Chevrolet Colorado
2011-Chevrolet-Colorado-Truck-Work-Truck-4x2-Regular-Cab-6-ft.-box-111.3-in.-WB-Exterior.png
 
I'll take the Ranger. Both are decent though, my grandpa owns a Colorado with the I5 engine and its pretty nice. It's a bit stiff though.

The Ranger has more aftermarket, though generation depending. It is very easy to swap V8s into them and overall it's just more fun.

A more fair comparison would have been a Ranger vs S10 or Colorado vs Dakota.
 
Slashfan
Based on the '65 Coupe.

vs fastback

All they did was extend the roofline.
Click to expand...

What about the hood, spoiler and rear window accessories? I guess they could have been added by the owner...

By extending the roofline, they made the car look so much sleeker. Modern Ferraris have that same design (599 comes to mind), which shows just how revolutionary that tiny change was. The Coupe looks much older than it actually is.

2011 trucks - Is the Ford really from 2011? It looks awful! I have no idea how these cars drive and I don't care, if I bought one of them it would be for necessary hauling, not driving experience. I will take the Chevy since it looks decent.

1. Chevrolet
2. Ford
 
Bodyguard
What about the hood, spoiler and rear window accessories?
Click to expand...

Those were optional accessories you could order when you bought the car. You could get a chin spoiler too. Hood options...there was like 6. All on the order sheet.
 
Are we doing lightning rounds again?

'70 Mustang Coupe vs. '70 Charger

I'd rather have the Charger

'72 Continental vs. '72 Eldorado

I'd rather have the El dog (Eldorado)

'65 Coupe vs. Fastback

Fastback please...

'11 Ranger XLT vs. Colorado

I think someone has already posted this comparison, but I'd rather have the Colorado.
 
2011 Ford Ranger vs 2011 Chevrolet Colarado; The Ford easily.

Honda Beat vs Autozam AZ-1; the AZ-1.

Audi S6 vs Jaguar XJ; I would pick the Audi S6.
 
Autozam AZ-1 vs. Honda Beat - AZ1, easy.

Results:
1. Autozam AZ-1
2. Honda Beat

Audi S6 vs. Jaguar XJ - The Jag, the S6 is kind of boring.

Results:
1. Jaguar XJ
2. Audi S6
 
Autozam AZ-1 vs Honda Beat - I will take the Autozam, but I still dislike the fact that these cars exist. There is nothing anyone can say to make me spend actual money on these "cars". I know I'll get hate for that opinion, but meh.

1. Autozam
2. Beat

Audi S6 vs Jaguar Xj Sedan - The Jaguar has a certain degree of hoonage to it. I love that about so many cars, but not the Jag. If you want a sporty Jag, you get the XFR or XKR, not an XJ Sedan. So, these cars are made for luxury, which is why I pick the Audi. It has the nice S package, which I adore, as well as being 4WD. It knows what it is and excels at making its best aspects better.

1. Audi S6
2. Jaguar XJ Sedan


My turn, would you rather have a:

Honda Odyssey
2008_Honda_Odyssey_01.JPG



or a

Mercedes-Benz Sprinter
Mercedes_sprinter_2_v_sst.jpg


Both of these cars are massive, but they serve different purposes. Will you take the van and heavily modify it or take the minibus and leave it close to stock?
 
I'd take the huge van, and mod it to be a sleeper on the drag strip, since that's about all its good for.
 
Honda Odyssey vs. Mercedes-Benz Sprinter - Odyssey, I actually like the styling of it.

Results:
1. Honda Odyssey
2. Mercedes-Benz Sprinter

Chevrolet El Camino SS 454 vs. Chevrolet Chevelle SS 454 - Chevelle, but it depends on what year.

Results:
???
 
GranTurismo916
Honda Odyssey vs. Mercedes-Benz Sprinter - Odyssey, I actually like the styling of it.

Results:
1. Honda Odyssey
2. Mercedes-Benz Sprinter
Click to expand...

It's a Honda, of course. It's also cheaper and possibly, more reliable than the Sprinter.
 
El Camino vs Chevelle - My favourite muscle car of all time vs a similar car but with a truck's rear end? Please, give me the Chevelle. The Chevelle is also the only car that I can't decide on a colour for; maybe black with white stripes?

1. Chevelle
2. El Camino
 
Year depending I'd take the Chevelle. I'd rather hard a ranchero over an el camino.
 
Mustang vs Charger; I'll go with the Charger.

Road yachts: I'll have the Eldorado. It's probably a bit smaller and easier to drive.

Trucks: Ranger since we get it in the UK.

Kei Cars: I still hate Kei cars but I might as well have the AZ-1 for the novelty of gullwing doors.

S6 vs XJ: Audi, easily.

Vans: I'll take the Sprinter. I never liked the Odyssey.

El Camino vs Chevelle: El Camino for extra practicality.
 
Honda Odyssey vs Dodge Sprinter; The Odyssey for its styling.

Chevrolet Chevelle SS 454 vs Chevrolet El Camino SS 454; The Chevelle.
 
Slashfan
I'd take the huge van, and mod it to be a sleeper on the drag strip, since that's about all its good for.
Click to expand...

It's good for hauling things. :sly:


I'd take the van and turn it into a sleeper, and when I say sleeper, I mean camper.
 

Latest Posts

Back