Resistance is 16GB, Ted Price himself said so on his blog. It was lowered because they figured out they could convert the NTSC stuff into PAL on-the-fly, so they could remove all the PAL stuff on the disc.
That makes sense, thanks for the clarification.
And if Resistance used better compression than what they're using now and removed any other crap from the disc (like the PAL stuff), it would fit on a DVD9 real easily.
What better compression are you talking about? I had the impression they were using MPEG4, and of course this only impacts audio and video compression, not data. However, even VC-1
(SMPTE 421M), which both the XB360 and PS3 support, can not compress audio and video more than MPEG4 can.
As for multi-platform titles... I doubt they'd be going over the 8.5 GB mark.
I was under the impression that XB360's DVD-ROM only could store 7GB of data.
And even in the rare case they do, there's a little thing called disc 2.
Of the thousands of game titles released on CD & DVD, how many are 2-disc releases? In fact, how many XB360 games are 2-disc, let alone multi-disc releases? I was under the impression developers and consumers were not a fan of multi-disc game titles.
I seriously doubt Call of Duty 5 will be 15GB, or that Fatal Inertia will be 12GB, or that Assassin's Creed will be 24GB, or whatever.
Well a few months ago, prior to Resistance you also said you doubted any PS3 games would exceed the capacity of what a DVD could hold, and that it would be a long time, if ever that they would use all the space that Blu-ray provides.
Exclusive PS3 games are going to use the full potential of the PS3. They're going to use all the space they can get, just because they can.
That would be nice, but considering the developmental learning curve, time, and cost, I'm afraid not all exclusive titles will take full advantage of everything the PS3 has to offer.
With multiplatform titles, they'll probably be made so that it fits on one DVD9. I seriously, seriously doubt GTA4 will be cut down to fit on the 360. If anything, the PS3 version may not reach it's full potential.
I suspect you are probably right, or maybe a little of both, thus the PS3 version may be a little larger then the XB360 version, and maybe a few extra features. As you say, we will just have to wait and see.
BTW: What is the size difference between the PS3 and XB360 versions of
Fight Night: Round3?