- 21,286
- GR-MI-USA
- YSSMAN
- YSSMAN
YSSMANOfficial Update of YSSMAN's "Infinite Crisis"
As if Christmas Day, 2007
So, I've been doing some thinking and things are a bit tough. With near-certainty, I'm hoping to have a new car by the end of the school year, but of course there are still plenty of variables that may in fact derail that plan completely.
So, an updated list of requirements:
- Must be no more than $10,000 USD (give or take $2,500 depending)
- Looking for $300 or less collective car payment + insurance payment
- Fun-to-drive is first and foremost
- Cheap
- Fuel-friendly
- Reliable (should be higher?)
...The biggest wildcard, living in Michigan, as always is the snow...
The top two cars (thus far) have been such:
- The Subaru Forester (pre-2003?): Moderately reliable, pretty well-built, but falls short on the fuel economy and fun-to-drive factor. Insurance isn't nearly as cheap as I'd expect either, which is unfortunate. They're pretty easy to find in Michigan, which is a bonus, but I'm unsure of pre-2002 updated models. Getting into that year range gets very expensive.
- The Mazda Miata (NA & NB): For the most part, the Mazda meets every criteria. They're really cheap to buy (I've found nice, low-mileage NA models for less than $7000), really cheap to insure (less than my Jetta), cheap to fuel, cheap to fix, and overall don't require much fixing in the first place. Thing is, we've got this thing called snow, and we occasionally get a lot of it. As much as eight inches in a few hours the other night... That causes problems. BIG PROBLEMS.
====
Recent developments:
The $10K cap and the preferred $300 monthly fee, for the most part, is all that I can afford. At most. That would pretty much eliminate any kind of long-distance travel (unless I get a raise at work), and most other "non-important" things as well.
That being said, two new vehicles have recently landed in my lap:
- 2002 Honda Civic Si Hatchback: After seeing one on the highway yesterday, it got me thinking... I really don't "hate" Hondas all that much, I love the hatchback body style, and they certainly aren't that slow either. They seem to be cheap-ish to run, cost the same to insure as my car, and can be had for $9000 or less these days... That is, if you can find one unmolested.
- 1995-1998 BMW E36 328: This is Doug's suggestion, as discussed in private. The price is certainly low, and the insurance rates actually aren't that bad either. Thing is, replacement parts scare the living hell out of me, and they not being of newer generations, I'm even less knowledgeable of the cars themselves. Snow is still an issue with the RWD models, but good tires can fix that. I have no idea what gas would be like either...
- 1999-2001 BMW E46 323: I've already been yelled at for this one, but it seems like a logical step forward. See above for similar reasonings.
====
My mood changes from time-to-time, and that is unfortunate. The cars seem to be a bit consistent, and I'm still weighing my options. I just wish the damn snow wasn't this much of a problem....
I think the title says it all... The guy who normally would shop only at the GM and VW dealers is actually considering a Subaru to replace the Jetta.
What Subaru you may be wondering?
One of these:

Thats a Subaru Forester, if you didn't know...
Yes, its a fairly drastic change of pace for me. My Volkswagen has been giving me some troubles as of late (its 12 years old now), and I'm not looking to spend much money, if any at all, to keep it running. Its still a solid car and would happily go to 220K if I let it, but I'm not in the mood to make it so. So, with the weather these past few weeks, I went about making a list of cars that would be appealing to me, and consequently, the Subaru came out at (or near) the top every time.
The general listings:
- Subaru Forester
- Mazda Miata
- Mazda Protege
- Ford Focus
- Volkswagen Golf GTI VR6 MKIV
- Chevrolet Cobalt Coupe
- Chevrolet Camaro Z/28
Its tough. Insurance has to be cheap-ish (preferably less than $150 a month) and I can't afford much of a car payment either (preferably around $200). The Subaru, I've found, isn't much more to insure than my own VW. The only car that is cheaper would be the Miata (weird?). Most of the cars are fairly easy on gas, seem to be built fairly well-ish, and fit my driving style when need be. Sticks are required across the board, obviously, with a fair amount of "fun to drive" factor baked-in.
So, I dunno. So far, the Subaru sits on top. I'd love to get a 2004+ XT, but thats about $5000 more than what I want to spend right now (God knows what insurance would be like). I'm looking at 2003+ XS models (thats with the 174 BHP H4), but they're difficult to find around here with a stick.
===
So, basically, what do you think?
Are parts expensive? Are they really all that reliable (from what I've read, its usually good)? Any Subaru owners in general want to chime in?
I'm not looking to buy anything until the spring, maybe. I've got to get some bills sorted out after taxes are done, and then I'm going shopping. I've never driven a Forester, but I like the idea of it, so I may have to wait and see how I feel about it.
...Just thinking. Feel free to make suggestions...