- 7,956
- BradleyH131
Well, make that two people. Mechanicals are, imo, no better than the $5 peices of crap Dell and Acer send out with their systems. They sound (and from what limited experience I've had with them, feel) like you're typing on a 1930's typewriter, and you pay extrodinate prices for something that just purely isn't worth it. I'd happily go and pick up something like this before something like this...
For me, the lower the profile, the better (which is why I'd love to mod out a Laptop keyboard some day), and the more displays and flashy bits so I can see what's going on, the better.
People who say Mech keyboards 'sound like a type writer', need to realise that literally only one mechcanical switch type remotely sounds like a typewriter, the rest of them sound pretty similiar to any other membrane keyboard, you can also get O-Rings which make them basically silent.
This discussion is almost exactly like the headphone discussion, you can pay $150 and get a Logitech Headset which is full of lights, gadgets, microphones and ********. Or you can spend $150 on headphones from a dedicated headphone maker and get something which actually sounds good. Same thing applies with keyboards.
It basically comes down to the question of quality. I know my Mech will last 10-20 years, but I'm guessing the gimicky LCD screen on a G19 won't.