GT5 Review scores (Update :Average metacritic score)

  • Thread starter DoctorFouad
  • 1,417 comments
  • 172,705 views
From the looks of it it is pretty much given that Gamespot which gave a poor preview of the game along with Bias Gametrailers and EDGE will give this game a low score

Give me a break. There is perhaps some validity in questioning Gamespots review based on who did the play test earlier. But thats not necessarily bias, thats a clueless reviewer.

But for Edge and Gametrailers, there is no bias.

Each magazine/site has several reviewers for a start, you cant refer to any one site or publication as a collective whole as even within them reviewers are going to have different opinions.

And at the end of the day, a review is that persons opinions and feelings towards the game. There is no single game that everyone will enjoy. GT5 is sure to get bad reviews, as long as the opinions in the review are justified by the reviewer they are entirely valid. So really, who cares? Some places are going to give GT5 a great score, some average and maybe one or two a bad review. Thats life, deal with it and move on. All that matters is that you enjoy the game, right?

Petty accusations of bias just because someone doesn't rate your favorite game is childish.
 
Now this bogus reviewer will kindly explain me how comes that after being playing at forza for 3 weeks (more or less, until I could be able to best a ferrari f40 with a 4wd honda jazz) I got so bored that I had to exhume the ps2 and keep on playing at gt4. Forza is the most over rated game in history

The reviewer clearly disagrees with you. I am also sure he won't be the only one.

I myself prefer the GT series but I know plenty of people who prefer Forza. It doesn't hurt my feelings, however.
 
Don't know if this was posted already or not but it's the first part of a "pseudo-review", where the site compares the game in many points to Forza 3 and my opinion is that they failed miserably at doing that, anyways, check it out and make up your own mind about that.

http://www.4players.de/4players.php...48/70329/Gran_Turismo_5_vs_Forza_Motorsport_3

Can someone provide a rough translation? Just the main points. I'll like to know what they think.

Oelix posted the link and provided a rough translation about 60 posts above! check around post 450 - 460
 
You are mixing preference with actual physics, read the Physics of racing series and then come back and tell me it can't be modeled and is based on 'preference'.
Scaff

The one thing I notice is that this conversation revolves entirely around "physics" but not around "control". No game, of any type, ever uses purely raw controller information straight from the pad/wheel. It's generally far too noisy and unpredictable to be of much use. So anything you transmit from the controller will be filtered at a signal level, first of all, and the game will attempt to work out your intent from that. How the latter part of that happens has a gigantic impact, which can dwarf any changes you make in the physics data driving the car. It is entirely possible to construct an input filter that will make identical physical models behave in utterly different ways from the exact same input in the exact same game.
 
Are you kidding me? Gametrailers are known for being fanboys of the 360 very well. Don't know about Edge, though.
Edge is a high quality magazine but they are old school gamers who enjoy the likes of Mario.

I find most videogames tedius so I wouldn't be particularly impartial if you let me review the latest and greatest RPG or FPS.

The GT series tends to be marketed to the car enthusiast market not traditional gamers, you see the same thing on a much smaller scale with titles like iRacing.
 
Now this bogus reviewer will kindly explain me how comes that after being playing at forza for 3 weeks (more or less, until I could be able to best a ferrari f40 with a 4wd honda jazz) I got so bored that I had to exhume the ps2 and keep on playing at gt4. Forza is the most over rated game in history

Come on really? I'll admit I prefer GT and I check this forum 50 times a day but I've played Forza 3 (albeit briefly) and thought it was great. Sure its a little more on the arcade side but surely anyone with a passion for cars will get a lot of enjoyment out of it. If I had a 360 I would have definately bought it to keep me entertained while waiting for GT5 to be released
 
On this point I could not disagree more.

I've watched a good number of races in a wide range of conditions and can honestly state that some of the best ones have been in the rain.

Hell go and watch any of Senna's wet weather races or even qualifying runs and you will be witness to a degree of car control that simply goes beyond what can be shown in the dry.

I realize the point your making, but its fundamentally different than mine.

I agree. I never said you can't still see a great race in the rain under those uniquely challenging conditions.
As you describe, you may also see a display of tremendous talent and versatility in the process.
No disrespect, but you might see a great race watching cockroaches as well.

Again my point is fundamentally different.

All this I have to agree that to state that rain and adverse weather conditions have not place in racing outside of rally event is a rather narrow view of global motorsport to say the least.

Scaff

Thats not exactly what I said. Furthermore my original comment was directed to features of the game, not real racing. Also I qualified it as mostly personal preference.

But anyway by Rally I meant offroad racing or other than highspeed paved race tracks. The other exception I did say was 24hr or endurance racing ,meaning regaurdless of surface. Its expected and practically unavoidable to race in the rain if need be on these occasions.

What I did say, rephrased below, and which is still true:

It won't be close to what you would see under favorable or dry conditions wherein the power and true capabilities of the man and machine can be showcased in their designed for element.

As to narrow, maybe. But again thats my preference.
I have absolutely no desire within the confines of GT5 to race in the rain or snow, other than maybe the noted exceptions.

Given the choice of watching a race, with F1 or other high speed and power cars on a high speed track, in the rain or dry conditions, I believe the choice for most fans, would be pretty obvious.

However, to each his own.
 
Agreed. F1, the most influential racing series on earth... runs in the rain.

well, it's the biggest, not the most influential. in reality, more technologies trickle down from sports car racing to production cars than from F1 to production cars these days. that's not important to this conversation, however, because both the top level sports car series of the world and F1 race in the rain.
 
I predict ~ 91% average for GT5.

q5BPn.jpg
 
Can someone provide a rough translation? Just the main points. I'll like to know what they think.

Here you go:

(translation of 4players review so far)

cars (this refers mainly to the ultimate edition of forza with all its dlcs):
GT has the greater variety, but Forza has the higher quality. They give you more oldtimers and up-to-date cars as well as more cars from the US/EU region. GT on the contrary is too much limited to japanese cars and endless variations of the same car.
The GT cars are a little more detailed but too many are lacking a cockpit view. Forza cars have better shadows and you can paint them etc.

sound:
They are in general of extremely low quality in GT5 ("sound like a vacuum cleaner")! Premiums are a little bit better tough but still weak.

tracks:
GT is comparable to Forza in case of real courses but theirs are modeled with a little bit more precision. GT is clearly tacking the lead regarding original courses.

career:
None of the two games is offering something special but the career modes are ok.
 
Last edited:
I won't translate anything but looks like the guy only saw the negative part of it. I find this review very non-professional.
 
Hello there,

Here's a thread where we could all post official reviews of GT5.

Here's a first review, from a franch Website (famous and also a weeeeee bit unfair)
http://www.jeuxvideo.com/articles/0001/00013884-gran-turismo-5-test.htm

Hello 2005pierric

You'll see I moved your post into this existing thread. DoctorFouad's original post suggests using this thread to start collecting reviews from around the internet, and as long as people can avoid turning it into another GT/Forza argument, it'd be great to stick to that. Thanks for posting the review!
 
Ouch! That seems like a pretty harsh review. It's not that I don't agree with the written text, but the score isn't really fair. A 7/10 would be fine if you are comparing to other GT games possibly, but not as an overall score for the game compared to all other games.
 
Hello 2005pierric

You'll see I moved your post into this existing thread. DoctorFouad's original post suggests using this thread to start collecting reviews from around the internet, and as long as people can avoid turning it into another GT/Forza argument, it'd be great to stick to that. Thanks for posting the review!

no worries I hadn't noticed that thread, thanks for your action 👍 .
 
Sorry about that boys; you guys post way too quickly! Threads merged, continue discussing reviews :)
 
He "tested" the online but said it was sloppy..
What did he expected it online just got on

Yeah like every other big name game prior to the official release. Black ops was bad on day one. Dude is a clown. Wait for real reviews. dude was prob upset it was not overly easy for him, not a sim guy.
 
Hello there,



Here's a first review, from a french Website (famous and also a weeeeee bit unfair: they reviewed richard burns rally and it scored 12/20 because the reviewer, I think, found it too hard to finally have a real simulation in his hands xD). on the contrary, NFS shift got 18/20... and forza motorsport 3 17/20)
http://www.jeuxvideo.com/articles/0001/00013884-gran-turismo-5-test.htm

If a team that has worked hard for 6 years perfecting and raising the bar for the genre and they get this kind of review.What a bunch of ignorant reviewers the game is not perfect but they even don't like the gameplay .Yes I am angry these guys are supposed to be professional no wonder why you guys don't listen to reviews.
 
Back