- 24,553
- Frankfort, KY
- GTP_FoolKiller
- FoolKiller1979
so who killed laura palmer, anyway?
Bob
so who killed laura palmer, anyway?
Just to clear this up, because I am not sure how you meant this: The island is not some form of afterlife. The island is real. Only the alternate reality is part of an afterlife.
that i knew, what i want to say is that in one season , the cast make this hypothesis. I think it is where they play golf analucia is shot,...
Only in the alternate reality are they dead, because that is the afterlife. And there they are all dead because, as Christian explains, it is free of time, so there is no one technically still alive at that point. Those not in the church were either not overly important to each other, so as to be a part of their moving on, or they were not quite ready to move on yet because they needed to deal with some of their issues, like Ben and Ana Lucia.
yes i rewatched that scene to really understand it.
They explained the alternate reality: It is the afterlife, a sort of purgatory. The explanation of the time travel is not 100% clear, however the island as a whole is not explained. The reason for that is that the story was never about the island. It was about the characters.
For me this is only particialy true until season 3. After that the scientist came to the island and a lot of storytelling was about the island. I know that the main pillar is protagonist centric, but the whole story was also based on the island... that's my 2 cents, and who knows maybe the island returns with new people. LOST 2: The Hurley Initative
Because in life she killed her own son. She isn't ready to move on yet and needs Daniel in order to reach that point.
But she isn't dead yet or is she??
The story of these characters is concluded. That was the story we were being told.
Nearly all major religions have some form of purgatory-like belief. The church they were in had six different religious symbols on the stained-glass window, signifying a spiritual afterlife not constrained to any one belief.
good spotting 👍 , representing it like it really is
As for the role of the alternate reality being an afterlife, the clues were always there. Sawyer and Miles seemed like some TV cliche cops. Sun was shot just over a day after the plane landed, but Sayid did the shooting days after he landed. And then Sun was rushed into the ER as Locke was just going in for his surgery, after he had enough time to get fired, meet Hurley, get a substitute teaching job, and teach enough classes to be well liked by students. The time lines are all off and cliches were in place wherever someone was playing a role they had no real experience with. Even I suspected mid-season that the alternate reality wasn't real, but I thought it was a creation by Jacob.
Again good spotting that it is not coherrant in time. Also true that in this season all clues lead to the AR being After life. But the end of season 5 was leading more to a different time string (AR)than an afterlife, But it's all from memory so i can really rely on that
I didn't notice it so I can't comment on it.
As I pointed out earlier, the AR was timeless. No date or time was ever given for the AR. Because the plane landed we assumed it was 2004, but that was never stated. In the AR Hurley and Ben are dead. Christian says as much when he explains that some of them died a very long time after Jack.
Ok now Linus said in an interview that on the dvd there would be an epilogie (15min.) telling hurley and linus story after Jack died
One thing I like to point out to people who aren't happy with just having the characters' stories finished up: If this ending were given to us at any time during season 1, maybe even season 2, would you still feel ripped off? at that time there was no giant mythology surrounding everything. It was a story about some people stuck on an island that seemed to be slightly abnormal. It was a character-driven story about how people deal with these unusual situations. That story has been fully concluded. The story of the island began long before this story. Judging by the statue and wall symbols I would guess that it began as much as 3,000 years before Jacob was born, possibly even further back. In fact, if you want my take on what the island is, I think it is where life began on Earth. It is much older than even the Egyptian symbolism, but Egyptians discovered it and recognized it for what it is. So, they created temples and protections around it. This would explain the statute a Tawaret, the goddess of childbirth and fertility.
But hey, that's just my take. 👍👍
Ahhh i'm not alone.I'm somewhat disappointed by the ending. I was really liking the episode up until the church part, and the explanation of what the AR was. It was a bit confusing too but reading the comments in this thread made it clearer for me. Still, it wasn't the ending I was hoping for.
Is this 24?? Palmer??
That probably would explain a lot of the wierd stuff on the island. dog thoughts. The whole thing was a dream from a dog . HAHAH made me laughI found the "remembering" moments more touching than the end.Me too, and the ending (church) was a bit to short to really have a good explination (watched it again and now it's better)
Edit: Alternate ending:
![]()
This was a shoddy piece of storytelling. You see them try to fix it and direct the mythology toward Jacob, but they had gone too far for us to not have many questions. The biggest issue I have is that with their loose ends they basically said, "This is the story we are telling, and that's all you are getting." While that is legitimate, their storytelling drifted off on tangents like a five-year-old talking about his day at school.For me this is only particialy true until season 3. After that the scientist came to the island and a lot of storytelling was about the island. I know that the main pillar is protagonist centric, but the whole story was also based on the island... that's my 2 cents
Yes, in the AR everyone is dead.But she isn't dead yet or is she??
Laura Palmer's death was the great mystery that drove the story forward on Twin Peaks. Lost is often seen as this decade's Twin Peaks because of how that show dealt with alternate realms and evil beings. There was originally a Twin Peaks film featuring the last seven days of Laura Palmer's life. The show began with the discovery of her body and followed the story of the detective trying to find her killer.Is this 24?? Palmer??
Actually, yes. He became one of the spirits stuck on the island that went around whispering sweet nothings in everyone's ears. He explained that when Hurley saw his ghost/spirit/whatever, but he was short on time and stopped Hurley from asking more questions.Where is the owner of the dog (micheal?) Why didn't we see him?? Denied from heaven??
My biggest disappointment. I am telling myself that all dogs do go to heaven and he just didn't need the purgatory to move on. He and Walt both passed on without the need of crazy town.And where is Vincent. Com'on everybody loved him!!
Aaron was, sort of, there, as he was born. And Sun was pregnant, so Jeong was sort of there too.NB : none of the children died!! Araon,Micheals son, Sun's girl
Because Ben was being lied to by the MIB posing as Jacob. He was a good man at heart and was willing to aid anyone that would just be honest with him, which is why he was happy with Hurley. His only outright murder of his own free will (without manipulation), that I can remember, was Charles Widmore, and that was a revenge killing. Even then, it could be argued that Locke had manipulated Ben's emotions to make him want to kill Widmore.And why is Ben with the people. Didn't he tryed for seasons to kill and extort them?
Aaron was, sort of, there, as he was born. And Sun was pregnant, so Jeong was sort of there too.
But I didn't see Aaron in the church scene. Hmm, maybe they are innocents and move on without needing the purgatory? Or they have their own adult lives that don't rely on these main characters enough to be part of their afterlife. Remember, Christian said it was a place they all created so they could find each other. The children didn't need to find these people before moving on, I guess.
I'm having trouble recalling the situation. What season was that in?So, Christian on the island was MiB. What about that time Jack saw his father on the hospital, was that MiB too?
The only way he could leave is if he destroyed the island first, so very bad things.Did he get out of the island then? And what was the problem with him getting out of the island? What would happen if he did?
I think it was in a flashforward of Jack. He was at the hospital and heard the smoke alarm (wink, wink) beeping at the other room, so he went to check it and his father was there. Then someone interrupts him and his father dissapears.I'm having trouble recalling the situation. What season was that in?
I got the impression he needed to become mortal to be able to leave the island, and that happened when Desmond moved the stone. The island sinking seemed just like a bonus to him.The only way he could leave is if he destroyed the island first, so very bad things.
Was that when he was drunk and on drugs a lot? It could be a plot hole, but the writers would likely write it off as Jack has daddy issues and wasn't emotionally stable when he got back to LA.I think it was in a flashforward of Jack. He was at the hospital and heard the smoke alarm (wink, wink) beeping at the other room, so he went to check it and his father was there. Then someone interrupts him and his father dissapears.
He did not know that. Remember how he looked surprised when Jack punched him and he started bleeding, and Jack told him he was wrong too? I believe he was ready to go wreak some smokey havoc on the rest of civilization.I got the impression he needed to become mortal to be able to leave the island, and that happened when Desmond moved the stone. The island sinking seemed just like a bonus to him.
I'll watch it later, when I have more time.How many of these questions can you guys try to explain?