MAD CATZ Steering Wheel....If your on a BUDGET??

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lisa_Bonami
  • 66 comments
  • 12,196 views
Sohcahtoa
Dude, you TOTALLY missed the point of my post, or you didn't read it at all...

We seem to be taking turns missing each other's points.

My point is that your point doesn't seem to apply to what happens with the steering wheels we use in this electronic game. In real life you are absolutely correct, but the DFP and MC2 wheels don't seem to act like that. When driving, they both seem to only use something like 200 degrees of arc as you go around a typical course, at least with high-performance race cars.

When I borrowed a friend's DFP for a couple of evenings, I was immediately aware that I was not turning the wheel any more at racing speeds than I was with the MC2. It was, in fact, simulating the way the real cars are steered, as we can see in the in-cockpit camera views. The extra rotation was not used at all at racing speeds.

I tested the sensitivity of the wheels on Sarthe II, on the bumpy long straight, checking to see which wheel was best at tracking the white line at 230 MPH. I would say that I could be just a tiny bit more accurate with the DFP, but the MC2 was certainly good enough. If anything, though, I used less steering input on the 900-degree DFP to do it than on the 270-degree (your're right) MC2. That's backward from how they should act, but there you are.

The only time I used any more than 200 degrees of steering was when I was slowly making my way back onto the course after a spin. Otherwise, I might as well have had a DF rather than a DFP.

Once again, though, I only used my friend's DFP wheel with Le Mans cars. I never tried it on a prosaic little 90-HP sedan. Is it different with one of those?
 
I'm not even going to bother arguing this. I confess, I'm a biased DFP elitist. All I can really comment on was the huge improvement I noticed in the DFP after having the DF (or GTForce, as it used to be).

I haven't even tried the MadCatz or any of the other wheels, so I'm not really qualified to comment on them. The fact they don't have FFB is enough to put me off even trying them though. I absolutely LOVE the FFB technology, it gives the game that extra 50% fun factor because now the wheel can literally force your arms around and give you a sense that you can lose control at any moment!
 
How many LMP cars are there in GT4?

How many Purpose Built Racecars are there in GT4?

How many F1 cars are there in GT4?


Compare the total of all of those, to the normal day to day cars.


Think about how many people buy this game to only hop in the very fastest cars, and then think about how many people buy this game to drive a variety of cars they would simply never drive in real life, or have driven in real life.

Having to turn the wheel less to keep yourself on the corrected line is better, it means the wheel is giving you finer control, and is the difference between a Machete (Mad Catz Wheel) and a Scalpel (DFP) when it comes to carving up roads.

Both will get the job done...one requires more work, but gives more satisfying results, the other will suffice, but will be less accurate, and less attractive in the replays.


I wanted a Wheel because the D-pad on my Mad Catz micro controller is only so good, (much better than the Analogs though..strangely) but it doesn't give me near the fine control of a wheel.

I didn't want to buy an "Ok" wheel...

I wanted to buy the "Best" wheel.
 
Onikaze
I didn't want to buy an "Ok" wheel...

I wanted to buy the "Best" wheel.

No one on the planet can argue that that's the DFP right now. I've tried both and the DFP is in a league of it's own.
 
I thought it was worth mentioning that I got my refurbished Logitech Driving Force (the old version, not the DFP) wheel off eBay for about $30, and it works perfectly. I haven't looked recently, but at the time (about 6 weeks ago) the same seller was trying to unload lots of them. So if you're looking for a cheap wheel, but would like to have force feedback, that may be an option.

[edit] Just checked and the price has gone up a bit, but here are several with a "buy it now" price of $38.95. You could probably get it for less, though, if you were willing to place a bid and wait for the auction to end (min. bid is $20).
 
Back