North American perspective
I'm very curious to see this matched against the Bronco despite them not being quite in the same segment.
I love Straight Pipes but I gotta be honest, I'm not bothering with on-road tests of any of this new wave of offroad-capable trucks. It's just irrelevant. It's 2020, everything drives fine on-road. My 2006 Sequoia drives fine on-road.
The
identity of these new vehicles is how the drive off-road. Defender, Bronco, Wrangler and Gladiator, etc. What we need to see is a comparison of off-road hardware between Land Rover, Ford, Jeep, Toyota, et al. From prior experience and prior reviews, while Jeep obviously leads the offroad hardware game, Toyota, Ford, and LR all have competitive off-road tech although I would give the edge to Toyota and LR. How that tech combines with the hardware is a big deal though - Toyota's 4Runner TRD Pro combines a rear live axle with a rear locker
and their ATRAC traction control for the front wheels. LR offers the rear locker and traction control, but its combined with less articulation from the IRS. It might offer the best "clearance" but that comes at the cost of fully-inflated airbags which destroy articulation, relying heavily on the traction control. It
also has larger wheels than the Toyota, even in base trim, and less room for larger tires, which ultimately limits performance increases from larger tires such as air-down capability and puncture resistance.
LR is over here like "this is what we can do with technology" while Toyota and Ford are like "this is what we can do with technology
and hardware, and we left you room to make it better", and Jeep was like "we don't need all that technology because we have the gnarliest hardware
and the most room for you to improve it[/i]".
I'd like to see a brutal stock-for-stock comparison among all four of these offerings. I have a feeling the 4Runner and Defender would be dueling it out closely, although both the resale market and parts aftermarket already heavily favor the Toyota for which is the best option.
The Fast Lane recently bought a long-term base-model Defender which they'll modify and punish. It's been broken for at least 21 days so far, within 300 miles of new. Can't say I expected anything else honestly. They also intend to get a Bronco to test. They've already modified and tested several other trucks and SUVs, including the first-gen Touareg (very capable), Disco 2, LR3, Gladiator, among others.