The "Rate My Photo" thread! **Read the OP Before You Post**

  • Thread starter Thread starter MSD Drifter
  • 2,388 comments
  • 185,908 views
8/10 for the Audi R8 photo. Really nice, but the edges of the photo seem a bit too dark to me. Could be just because the sun is in my screen though:D

I'll throw some in. Don't know if they get automatically resized so I would like to know how to do that if it doesn't happen.

Just started to use the full options on the camera and I don't have photoshop. But I would like to know how you think they look and how I could improve them.

specialstageroute7j.jpg


azur5n.jpg
 
leepangfu
Just started to use the full options on the camera and I don't have photoshop. But I would like to know how you think they look and how I could improve them.

specialstageroute7j.jpg


I like the picture of the maserati, are the edges of the pictures meant to be blurred or not? 7.5/10

Tried to go for a realistic downhill shot, I think it paid off but hey, your the critiques
5695408831_690fe22946_b.jpg
Click to expand...
 
8/10 Overall looks great, but there's just something that find odd (Prehaps it's the horrible dirt texture, but I can't blame you for that)... but that's still a lovely pic. Looks pretty realistic too! ;)

My pic:
Mt.jpg
 
Hmm... I'll give you a 8/10. Nice sense of speed and color, but prehaps not having the car in the center of the shot might make it look better (if you know what I mean). But still, a marvelous shot ;)

My shots:

RedBullHangar-7_8.jpg


Lucerne-ChapelBridge_4.jpg
 
matt-mtb
That pic is just mind blowingly awesome, well done 10/10
5695986428_8fde17a0a8_b.jpg
Click to expand...

Something funky about the cropping, but I can't quite put my finger on it. The car isn't driving over the photograper, that's good. Always refreshing to see drift shots from different angles. 8/10

toscanatarmac4.jpg

Panic shot of photographer escaping from a certain death! Does it look anything like that?
 
matt-mtb
That pic is just mind blowingly awesome, well done 10/10
5695986428_8fde17a0a8_b.jpg
Click to expand...

matt-mtb
I like the idea, i think its paid off but i would of made it a little clearer 7/10

5695987414_76aae101a2_z.jpg
:nervous:
Click to expand...

I think I see what PanzuDrift is talking about too. With the 1st shot the motion / direction of the car is a bit vague, it looks like there some smoke so it could be a bit of a drift or power slide around a corner but there wasn't enough of the track maybe to get idea of what the car was actually doing (perhaps if it were zoomed out more to show the track it'd give a better sense of where the car was going to / coming from). It's almost like the car is out of context is that makes sense?

The 2nd shot much better illustrates what I'm trying to say even though it's a different angle, you can see the touch of counter steering as the back end's trying to come around so you can see or imagine what led up to what's captured in the still image.
 
I like the picture, I think it would look better if would of used a filter, probably cool. 8/10

Heres mine
5669615083_865fb0e555_b.jpg
 
matt-mtb
5698731263_7c1090af8b_z.jpg
Click to expand...

I'll give this a 7.25 / 10.00
Solid picture, just a little too "off" for me.
(I really like, and regularly use odd angles myself. However, the photo has a very nice realistic look to it, and in my opinion the angle takes away from that realistic look...)


I missed the PMC this week - by less than an hour. :banghead:
After taking a good one hundred pictures using eight different cars (seven different models), one of these three would've been my submission choice.
Amazingly - it's a Standard car!

missedpmcwk23a.jpg

missedpmcwk23b.jpg

missedpmcwk23c.jpg


Any and all critiques are welcomed and greatly appreciated... Much thanks!

Peace...
 
The first one is awesome, I still cant believe that it is standard from that picture. :) 9/10

Heres mine
5698733191_9781802509_z.jpg
 
@Matt-mtb

Nice 7.5/10, it looks good, but something about it bugs me and I think the car is a little too shiny and reflective. But very good!

@Nigrick

Pretty good, 8.5/10, the road surface looks a little odd, and the car looks odd when it's drifting while the others are not. But I like the fog and the angle!

Here is mine, I know its not much...
Autodromo%20Nazionale%20Monza_4_Edit.jpg
 
Nope, did a little bit of tinkering with Paint.NET though, just in the saturation and brightness/contrast

Nice, thats much better, less shiny. Can't see anything wrong with it except the spolier disappearing at the back. 9.5/10!

Here is another, no editing whatsoever!
N%C3%BCrburgring%2024h_6.jpg

Sorry about the small pic size though!
 
ECGadget
Nope, did a little bit of tinkering with Paint.NET though, just in the saturation and brightness/contrast

Nice, thats much better, less shiny. Can't see anything wrong with it except the spolier disappearing at the back. 9.5/10!

Here is another, no editing whatsoever!
N%C3%BCrburgring%2024h_6.jpg

Sorry about the small pic size though!
Click to expand...

8/10
I like the glowing brakes but the angle could been better.


Circuit de la Sarthe 2009 (No Chicanes)_7 by screiinshot, on Flickr
 
I would give your picture a 7.5/10. It has a very good use of the filter and shutter speed, however there is no main focal point. I would recommend moving the angle more to the right and capturing both cars from a similar distance.

HighSpeedRing_3.jpg


SpecialStageRoute7_5.jpg


RedBullHangar-7.jpg
 
Dylans1o
Heres Mine

(Click For 1080p Recommended for full quality)
Click to expand...

I like the concept of older vehicles in the heat of battle very much, however, I don't think that the "heat of battle" feeling was quite captured in this picture. It might just be my opinion, but I feel no sense of speed. But, like I said, with some fine tuning of the camera options, blur effects could be used to help the viewer sense the speed. 6.5-7/10.

Now here is one of my more recent photos. Tried for interesting angle to capture the battle for first between two orange esprits.

Lotus Esprit by Sctr9Bomber, on Flickr
 
I think it would've been better if you could see a bit more of the Espirit in the Background (or had a different colour for it) because to me it blends in a tiny bit.
Okay, my one :D

Inspiration (from GT4)
 

Latest Posts

Back