The "Rate My Photo" thread! **Read the OP Before You Post**

  • Thread starter Thread starter MSD Drifter
  • 2,388 comments
  • 199,192 views
KamyKaze1098 -> Technically very good. Framing is well balanced. But your composition doesn't "tell" me anything...
Very hard for me to rate it. 8.5/10.

nmrgoodnightn -> First one is funny. 7/10. Second one is way too dark.

Here's one. I like the car but the tree is ugly. Maybe I could have chosen another point of view...

 
yeah that tree spoils it, I would like a filter as well. 7/10

heres mine
5887920168_40a54b8d42_b.jpg
 
Mattmtb, a 7/10, I think you need to blur a bit the car.

4j5fs9.jpg


What about mine?
 
Well I like the car and scenery but there is something I dont like about it, but I cant put my finger on it. I think it s the fact that the background is blurred too much.
5887960620_600c6d2f6f_b.jpg
 
matt-mtb
Well I like the car and scenery but there is something I dont like about it, but I cant put my finger on it. I think it s the fact that the background is blurred too much.
Click to expand...

Your shot is good, but I think you need to blur a bit more, not so much, as me (I got wrong) but you should do that a bit because the scenary is not having as much a quality as the car. :) 8/10
 
trangurismo, great shots! :) 1st: 9/10 2nd: 7/10

112fln5.jpg


Here comes mine, please RATE!
 
matt-mtb
Well I like the car and scenery but there is something I dont like about it, but I cant put my finger on it. I think it s the fact that the background is blurred too much.
5887960620_600c6d2f6f_b.jpg
Click to expand...

7/10
the Ferrari sliding in the dirt gives it a good feeling of drifting for some reason . The scenery looks very good with the diffrent amount of zoom and its a good photo overall , but not enough
 
wejhvabewjty
112fln5.jpg


Here comes mine, please RATE!
Click to expand...

7/10 you maybe tried too much to get a realistic image. But it is realistic in some ways, like the colours.
It's not bad and nor it is brilliant. What I don't like in the photo is the F-number, the car looks too pixelated.

My image, rate!

ahrweilerstreete.jpg
 
5/10, reason is that you used the miniature filter inappropriate, its not ment to be used on close ups.

Mine
 
DawgCCCP
5/10, reason is that you used the miniature filter inappropriate, its not ment to be used on close ups.

Mine
Click to expand...

I'll have to give that a 9.5/10. I like the good sense of speed. Like the blur of the stands. I'm rating it highly due to me feeling that there isn't much you could do better with an un-edited shot of that style. Nice work. 👍

A shot 'o mine. :p

 
7, essential feeling!

How's this for a try? I love my F40

f405.jpg


f404.jpg
 
Pic 1
I think you need to turn the f value up, its a bit too blurred in my opinion. 6,10

5887959972_646864e9c7_b.jpg
 
matt-mtb
Pic 1
I think you need to turn the f value up, its a bit too blurred in my opinion. 6,10

5887959972_646864e9c7_b.jpg
Click to expand...

It's a nice shot, not a big fan of the filter though. 7/10.


DB9 Deep Forest by PHO3NIX_F1RE, on Flickr

Also, what settings are people using to get pictures where the wheel is blurry but the car isn't? I can only ever get one or the other.
 
PHO3NIX_F1RE
Also, what settings are people using to get pictures where the wheel is blurry but the car isn't? I can only ever get one or the other.
Click to expand...

Don't you mean wheelspin, seeing the wheels and tarmac move along the car?
If so, Panning mode 3. I think your shot would look better with panning mode 3 and a low shutter speed. Unless it already is. :p
 
FishyJuice
Don't you mean wheelspin, seeing the wheels and tarmac move along the car?
If so, Panning mode 3. I think your shot would look better with panning mode 3 and a low shutter speed. Unless it already is. :p
Click to expand...


Thanks dude, I've not experimented with the Panning Modes yet. I'll be sure to try it out :D
 
CMfeO.jpg

It's an old one but i still like it :)
VmiPR.jpg

Can't decide which one is best, you guys choose!! :D
 
here are my first entries in this.

what do you think?

EigerNordwandKTrail_2.jpg

GrandValleySpeedway_5.jpg
EigerNordwandKTrail_3.jpg
EigerNordwandWTrail_1-1.jpg
RedBullHangar-7.jpg
 
The last picture is ok, I think you need to turn the brightness up a tad and possibly experiment in a filter like cool. 6/10

5847815601_f42a12c20d_b.jpg
 
@counter's pic

Your pic is good but it's not very original, you see racing pics a lot. 8.5/10
 
Last edited:
BlackIce90
picture.php


picture.php
Click to expand...
These 2 I like the most, I'm a huge fan of the maserati, and the bmw is just so sexy , and the lightings and the place of the camera are beautifull , 9.5/10

so, what u guys think of this? also tell me what I can change to make it look better :)
toscanaasfalt1.jpg


kyotogion9.jpg


abdijvansangalgano2.jpg
 
^ Intresting pics, in terms of improvement, I'd say the red wheels and slick tyres detract a little. The M3 is my fave 👍

Here's one of my latest........

 
HagbardCeline23
^ Intresting pics, in terms of improvement, I'd say the red wheels and slick tyres detract a little. The M3 is my fave 👍

Here's one of my latest........
Click to expand...
if i didn't know this is in a game i would think it's made in real life, super realistic ;) , what do you think about this?
toscanaasfalt1.jpg
 
BLueMotiioNx
if i didn't know this is in a game i would think it's made in real life, super realistic ;) , what do you think about this?
http://img835.imageshack.us/img835/5905/toscanaasfalt1.jpg
Click to expand...

I love it. The R8 looks menacing when it's coming at you at 100+. I like how the blurriness gives it a sense of speed but everything is still nice and detailed. It almost looks just a little pale though. 9.5/10.


I almost entered this in a competition. I'm aiming for a realistic look ;)


GT5 - F430 Scuderia - Monza by gregthestig, on Flickr
 
GregTheStig
I love it. The R8 looks menacing when it's coming at you at 100+. I like how the blurriness gives it a sense of speed but everything is still nice and detailed. It almost looks just a little pale though. 9.5/10.


I almost entered this in a competition. I'm aiming for a realistic look ;)


GT5 - F430 Scuderia - Monza by gregthestig, on Flickr
Click to expand...

damn man, the reflection and the extra light on the background on that sand, good motion of speed, I had to show this pic to some of my in real life friends who play with me on GT5, a few of them saved it, so i gues you did a good job (y) ;$
nice men ;)
 
Back