The "Rate My Photo" thread! **Read the OP Before You Post**

  • Thread starter Thread starter MSD Drifter
  • 2,388 comments
  • 199,192 views
Love that, but if that was me I would of had the lights on
9/10


5847814137_8ff6104c6c_b.jpg
 
Love the second nsx pic, I dont like the leaves much. 9/10

5847814765_b3c84d6e78_b.jpg
 
I'm not too fond of the car paint, and the pic's a bit dark, but otherwise quite good 6.5/10 👍

Used PS CS3
 
Nice pic, but I dont think that filter helps. However 8/10

5848381526_d6233595fd_b.jpg
 
^
I think you are using the blur to portray the speed of the car but I think the scenery wasn't an optimal choice. The focus of the picture is on the grandstand which makes the viewer concentrate on it when they first look at the picture, therefore the car becomes a secondary object which the viewer notices afterwards. The car turns into an obstruction to the picture instead of being the main focus.

Personally I think the picture would be better if the scenery was less detailed or interesting, which prevents the viewer from being distracted from the car.
Also instead of the car entering the camera frame, it would be better if it was exiting it instead.

7.5/10

All of the above is In My (non-professional) Opinion and only just my personal thoughts.
 
yeah thanks I tried to make a tribute to le mans, if I had photoshop, I would of added drivers to the podium to add the effect, but I dont have ps.

5847814581_2dedaf79fb_b.jpg
 
matt-mtb
yeah thanks I tried to make a tribute to le mans, if I had photoshop, I would of added drivers to the podium to add the effect, but I dont have ps.

5847814581_2dedaf79fb_b.jpg
Click to expand...

yes yes yes...!:)
 
^nice, but imo the car is either too dark, or the wheels to bright, 7/10

 
Love the idea 10/10

Which is better?
5847813843_4a631f85a8_z.jpg

5848371252_0fe2955936_z.jpg
 
Thanks! :) Second one is better, next time use Panning mode 3 and try F5 and mabye drive your car faster to get more panning :)
 
V8Loverrr
Thanks! :) Second one is better, next time use Panning mode 3 and try F5 and mabye drive your car faster to get more panning :)
Click to expand...

I dont get the panning modes, what do they do?

To me this is my most realistic
5848371016_2112d65028_b.jpg
 
8/10 I just find the wave effect on the sky distracting. Here's two more from me

ligegravel3.jpg


eigernordwandshorttrackx.jpg
 
matt-mtb
I dont get the panning modes, what do they do?
Click to expand...
Well, to put it simply, panning mode 1 makes the car much more blurry, panning mode 2 is a little less blur on the car, and panning mode 3 keeps the car completly in focus. More here (6.0 Robotic Arm Panning).

To the photos above:

1st: 9/10 love it! Shame about the blockyness on the car but that can't be avoided, and I think the car should be more in focus with the background blurred more. Otherwise, awesome! 👍

2nd: 8.5/10, lovely shot but i'm not entirely sure on blue and a blue car. Nice though.

_smaller.jpg
 
8.5/10 Love the angle, nice focus on the car.

Here's a few of mine, unedited.

SanGalganoAbbey_1.jpg


TheTopGearTestTrack.jpg


ToscanaTarmac_1-1.jpg
 
SuperVeloce
2nd: 8.5/10, lovely shot but i'm not entirely sure on blue and a blue car. Nice though.
Click to expand...

Thanks Lol, yeah I was debating on which filter to use for the second pic, i think this filter looks better:

eigernordwandshorttrackh.jpg
 
01gt4.6
8.5/10 Love the angle, nice focus on the car.

Here's a few of mine, unedited.

SanGalganoAbbey_1.jpg


TheTopGearTestTrack.jpg


ToscanaTarmac_1-1.jpg
Click to expand...

The first one: 8.5/10 sharper image would have been better but great position.

The second one: 7.5/ 10 nice action shot.

The third one: 9/10 epic face is epic!

Woops, I'll do the one after too :p 9/10 Love it, great side on shot.









 
Last edited:
1st one is pretty nice, 8/10, second is pretty empty 5/10



^unedited shot
 
V8Loverrr
1st one is pretty nice, 8/10, second is pretty empty 5/10



^unedited shot
Click to expand...

Great shot 9/10, I don´t give you the 10 because for it the first impression of the image should be real life. Anyway this is an awesome shot :)
 
6xxlvl.jpg


I just edited the image using Mac OS X Preview, only minor color tweaks to improve realism. Hope you like this one :)
 
wejhvabewjty
Great shot 9/10, I don´t give you the 10 because for it the first impression of the image should be real life. Anyway this is an awesome shot :)
Click to expand...

I don't get that part :dunce:


I'll give you a 6/10:

-car is a little too dark
-the cars end is completly blured, try to use Panning Mode 3

:)


 
V8Loverrr
I don't get that part :dunce:


I'll give you a 6/10:

-car is a little too dark
-the cars end is completly blured, try to use Panning Mode 3

:)


Click to expand...
Superb shot 9.5/10
Love the vintage effect and colours but the bokeh could be a bit smoother (in photoshop, use blur tool to smooth out a bit the annoying bokeh).



Click thumbnail for bigger picture.
 
V8Loverrr
I don't get that part :dunce:


I'll give you a 6/10:

-car is a little too dark
-the cars end is completly blured, try to use Panning Mode 3

:)


Click to expand...

The part that you don´t understand is:

To make you think that the pic is real :)
 
wejhvabewjty
The part that you don´t understand is:

To make you think that the pic is real :)
Click to expand...

Well dude, it's still a game, and this is not the ''post a realistic photo'' thread :scared:


@Vortex: Thanks will try that next time :)
The first one is really great, 9/10
Got no pic atm, so the following has to post a new one
 
THat mazda shot is pretty dece. 9/10

Heres my sloppy attempt at a shot
5864519450_cf0e128ba2_b.jpg
 
Back