Three-way showdown! ZZ-S vs. Elise vs. Garaiya

[Woolie Wool]

As usual, first to 50 votes wins.

 

[Cosmic]

Lotus Elise 111R 👍

 

[nissan man]

have 2 go with the british Elise

 

[spykerdriver]

I had to go with the only one I've driven, the Lotus.

 

[Driftnewb110]

I pick Elise because my friends name is Elise.

 

[azmati]

By the numbers the Tommy Kaira ZZ-S Pw\/\s both.

- After full mods._

-Power to Weight
Tommy Kaira ZZ-S = 1.776 👍
ASL Garaiya = 2.318
Lotus Elise = 2.365 👎
-Weight
Tommy Kaira ZZ-S = 627 👍
ASL Garaiya = 728
Lotus Elise = 782 👎
-HP
Tommy Kaira ZZ-S = 353 👍
ASL Garaiya = 331
Lotus Elise = 314 👎
Tommy Kaira ZZ-S gets my vote for over all feel and power. The only thing I can give the elise is it looks cool.

 

[Woolie Wool]

The ZZ-S has sucky handling.

 

[ppucci]

One of my favourites since GT3... Tommy Kaira ZZ-S

 

[azmati]

The ZZ-S has sucky handling.

All of the listed cars are pure handling machines, and do a great job at it. Im suprised you dident include the Opal Speedster, or the Lancia Stratos.

 

[MRslider]

The Opal is an Elise.

 

[MRslider]

The Elise 190's weight gets down there in the 600kg range, but no six speed tranny as it was availible in GT3.
Also I believe the Ford RS200 is a Mid engine platform, but with AWD. Can a European verify this for me? I miss the brief histories and descriptions with the cars.

 

[panjandrum]

IMHO the Lotus Elise wins this contest hands-down.

 

[Woolie Wool]

All of the listed cars are pure handling machines, and do a great job at it. Im suprised you dident include the Opal Speedster, or the Lancia Stratos.

The Tommy Kaira is nowhere near as agile as the Elise or Garaiya. As for the two cars you mentioned, the Speedster is too slow and the Stratos is not really the same kind of car as the Elise, ZZ-S, or Garaiya.

 

[EvilToast]

The ELise because that car handles like a god!

 

[ferrari_chris]

Woolie Wool, have you taken over from Ram-Rod? I thought he was running these 1st to 50 competitions? Did he hand it over to you did he?

 

[azmati]

The Tommy Kaira is nowhere near as agile as the Elise or Garaiya. As for the two cars you mentioned, the Speedster is too slow and the Stratos is not really the same kind of car as the Elise, ZZ-S, or Garaiya.

If you say so Jimmy. My B - spec guy, and 5 second better lap times suggest otherwise. Lanica Stratos is the precursor to the style these cars have, probably the first of they're kind.
As far as the Opal being slow, and excluded. You still have the Elise in there witch is all around the worst preforming of the 3. The Opal wouldent make the Elise look so bad.

 

[elctrk!]

tommy can you hear me??

 

[azmati]

Nurburgring Times for the 3:
B - Speced at 3 for consistency.
best of 3 laps.
All = Full Modded, spoiler with full downforce at both ends. Auto gear setting to 12 so they dont top out too fast.

Tommy Kaira ZZ-S = 7:01 <--Still uncontested,.
Lotus Elise = 7:06 <-- ok, it took a close second. I stand corrected.
Opal Speedster = 7:16 <-- added because it should have been included. Not the slowest.
ASL Garaiya = 7:24 <-- guess its not what it was cracked up to be

 

[ZZ-//]

I voted Tommy kaira. I didnt like the car at first because of its handling but i messed with the settings alot and now it is my favorite car. It now handles better than any cars in my garage besides 3 of the special black cars, the toyota molona and the F1.
You can make the handling really good if you put alot time into the car. I would give you my settings but my PS2 is broken right now but I'm getting another one soon and if you guys want I could give you the settings then.

I just had to defend my car..........

 

[azmati]

I voted Tommy kaira. I didnt like the car at first because of its handling but i messed with the settings alot and now it is my favorite car. It now handles better than any cars in my garage besides 3 of the special black cars, the toyota molona and the F1.
You can make the handling really good if you put alot time into the car. I would give you my settings but my PS2 is broken right now but I'm getting another one soon and if you guys want I could give you the settings then.

I just had to defend my car..........

<--- Is also a ZZ fan.

 

[ZZ-//]

Sorry for the double post but I thought you guys were talking about the ZZ-2 not the ZZ-s. I'm so stupid!!!!

 

[mouser]

Tommy Kaira gets my vote, it is an awesome car.

 

[Crash]

Elise becuase the car just handles so damn well.

 

[MRslider]

I Will do the 4 hours at the ring in a fully modded 111R, but keep the power down to a chip, ballance and port/pollish at around 220HP or so and I'll only race if the ASL shows up. If I pit every other lap the racing stays close for the first hour or so, (130-140pt race). In other words, the ASL might not be that bad of a car...

 

[Gentry Coach]

In my personal testing (15 different tracks/lap times), the ZZ-S wins on performance (and it wasn't that close). The Lotus was second.

Observations:
for me the Lotus was the hardest to handle, but I think it looks the best
to get the ASL to perform I had to use a low gear ratio (7 on auto)

To add to the Speedster debate, I tested the Opel also and it was VERY, VERY close to the Lotus.

EDIT: to add more fuel to the fire , after further testing (more tracks) the Opel came in second. I know people have different driving styles, but for me at least the Lotus was pretty hard to handle