Would you rather?

  • Thread starter motortrend
  • 22,046 comments
  • 1,111,240 views
Surprisingly I'd take the 599 I'd die in the zr1
The subie is much better looking and performing easy choice.
The 250 gt lusso is just beautiful forget the Enzo
 
Last edited:
Without any hesitation if I was given the keys to a 2012 GT-R to own, short of maybe a Murcielago SuperVeloce or an Aventador I'd take the GT-R over anything. Plus, as much as many people here disagree with the man, I reckon Jeremy Clarkson is right with the 991: you take away the steering feel, you kill the 911.
 
I'll take the Legacy over the E-Class.

Now between the two Ferraris, it's a hard choice. But that 250 GTO looks nice, so I'll take the Lusso.

GTR or 991, a hard choice. But I'll take the GTR first. I want a 991 Turbo or GT3/GT2, until that. It's my CBAR35, VR38DETT and AWD beast espically with mods pushing around 800-1200hp! :D:tup:
 
I'll happily take the new 911. I love the new 911, it's fantastic. :) Compared to an R35 GT-R, there's no need to think about it at all, 911 all the way. The GT-R is boring and too computer like, and it looks chubby. :ouch:

Mini Cooper S
mini-cooper-p0503.jpg


OR

Fiat 500 Abarth
2008%20Fiat%20500%20Abarth.jpg
 
Slashfan
Clearly :lol:

2 completely different vehicles with the same purpose XD.
Click to expand...

It was an unfair comparison, an f250 vs a 1500 is fair. I'd Still take the chevy, otherwise o wouldn't make it home to often.:P
 
Autoweek did a Mini Coupe thing vs a 500 and l chose the Mini. But with the normal Mini, i'd choose the Fiat.
 
GT-R over the 991 cause I'm Nissan fan :D


500 Abarth over the Mini Cooper cause I don't like the look of the Mini.
 
The 1964 Ferrari 250 GT Lusso for sure, classic Ferraris are some of the best looking cars ever made.

The 911 over the GT-R because it isn't a GT-R or a Nissan.

The 500 Abarth v. Cooper S would be a hard choice for me. I know how the Cooper S performs and it's a fantastic little car, but the Abarth is really good too despite having pretty awful build quality and cheap interior. The sound on the 500 makes up for some of it's short comings though. In the end though I think I'd go with a Cooper S just because I know MINI's quirks.
 
911 Carrera S vs Nissan GT-R: GT-R, not to fond of the Carrera's styling and the GT-R is pretty nice top look at. Plus I grew up with Nissans on my mind so the GT-R all the way.

MINI vs 500 Abarth: Why not the JCW Cooper S? You got the performance version of the 500... oh well. I would still take that MINI anytime. Also grew up with MINIs in mind. :)
 
911 vs GTR. Neither. I'd get a an R32 for that money and have some change for other things. If i had to choose it would be the GTR.

BMW vs Abarth 500. Abarth for me. I hate BMW's take on the British classic. At least the Fiat stayed more true to it's roots. Looks and size wise.

458 vs MP4. Can I have a Noble M600 instead? No? Ok I suppose it's the 458.
 
I'll take the Cooper S and as much as I love Ferraris, the 458 doesn't quite do it for me, plus there are already like 4 of them in here, which is a lot for how small this island is, so Mclaren it is
 
Porsche, no BMW can beat the styling of a Porsche let alone a 4-door(lol jk). It can also go faster than a BMW and speed is what I look for in cars.
 
Panamera or X6?

Panamera - it's not the best proportioned car, but in the right colour and from the right angles it's passable. At least you wouldn't feel like a douche driving it, like you would in the X6.
 
TheCracker
Panamera or X6?

Panamera - it's not the best proportioned car, but in the right colour and from the right distance it's passable. At least you wouldn't feel like a douche driving it, like you would in the X6.
Click to expand...

You mean about seventeen miles away?

Oh and you're wrong about the douche bit. I'd feel like a douche, as a matter of fact I would want to wash every orifice as well as my skin, hair, eyesockets and so on with boiling diesel after driving either of those horrible ugly cuckold-mobiles.
 
I'd rather die than buy either of them. A Maserati Gran Turismo or Aston Martin Rapide is a much better comparison for the Panamera. Out of them 3 I'm stuck between 2. The Aston and Maser. Both look good, Both sound good. But cos of the V8 noise I'd probs take the Maser.
 
Panamera and 458. I like the MP4-12C, but it needs more soul for me. The 458 isn't as good looking (don't kill me!), but it's more fun. The Panamera, well, because the X6 is stupid.
 
I'd go with the Panamera, I do like it a fair bit.

As for MP4-12C vs 458.. that's tough. I think the McLaren would be easier to live with every day, but I think I'd ultimately go with the Ferrari. Hard to say with never having driven either, but I'd lean towards the Italia. It's prettier, I prefer how it sounds, and I like the look of the interior better (at least from internet pictures).
 
I would rather poke my eyes out with a rusty nail than be seen in either of those cars. It'd be less painful.

Sorry, but I strongly dislike both Porsche and BMW... especially the X6.
 
Eh probably the Ferrari 458 just because I think it is the better looking of the two.

The Panamera, if you fold down the rear seats you can fit some stuff in it. The X6 just has weird proportions and it looks like cargo wouldn't fit all that well into it. Neither of them look all that great though.
 
1972 Eldorado (eww) FWD, 180hp 8.2L 500+cui

Or

1972 Continental (yum!) RWD, 220hp 460cui



Can you guess which one l would take? :D
 

Latest Posts

Back