Would you rather?

  • Thread starter motortrend
  • 22,046 comments
  • 1,098,581 views
The Vanishing Boy
Lancia Delta HF Integrale Evoluzione 2 vs. BMW E30 M3 Sport Evolution vs. Mercedes-Benz W201 190E 2.5-16 Evolution 2 vs. Ford YBD Sierra RS500 Cosworth vs. Toyota ST185 Celica GT-Four RC
Click to expand...

This is by far one of the most impressive group of cars we've had to choose from. Although I'd be happy with any car from this group, I'd rather have the Lancia.

Would You Rather:

2005 Porsche Carrera GT
2004_porsche_carrera-gt_convertible_base_fq_oem_1_500.jpg


or

2003 Ferrari Enzo
2003_ferrari_enzo_coupe_base_fq_oem_1_500.jpg
 
Carrera GT vs Enzo -
Definitely the Carrera, it just beats the Enzo on so many key aspects. Here is the wiki page for the Enzo and here is the Carrera's wiki page. The Carrera has a 6-speed manual, which is better than the Enzo's 6-speed semi-auto. The Enzo does, however, have a bigger engine (6.0 litre V12, compared to the Carrera's 5.7 litre V10), so it has more horsepower, albeit not much more.
I also think that the Carrera looks better and is easier to live with. Finally, it is also a Porsche, meaning that it will be more reliable and better built than the Italian Ferrari. This is just my opinion.

My turn! Would you rather have a:


2014 Chevrolet Camaro:

2014-Chevrolet-Camaro-Z28-front-three-quarters-21.jpg


or a


2014 Ford Mustang:

2014-Ford-Mustang-GT-HD-Wallpaper.jpg
 
That's not even a 2014 Mustang. A 2014 Mustang is this:

2013-mustang-rtr.jpg
13-MUST-GT-FT.jpg


What you posted is a rendering.
EDIT: Just realized the hood is behind the grill on the new models...something not seen on a Mustang since 1974 with the MII. Styling cues...
 
If the Camaro is the Z28, I will take the Camaro, but if it's a normal Camaro, I will take the Mustang. You need to be more specific with what spec the two cars are.
Edit: Between the Enzo and Carrera GT, I will go for the Carrera GT even though it doens't have a roof (pardon the pun :sly:). I'm not a massive Enzo fan anymore nor the Carrera GT but, the Carrera is an absolute beauty whereas the Enzo looks boring in my eyes.
 
Last edited:
Lancia Delta HF Integrale Evolution II vs. BMW M3 Sport Evolution vs. Mercedes-Benz 190E 2.5-16 Evolution II vs. Ford Sierra RS500 Cosworth vs. Toyota Celica GT-Four RC - M3, another "just the best car there" comparo.

Porsche Carrera GT vs. Ferrari Enzo - CGT.

Chevrolet Camaro vs. Ford Mustang Render - I'll take the real car.
 
Enzo vs. Carrera GT: I'll have the Enzo please. You have to wear noise cancelling headphones while wearing it. End of story. :lol: (Well I'm sure you don't have to, but you probably should.)

Skip to :30 to see.

 
Carrera GT over Enzo, I like the style of the Carrera more though I have no doubt the Enzo is probably the superior car technically.

Camaro over Mustang, I've always been more a GM guy than Ford. Simple bias I know but a bias I've always had none the less.

I'm sure that someone has asked about this comparo by now but...

Ferrari-599-GTB-Fiorano.jpeg


Or

lexus_lfa_10_08.jpg
 
Sorry for the frequent posts, but I just had a brilliant comparo idea. I love these kinds of cars, so I just had to write this one up.

Would you rather have a:

Chevrolet Chevelle SS 454 '70:

autowp.ru_chevrolet_chevelle_ss_454_6.jpg


or a


Ford Mustang GT500 '69:

69-Shelby-GT500_DV-12-GG_08.jpg


or a


Chevrolet Camaro Z28 '69:

69z28.jpg


or a


Pontiac Firebird Trans Am '70:

1970_Pontiac_Firebird_Trans_Am_by_LPAGAN401.jpg




P.S. - I would have the Chevelle without thinking twice, I'm a massive Chevelle fan!
 
Last edited:
The Mustang you posted is a '67 GT500. This is a 1969 GT500.

0_-_CAR_PICS_072-c.JPG

69-Shelby-Mustang-GT500-DV-09_GC-001.jpg



Anyways, the Mustang would be my first choice for obvious reasons, then the Trans Am would come in next.

Besides, I've always found the 428 Cobra Jet and Super Cobra Jet engines to be more exciting than the rest.
 
LFA vs 599 -
I am stumped. These are two of my favourite super cars of all time and I have never thought about which one I prefer. My brain is screaming "LFA, LFA, LFA!", but I know that the 599 will undoubtedly be a better track car. I think, after about 3 days of consideration (if I was really offered one of these cars in real life), I would choose the LFA. The LFA sounds... magnificent and inspiring, while looking the part, too. It also has that super car status, while having an underrated brand, Lexus. It is far more expensive, too, making it the more unique option. It hurts me to leave the 599 behind, but the LFA is just better, in my opinion.

EDIT: Thanks Slash, it's fixed now. I won't edit the 2014 Mustang in the previous page because I can't seem to find a decent picture. I was sure that the 2014 Mustang looked like the one I linked, since a friend of mine showed me it, but I guess he was wrong. Thanks again!
 
LFA, no doubt. It's one of my favourite cars.

Camaro Z28, becasue it looks the best and probably handles okay.
 
Bodyguard
EDIT: Thanks Slash, it's fixed now. I won't edit the 2014 Mustang in the previous page because I can't seem to find a decent picture. I was sure that the 2014 Mustang looked like the one I linked, since a friend of mine showed me it, but I guess he was wrong. Thanks again!
Click to expand...

No problem. Yeah that happens when you use Google images, its one of the first images to come up but the reality is that the 2014 model is a carry over from 2013.


599 vs LFA

Tough call here. The LFA's design is whacky but I've always like the body lines of the 599 so I think I'll go with that. I'm partial to Ferrari in general though.
 
Kent
Carrera GT over Enzo, I like the style of the Carrera more though I have no doubt the Enzo is probably the superior car technically.

Camaro over Mustang, I've always been more a GM guy than Ford. Simple bias I know but a bias I've always had none the less.

I'm sure that someone has asked about this comparo by now but...

Or
Click to expand...

Who wouldn't take the LFA?
 
Ferrari 599 GTB Fiorano vs. Lexus LFA - LFA, used to be my favorite car.

Chevrolet Chevelle SS 454 vs. Ford Mustang GT500 vs. Chevrolet Camaro Z28 vs. Pontiac Firebird Trans Am - GT500. :drool:
 
Ferrari 599 GTB vs. Lexus LFA

Too easy, I'd rather have the LFA.

Chevelle vs. GT500 vs. Z28 vs. Trans Am

I'd rather have the Z28
 
Pagani Roadster vs Ferrari Roadster -
Definitely the Pagani, because I prefer its looks compared to the 458, as well as handling and interior. The sound is also better, and the car has a nice sense of exclusivity that you just don't get from a Ferrari.
 
Enzo- little bit better sound and more valuable.

Camaro- better looking than the Mustang.

599- because it has cup holders.

Chevelle- Looks better than the camaro.

Zonda- one of my favorite hypercars.
 
599 v. LFA: Easily the LFA. I just love the sound.

Muscle cars: Simple choice for me. Chevelle. As long as its the LS6 454 with 450hp, it's one of my dream cars. :drool:

Zonda Cinque Roadster v. 458 Spyder: Might as well compare a One-77 with a Jag XK.
 
Carrera GT vs. Enzo Ferrari: Hmmm, tough choice since I like them both. But I'll go for the CGT, because 5.7L NA V10 and one unique Porsche. ;)

Camaro Z28 vs. '14 Mustang GT: Ugh, I'll take both, since I'm a 'Stang and Camaro fan. Z28 in yellow and a 5.0 GT in blue with white stripes. Next is a supercharger for both.

Chevelle SS 454 vs. Shelby GT500 vs. Camaro Z28 vs. Trans-Am: Not another one!? Too many to choose from. Would take them all.....but

Heck give me the Chevelle and the TA and some mods, time for some Prostreet tuning for these beasts. :mischievous:👍

Zonda Cinque Roadster vs. 458 Italia Spyder: Hmmm, the Zonda hands down, but the 458 isn't a good rival to the Zonda. Maybe a Enzo or a CCXR though.
 
Carrera GT vs Enzo: Enzo easily. It's better at everything performance than the Carrera GT.

Camaro vs Mustang: Camaro, especially the new Z28. The Mustang is getting long in the tooth with using the same live rear axle technology.

Muscle cars: I'll have the Chevelle.

Zonda vs 458: Unfair comparison. The Zonda is my choice hands down.

LFA vs 599: I'll have the 599 for that bellowing V12 and superior GT capabilities. The LFA is too clinical to have any sort of soul.
 

Latest Posts

Back