Would you rather?

  • Thread starter motortrend
  • 22,046 comments
  • 1,094,593 views
Big jeeps : Knight XV. It's more awesome.

Hot Hatches: I'll take the Megane 225. Renaultsport know what they're doing.


Subaru BRZ
subaru-brz-interior-revealed-makes-video-debut_7.jpg


OR​

Ford Fiesta ST
ford-fiesta-st-12.jpg
 
xXKingJoshXx
I'll have the Porsche 911. :sly:

(the Opel Astra pic shows a 911 in case it shows the correct picture for you)

Seriously though, I'd have the Mazda. It's the best looking to me and likely the most fun.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I'm getting an astra on my page.

In response to the WYR above, I'll take the Ford Fiesta ST.
 
Stuff carriers: Crown Vic is a no-no, Volvo is just boring and uncharismatic, so I'll take the El Camino.

Yeti vs Legacy: Legacy. I would never want to be seen in that Skoda.
 
I'll take the Crown Victoria P71 and the Legacy Outback.


The Snake or The Stallion?


Shelby Cobra Daytona Coupé
AC-Shelby-Cobra-Daytona-Coupe_26.jpg


or

Ferrari 250 GTO "Series I"

14-ferrari-250-gto-2011-laguna-seca.jpg
 
Chevrolet El Camino SS vs. Ford Crown Victoria Police Interceptor vs. Volvo 740 Turbo Estate - Vic, it's the newest.

Results:
1. Ford Crown Victoria Police Interceptor
2. Chevrolet El Camino SS
3. Volvo 740 Turbo Estate

Skoda Yeti vs. Subaru Legacy Outback - Subaru, easy.

Shelby Cobra Daytona Coupe vs. Ferrari 250 GTO - A really hard comparison. I'm gonna have to take the 'Murikan.

Toyota Camry V8 vs. Dodge Charger SRT8 - SRT8, because it's not a ricemobile.
 
AudiMan2011
Subaru BRZ

OR

Ford Fiesta ST
Click to expand...

I really like the Fiesta, especially the new model, but I couldn't pick it over the BRZ.

Custom878
IMG]El Camino SS

or

Crown Victoria Police Interceptor

or

740 Turbo Estate
Click to expand...

The Volvo is so boring and unattractive, I just wouldn't be able to bring myself to drive it! That particular El Camino looks horrendous and wouldn't work on London roads. So the Crown Vic it is, although I don't see myself owning it for more than a couple of months. If I were to judge these cars purely on their ability to carry things, as the comparo said, I would pick the El Camino - it has a flatbed, so the sky's the limit when it comes to carrying things!

Roger the Horse
Skoda Yeti

or

Subaru Outback
Click to expand...

I'll take the Skoda, I quite like it! I personally think it looks better than the Subaru and is likely to be more practical and reliable, too.

NoobMan DS
The Snake or The Stallion?


Shelby Cobra Daytona Coupé

or

Ferrari 250 GTO "Series I"
Click to expand...

Love this comparo, welcome to the thread! I'll take the Stallion based purely on looks. I don't think I would drive either of these cars enough to properly notice how they handle around the track, so the styling would be more important.

Custom878
Toyota Camry V8

or

Dodge Charger SRT8
Click to expand...

I'll take the Charger because I don't hate myself. If that Camry was tastefully modified, then I might consider it, but as of now it's a piece of 🤬. The Charger isn't a great car, but it beats that RICEmobile by a mile!
 
Dodge Charger on the last one. It looks like they tried to make the Camry into something it's not. Which is awesome if you pull it off right, but I don't think they did.
 
Daily Driver

Random vehicles, each with their own pros and cons

Volkswagen_Beetle_.jpg

Beetle Sedan 1303

or

Toyota_Corolla_SR5_hatch_front.jpg

Corolla SR5 AE85

or

1988-1991_Volvo_240_GL_station_wagon_(2011-06-15)_01.jpg

Volvo 240 Estate

or

Dodge_Neon_Sport_coupe.jpg

Dodge Neon

or

38471580005_large.jpg

Impreza WRX Sport Wagon

or

2006_ford_f-250_super_duty_lariat_4dr_supercab_4wd_sb-pic-23807.jpeg

F-250 Super Duty (Powerstroke Diesel)
 
Stuff Carriers; The Ford Crown Victoria, it may not carry as many items as the other 2 choices, but it's a newer car. I also prefer the look of it over the other 2 and I think it could be fun to drive after a few mods.

Skoda Yeti vs Subaru Legacy Outback; The Skoda Yeti, for many reasons. I've heard the ride is comfortable, if would be a rarity to drive one in the US, & I think it would be better offroad.

Shelby Cobra Daytona Coupe vs Ferrari Series I 250 GTO; One of my favorite classic cars of all time is the Daytona Cobra and that's why I'm choosing the Cobra.

Toyota Camry V8 vs Dodge Charger SRT-8; I think the Camry is a decent looking family car, but that modified Camry doesn't look tasteful at all. So, that and the fact I actually sort of like the current gen Dodge Charger are the reasons why I'm picking the Charger SRT-8.

Daily Drivers; The Subaru Impreza WRX Wagon, I think it's a decent all rounder car. The F-250 Powerstroke would be my 2nd choice though and my 3rd choice would be the Toyota AE86 Corolla SR5.
 
Volkswagen 1303 Beetle vs. Toyota Corolla SR5 vs. Volvo 240 Estate vs. Dodge Neon vs. Subaru Impreza WRX Sport Wagon vs. Ford F-250 Super Duty - Easily the WRX.

Results:
1. Subaru Impreza WRX Sport Wagon
2. Toyota Corolla SR5
3. Volkswagen 1303 Beetle
4. Volvo 240 Estate
5. Dodge Neon
6. Ford F-250 Super Duty
 
Custom878
Beetle Sedan 1303

or

Corolla SR5 AE85

or

Volvo 240 Estate

or

Dodge Neon

or

Impreza WRX Sport Wagon

or

F-250 Super Duty (Powerstroke Diesel)
Click to expand...

I'll take the F-250, simply because almost all of the other choices look dull. I hate the bug-eyed Imprezas, can't stand the Neon, the Beetle would just be a joke and the Corolla wouldn't be comfortable or fun to drive. The F-250 is far too large, especially for London roads, but it definitely beats the other options!


I haven't done one in a while!

Would you rather have a:

1971 Nissan Skyline:

1971_Nissan_Skyline-1.jpg



or a

R32 Skyline

Nissan_Skyline_R32_GT-R_001.jpg



or a

R33 Skyline

Nissan_Skyline_R33_GT-R_001.jpg



or a

R34 Skyline

Nissan_Skyline_R34_GT-R_N%C3%BCr_001.jpg



or a

Nissan Juke

2010_nissan_juke_overseas_model_17-1019.jpg



or a

Toyota Camry

2005_Toyota_Camry_XLE_01.jpg



I realise these cars have pretty different prices and performance figures, however it will be interesting to see what people value most in cars. I personally value comfort, class and a bit of wheelspin when you need it; the closest thing to that in the above list is the 1971 Skyline, so I'd take that. I'm interested in seeing if people go for the newer and more reliable Juke/Camry or if they go for the oldies. Enjoy!
 
R33 For me its my Favorite of the Skylines. I hate the styling of the Juke and the Camry is boring as heck. I may have kids but I will never drive a boring car.
 
Bodyguard
I realise these cars have pretty different prices and performance figures, however it will be interesting to see what people value most in cars. I personally value comfort, class and a bit of wheelspin when you need it; the closest thing to that in the above list is the 1971 Skyline, so I'd take that. I'm interested in seeing if people go for the newer and more reliable Juke/Camry or if they go for the oldies. Enjoy!
Click to expand...

I don't know where you got the impression that a 1971 Skyline would be the most comfortable of all the Skylines given. :odd:
 

Latest Posts

Back