a possible problem

  • Thread starter Thread starter MadduckUK
  • 58 comments
  • 2,371 views
That's unusual seeing as Nintendo don't really do anything online do they? I thought they were all about gaming by a single person and multiplayer around the one console, that's what they've always been good at, is this possible? I mean how can they patent something that has already been done long before that must use the same methods and processes but just on different hardware. Is this Nintendo acting like a spoiled brat cause they ain't doing to well they're thinking "we'll throw in some outrageous hand and get money from our competitors who are destroying us in what we do best !!"
 
I guess you can just add one another feature and then patent your patent. It's cool for PR, but I guess Nintendo can't do anythnig with that patent which could compromise aother manufactorers (Sony and Micsft).

It would be like Mercedes Benz would patented an "system for driving a one to five persons in mechanical and motor-driven chasis with four wheels, air-condition, ABS, ESP, ASB, leather seats, 453 BHP at bargain price".

Npo harm done there. Just a nice gossip-starter.
 
Screw Nintendo - That's my opinion..

Besides - I can't see how they're going to enforce this - I wish them all the best...
 
It was said earlier, it's all irrelevent. :indiff: Just WAIT and see. When it comes out, we'll see if it's so much better, or just smoke up Nintendo's butt. Either way, I can bet you anything the PS3 will have that. By the way.....is there any news on that? just wonderin :)
 
i meant my edited post was irrelevant rather than the topic. but your right its just a wait and see jobbie. havent heard any ps3 news for a while... although i havent really looked all that much
 
Hey i suppose Nintendo does need something going for them. Although they have some great games they havnt been upto par, neither was Sega which is why they now ONLY develope games for other consoles. Face the facts Nintendo, Its all Playstation vs Xbox these days and nothing comes close............Other than a pc but thats completely irrelevant as they can be upgraded far more greater than any of these consoles.
 
This is all I am gonna say: REPORT THEM!

http://www.eff.org/patent/

Quote from EFF site:

"An EFF Initiative To Protect Innovation and Free Expression

(PDF available here. [41k])

I. The Problem

Every year numerous illegitimate patent applications make their way through the United States patent examination process without adequate review. The problem is particularly acute in the software and Internet fields where the history of prior inventions (often called “prior art”) is widely distributed and poorly documented. As a result, we have seen patents asserted on such simple technologies as:

* One-click online shopping (U.S. Patent No. 5,960,411.)
* Online shopping carts (U.S. Patent No. 5,715,314.)
* The hyperlink (U.S. Patent No. 4,873,662.)
* Video streaming (U.S. Patent No. 5,132,992.)
* Internationalizing domain names (U.S. Patent No. 6,182,148.)
* Pop-up windows (U.S. Patent No. 6,389,458.)
* Targeted banner ads (U.S. Patent No. 6,026,368.)
* Paying with a credit card online (U.S. Patent No. 6,289,319.)
* Framed browsing; (U.S. Patent Nos. 5,933,841 & 6,442,574.) and
* Affiliate linking (U.S. Patent No. 6,029,141.)

II. The Harm

The harm these patents cause the public is profound.

Unlike most technologies, software and the Internet have attracted a vast number of small business, non-profit, and individual users – each of whom has adopted and built upon these resources as part of their daily interaction with computers and the online world. From open source programming to online journaling to political campaigning, the average citizen is using new technology online and on her desktop as often as any traditional company.

With this increased visibility, however, comes increased vulnerability. Previously, patent holders had only targeted competing companies. These companies have established legal departments and outside counsel and are thus able to defend against illegitimate patent threats. Now some patent holders have begun to set their sights on the new class of technology users–small organizations and individuals who cannot afford to retain lawyers. Faced with million-dollar legal demands, they have no choice but to capitulate and pay license fees – fees that often fund more threat letters and lawsuits. And because these patents have become cheaper and easier to obtain, the patentee’s costs can be spread out quickly amongst the many new defendants. Our patent system has historically relied on the resources of major corporate players to defeat bad patents; now it leaves these new defendants with few if any options to defend themselves.

Illegitimate patents can also threaten free expression. More and more people are using software and Internet technology to express themselves online. Website and blogging tools are increasingly popular. Video and audio streaming technology is ubiquitous. E-mail and Instant Messaging have reached users of all ages. Yet because patents can be anywhere and everywhere in these technologies, the average user has no way of knowing whether his or her tools are subject to legal threats. Patent owners who claim control over these means of community discourse can threaten anyone who uses them, even for personal non-commercial purposes. We lose much if we allow overreaching patent claims to reduce the tremendous benefits that software and technology bring to freedom of expression. ...."

Apparently Nintendo is already on their Top 10 Most Wanted List regarding software based video game emulator.
 
Too many preteen fans? Wait until that new Zelda game comes out! That's going to be a damn good game.

As I noted, I'm not real big on online play, but I guess Nintendo just might enter the fray. I can surely imagine "Mario Kart: Double Dash!!" being an online own-fest. If Nintendo is looking to rival Sony Online and XBOX Live, it has a lot going for it. I don't really see how this can rival GT4, nor do I think this is more of a GT4 thread. In the meanwhile, let's see how this thing goes with Nintendo.
 
Here's a kicker, you guys: there's some info on this same thing at Gamespot, but it's revealed that the whole thing was done in, like, 1996 or 1997 for none other than, yup, the debacle known as the 64DD. Not sure of the date Gamespot posted the news, but it's all there. They've got more details in it, AND pictures of those same documents that also have drawings of the 64DD on it. You can rest easy now. <SCORE>
 
thats the old paptent. the new bit is the scary bit. "but the second filing adds provision for "substantially real-time" online multi-player gaming, connection via an online gaming service, support for online "player performance data", using the connection to download information and do so securely through an authentication process, and the communication across the Net of "audio input signals"."
 
Dont worry be happy :) its all good, this wont be a problem for Sony or MS, they will probably find a way around it, if it poses a problem, but i dont think it will.
 
It really doesn't make a difference, Sega had a patent when DC came out for online play and 1 year later PS2 uses the same system....then Microsoft...I really don't see anything new from nintendo anyway.
 
Gabkicks
👍 i agree. just a pitiful effort to slow down sony's utter domination of the console market. :sly:


'a pitiful effort'? Its a 64DD patent from the late 90s. It simply takes a long time for patents to be approved. The only thing that is pitiful is your need to see a company you have nothing to do with be perceived as being better than another you equally have nothing to do with. If this story were reversed I am quite sure I would be reading 'xb0x d00m3d'.


Just picking one post out of the many here to pic on, but it could have been almost any one of you...
 
U speaka good engrish. Shut up noob. I'm not some idiot fanboy. I'm simply stating facts. Sony sells more consoles than all other consoles combined. 👍 Learn to type correctly. Or do you live on another non-english speaking continent?
Make sure you know what your talking about before you speak. or you could end up looking like a fool many more times. 👍
 
these Patents are usually just a scare tactic, its like a mini-cold war if you will. an example is Microsoft and IBM. both companies patent anything they can and at the same time, violate the other companies patents. what this eventually boils down to is that if one company decides to enforce a patent, the other company will enforce one, this will go right to the point of both companies eventually sinking more money into legal fees than what its worth.

Nintendo knows that Sony and MS have their huge arsenal of Patents, they're just trying to make sure they remain competative.

think of it as a patent-deterent theory (ie. Nuclear Deterent theory)
 
Gabkicks
U speaka good engrish. Shut up noob. I'm not some idiot fanboy. I'm simply stating facts. Sony sells more consoles than all other consoles combined. 👍 Learn to type correctly. Or do you live on another non-english speaking continent?
Make sure you know what your talking about before you speak. or you could end up looking like a fool many more times. 👍


For a start, I am no noob. However the very fact that you don't know who I am proves you are.

And I indeed do speak good english. I am Australian, not Japanese. You should learn not to assume, you do know what thay say about it?... 'U speaka good engrish'? I would have thought that since you are on a GT forum, with GT being a Japanese product featuring mainly Japanese cars that you would not be so racist as to say something that offensive.

There are many fools here, I however am not one of them. You will learn this.
 
code_kev
i wonder if I can patent "graphics that simulate the effect of 3 dimensions" :D :D
You should patent cows - That would be pretty sweet 👍
 
Back