Best racing game???

  • Thread starter Thread starter joe8
  • 23 comments
  • 1,359 views

Which is the best racing-game?

  • Project Gotham Racing 3

    Votes: 4 10.5%
  • Forza Motorsport

    Votes: 11 28.9%
  • Gran Turismo 4

    Votes: 23 60.5%
  • Project Gotham Racing 2

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    38
  • Poll closed .
Messages
157
Projekt Gotham Racing 3
Forza Motorsport
Gran Turismo 4
Projekt Gotham Racing 2

Which game is the best for you?
 
ok so only one of those is actually a 360 game, but Im gonna have to vote for FM. PGR3 is definately the best 360 racer right now though.
 
I fail to see what GT4, Forza or PGR2 does in a 360 thread... but of the four, GT4 hands down of course.
 
I played all of them and I still say Forza. 2nd place would be PGR3.
 
Forza and GT4 have no place in this thread, or PGR has no place in it and this thread has no place here. These games are very different.
 
Almost chose GT4, but to me, it didnt bring anything new to the table.
Its still my fav series, just not my fav game.
 
Wow 3 Xbox games 1 PS2 game, this is cool........ GO GT4!
 
...I had to choose PGR3 just for the graphics and the possibilities of the Ferrari vs Lamborghini shooutouts...!

GT4 is still good, and after playing for a few hours today, I had to ask why I hadent played in such a long time. Ohh wait, ther was Halo 2, NFS:MW, Jade Empire, Forza, Burnout, Half-Life 2, Mario Kart DS, Advance Wars DS, etc... Maybe thats why my PS2 plays DVDs more than games these days...
 
believe it or not i was tied up between Forza and Pgr2, but i voted for forza
 
#1 Swinger
Forza>GT4
Do you have any arguments to support this statement? Or maybe you forgot to say "IMO" because, believe it or not, it's an opinion, and not a fact.

I went with GT4. With WRS, Photomode comp., Drifting, Racing, Etc. it doesn't get boring even with the lack of online racing. (excluding Xlink)
 
Forza>GT4
 
Forza's addition of Ferrari and Porsche does make a difference. Forza also did a better job in the graphics, mostly with textures and surface quality, but the cars dont look quite as crisp as those found in GT4. The car's feeling between the games is very different, Forza doing a better job overall with tire wear and weight distrobution (owed to the XBOX's power), but lost out to GT4's attention to detail in the way the cars would react to imputs from the driver.

GT4 may be a superior product in many peoples opinion, and the same can be said for Forza. Be thankful that there is competiton for the title of "Best Sim Racer," because as we have seen with Madden NFL, programmers get sloppy when they are the only ones out there.
 
Forza>GT4

Forza might be the better "racing game", but GT4 is the much, much better "driving simulator". Take any car and go to the Nurburging for one lap. Night and day difference, even with an ordinary pad. For me this is more inportant than an AI (GT4 has the worst AI of all racing games). GT4 + DFP > any other racing game (including PC games).
 
GT4 + DFP > any other racing game (including PC games).

You obviously aint played GT Legends.

Gt is hardly all that, it saps the fun and excitement out of driving. The cars feel far to tame.
 
GT4 did do a petter job with the capture of the Nordshelife, I'll give them that. Although, they fixed that problem in PGR3...
 
YSSMAN
Forza's addition of Ferrari and Porsche does make a difference. Forza also did a better job in the graphics, mostly with textures and surface quality, but the cars dont look quite as crisp as those found in GT4. The car's feeling between the games is very different, Forza doing a better job overall with tire wear and weight distrobution (owed to the XBOX's power), but lost out to GT4's attention to detail in the way the cars would react to imputs from the driver.

GT4 may be a superior product in many peoples opinion, and the same can be said for Forza. Be thankful that there is competiton for the title of "Best Sim Racer," because as we have seen with Madden NFL, programmers get sloppy when they are the only ones out there.
Ferrais, and Prosches are fun, but those to companys can't make a game.

EDIT: LOOK AT THE POLL!!! GT4 has out beaten what i thought a biased comp. Well i gues we see what peoples favorite games is. :D
 
well technically its on a GT board so its a little biased both ways.
 
GTR should be an option. :cool:
 
Damn you took the words right out of my mouth.

GTR>GT4>Forza
 
194GVan
well technically its on a GT board so its a little biased both ways.
well technically it's on a xbox boared thats in a GT4 forum. :D
 
Back