This ignores the grip of each car which varies tremendously. You can have a 100pp difference, or more, in some cars with the same power and weight. Set up a GR3 car and a street car to the same weight and power and watch how the GR3 destroys the street car.
Yes, because in the lobbies it is strictly PP. With Sophy, you can equalize other factors to achieve a better balance.
As I mentioned regarding the GR3, make them all the same downforce. When balancing for Sophy, try to keep the cars relatively close on all the stats (grip, power, and weight), then adjust slightly for the PP target.
In the screen below, you can see how I set the downforce to 400/700 (399/699 and I will explain in a moment). Generally speaking, this is what you want for whatever field of cars you are assembling. Try to keep their downforce as similar as possible. Do this first.
Then, every car should get the ballast and the power restrictor. This will allow you to fine tune the power and weight. What I do is reduce the power on both the "output adjustment" and "power restrictor" until I get as close to 700pp as possible without going under (or whatever your target is). Then, increase the weight. This is usually enough.
In the example below, the move between 30 and 31 kg made a big difference to PP. So, I reduce the rear downforce by 1 step, which increased the PP slightly, then adjusted the front downforce 1 step, which decreased the PP, and boom. 700.01 pp
This provides the best balance possible next to driving the same cars. That said, you will likely still be much faster than Sophy.
View attachment 1456421
IMHO the Sophy races are better with lower grip cars, such as the street cars or converted race cars. For instance, this converted 512 is an analog to the current GR3 cars. It's 700pp and you can create a field of these types that is much more entertaining and challenging than the actual GR3 cars. More power, less weight, and MUCH less grip which makes the cars move around and adds an element of unpredictability. Of course, this does take more work since you have to buy the car and add all the parts.
View attachment 1456422