The walk controls are they way they are so that you can use the analog sticks for whatever context actions there are. It works, but there should be a way to pan around the character for many places.
Twister with your fingers? I have to admit to using a chin or nose more than once when I wasn't using the appendages they had planned for me to use. I certainly consider Heavy Rain to be at least a 9.
Except you still use the sticks to turn just not to walk forward. Which begs the question: why the heck not? I mean if I use the left stick to turn, why can't I use that same stick to move forwards? Essentially, walking was like walking through a never ending maze, it would be a heck of a lot better. And the button sequencing...is on random. WTF? Who puts a button sequences on random? Then you get the weird, twister-like, cramp inducing button combos in Heavy Rain. Not all of them are on Random. But there there are enough that are to make it irritating. And then there are the useless scenes...or at least scenes that make you go, "Why am I controlling this person?" Like the kid scene. The kid was dead and buried, so you know how that scene was going to turn out, and it teases you with all these opportunities to kill your character, but you know you can't 'cause then it would mess up the whole sequence. And so you just wonder why they didn't make that a long cutscene? Or a short one? I mean, you knew the kids were going to be messing around and Johnny was going to fall in a drain or something and drowned.
And then there's Madison. I mean, what exactly is her part in the whole story anyway? I'm like halfway through the game, and so far she's helped Ethan (kinda important to the story but could be explained off in other ways) and gotten naked. What exactly is her role in the story other than being the sexy woman? I hope she does more than take off her clothes every time you see her and contributes more to the story.
I also love how the guys get all the "maybe if I create a diversion...or complicated missions, and the best idea Madison could come up with for the club was: "Oh, I'll flirt with this guy and shake my ass." In fact, all the women so far have been a little weak.
There are good things about this game, and the visuals are awesome, and the story alone is worth buying the game, but there are some things that kinda ruin the story.
to be had.
Only for fat PS3 owners though, slim users can play. 
