I'm willing to take on a big task: Discuss: New Reputation Thread

[JK83]

So happy im in the OP with 2 successful trades.
Hope im a trusted trader now.....

Pity the other 600 trades arent listed.....

I think that is enought for you
I got clear ZERO trades succesful but like you know donation isnt trade
Where is donator reputation thread? You can maybe make big ask for mods and get sticky for it rightaway

 

[ryanerb]

Funny... Hundreds of trades and donations and I'm not even in the OP

 

[ryanerb]

I guess we all have to come up with arbitrary numbers to reestablish the long term traders reputations...

Good thing between all of us we know. Even if personally we haven't all traded as Chris stated by those traders that had positives with others that we trust. Trust by affiliation.

 

[werty_56-1]

I only gave a few billions plus to mike because thanks to his remote races I bought my 1st x2010 in red met. (20 mill )

And yes it's weird but I think (not sure) it's because , following that example but using also a new member , people gave sharky a +1000 because he's here for about a year or more and he has always been a great trader , while the new member gets a +1 well , because he's a new member

 

[ryanerb]

I only gave a few billions plus to mike because thanks to his remote races I bought my 1st x2010 in red met. (20 mill )

And yes it's weird but I think (not sure) it's because , following that example but using also a new member , people gave sharky a +1000 because he's here for about a year or more and he has always been a great trader , while the new member gets a +1 well , because he's a new member

And I understand that but I have 1 PS3 and simply can't move the volume he does nor can most. So it shows that the numbers themselves mean very little really.

What is needed to know is how each trader works... Easy to communicate, fast, reliable, slow but traded, fixed problems, failed to respond etc..

 

[werty_56-1]

Yes and a OP that's regulary updated , I only wanted that , I even PM'ed Mods and screamed to GM lol

 

[ryanerb]

But in the OP it says no negative. What's more important is knowing the negatives and how they were handled. The original thread had negatives and the trader in question openly communicating to resolve the dispute on the thread. That meant it was a mistake that was fixed. I've made mistakes a few times and bent over backwards to make it right. So that discussion is valid too IMO.

I've stated my opinion and I will end my portion of it in this thread before I get warned for off topic chatting.

I hope this works out and is kept up as well...

 

[cbarbosa]

And I understand that but I have 1 PS3 and simply can't move the volume he does nor can most. So it shows that the numbers themselves mean very little really.

What is needed to know is how each trader works... Easy to communicate, fast, reliable, slow but traded, fixed problems, failed to respond etc..

This means that the old thread made more sense then this one?
So the important is to qualify the trade no to quantify it...

Just a modest opinion, i´ve been aside this discussion, but one thing is certain, i will not leave feedback in this new reputation thread because I believe its wrong to use a scale to measure a trade. 👎

 

[werty_56-1]

But in the OP it says no negative. What's more important is knowing the negatives and how they were handled. The original thread had negatives and the trader in question openly communicating to resolve the dispute on the thread. That meant it was a mistake that was fixed. I've made mistakes a few times and bent over backwards to make it right. So that discussion is valid too IMO.

And it would be better , as you said to put the truth , if he scamm , negative , and it could be better too if in case someone scamm us , we could explain why.

Soo other members know bettter the person that they gonna trade e.g.:

ryanerb

good trades: 5

bad trades : 2

Observations : he scammed werty_56-1 , by not acomplished his part of the deal .


Just a e.g. , how I would like to be done , soo the traders could go trade with
the "trading history" of the person they gonna trade.

 

[christara321]

Well these people have done excellent trades with me. if i have missed you please contact me so i can update this.
TwinsPoppa x5, GDB420 x3, J19NYB x4, Chqr, CMoe x5, speedy233, Urlik x2, STEG-13 x3, andy54321 x3, Madmyk, go4gold x2, Riyebow x11, Gamewarrior14 x5, Breezeblock95 x4, Beane13 x2, J19NYB x3, Reidy_17, MustangRyan x5, HrcBoy x2, atomicnmd x10, Igwyana x3, ch1potle x200, Natt x30, Monatsende x4, Jables72 x50+, HOODFIELD x5, cryptomanic (sent all Gear), AFTAC99104

Hi mate for some reason this was posted quite early in this thread and bares no reflection in the SCORING system in the OP (original post) that now is in place.?
Think people need to see how its working before posting.?
I understand and most people do, that x6 means 6 trades but thats not how the thing looks in OP?
Chat soon bye for now mate.


_______________________________
@ Thread
While am at it, Just out of curiousity.
Sent a person on GTPlanet 1250-ish Suits and Helmets today.
Can you translate that into a score. I ask simply because of the first part of my post?
I see every single item you send a person counts as a single trade. Regardless of who you send too.
And do not add it has a trade into any system in the OP please. Thank you.
Take it more has an exquirey rather than a trade.
Bye for now.

 

[spikeyhairdude]

Hi mate for some reason this was posted quite early in this thread and bares no reflection in the SCORING system in the OP (original post) that now is in place.?
Think people need to see how its working before posting.?
I understand and most people do, that x6 means 6 trades but thats not how the thing looks in OP?
Chat soon bye for now mate.


_______________________________
@ Thread
While am at it, Just out of curiousity.
Sent a person on GTPlanet 1250-ish Suits and Helmets today.
Can you translate that into a score. I ask simply because of the first part of my post?
I see every single item you send a person counts as a single trade. Regardless of who you send too.
And do not add it has a trade into any system in the OP please. Thank you.
Take it more has an exquirey rather than a trade.
Bye for now.

I just copied it from my trading thread. So i know who i did good trades with. is this a problem?

 

[latoslapise]

I believe he is still updating the thread, and taking the previous scores from the past thread, if you look at the names on the OP you will notice that some names are for people who are not around here anymore or they are their old names. I believe in a previous post somebody asked of their name could be changed because they no longer use that one. With all that in consideration and considering the number of pages on the old thread, I feel it is going to take a couple days before you see the stuff you posted now in the OP

 

[christara321]

I just copied it from my trading thread. So i know who i did good trades with. is this a problem?

No mate just read it again and understand what I mean.
x6 means 6 trades.

But you have put x what ever on many names and it doesn,t reflect what is wrote in OP?
Chat soon bye for now.

ch1potle -2*
Natt -2*

ch1potle x200, Natt x30, Monatsende x4, Jables72 x50+,
Just a little example of what you wrote.? Surely it should Chip with 200 in the OP?
And Natt should be 30?

 

[werty_56-1]

I believe he is still updating the thread, and taking the previous scores from the past thread, if you look at the names on the OP you will notice that some names are for people who are not around here anymore or they are their old names. I believe in a previous post somebody asked of their name could be changed because they no longer use that one. With all that in consideration and considering the number of pages on the old thread, I feel it is going to take a couple days before you see the stuff you posted now in the OP

Right , Nick i'm Carl3456 / werty_56-1

 

[Rayzah]

Right , Nick i'm Carl3456 / werty_56-1

Seriously? How the heck did I not catch that? Is it a new alias for the drag strip?

 

[werty_56-1]

Seriously? How the heck did I not catch that? Is it a new alias for the drag strip?

Yes lol

 

[christara321]

Hello Moderators or Nicksfix is there any chance you could put a close on this thread until Nicksfix gets a chance to update the Original post with what information he is gathering from the old thread and give us the nesscerary information, And then we may be a little bit more clearer and see how this works.
Rather than me or anyone elses comes in and gives more opinions and trade completions.?
Thanks bye for now.

 

[latoslapise]

Hello Moderators or Nicksfix is there any chance you could put a close on this thread until Nicksfix gets a chance to update the Original post with what information he is gathering from the old thread and give us the nesscerary information, And then we may be a little bit more clearer and see how this works.
Rather than me or anyone elses comes in and gives more opinions and trade completions.?
Thanks bye for now.

I'm not sure if a thread can be updated if it is closed. Not to sound rude but if you feel unclear about something you should always ask questions to the source rather then just going off of misunderstood notions and rumors but yea I feel as though if we just put up our trade completions they will eventually be reflected in the OP. but if you don't want to post if you don't want too or just wait until it becomes more clearer that is alright 👍 I personally will just post mine because as you can see there is no other thread and I like to give credit where credit is due

 

[spikeyhairdude]

Another thing. Why doesnt people just search the thread. type in the user name and search and it will show whoevers typed there name so we all know whos done good trades or bad. This is what i do before tradeing with someone new.

 

[latoslapise]

Another thing. Why doesnt people just search the thread. type in the user name and search and it will show whoevers typed there name so we all know whos done good trades or bad. This is what i do before tradeing with someone new.

That is a really great idea, but I'm guessing they want to make it really simple for people. By making it so that all they have to do is go to the OP to check peoples trade status. but like Chris said simple is not always better, because you'll be missing a lot of important details.like people failing a trade but making up for it. So basically what it's going to come down to is that you still are going to have to do your research but hey at least it will be up to date 👍

 

[crang08]

I've done hundreds of trades and had a good reputation in the old thread, in here my name isn't anywhere. Doesn't really help me as i'm slowing down my trading ;(

 

[christara321]

Another thing. Why doesnt people just search the thread. type in the user name and search and it will show whoevers typed there name so we all know whos done good trades or bad. This is what i do before tradeing with someone new.

I think you will find thats how the old thread worked.?

I'm not sure if a thread can be updated if it is closed. Not to sound rude but if you feel unclear about something you should always ask questions to the source rather then just going off of misunderstood notions and rumors but yea I feel as though if we just put up our trade completions they will eventually be reflected in the OP. but if you don't want to post if you don't want too or just wait until it becomes more clearer that is alright 👍 I personally will just post mine because as you can see there is no other thread and I like to give credit where credit is due

While I and others do not need to post while the move over takes place it seems that every one wants to still keep posting but thats just adding to the work load of Nicksfix.
I will also point out that with looking at Nicksfix RED name you have the power to open and close your threads.
So while the update is going and I suggest to speed up the process he simply puts a lock on it so a lot of people are NOT making it a longer process that it already is.
When are people just going to understand some one instead of reading between the lines.?
I really can not understand some people here at times.?
Tell you what why don,t we all just jump in the old thread copy all our crap and just paste it here saves a bunch off work or might just inundate him with more.
Bye for now.

I've done hundreds of trades and had a good reputation in the old thread, in here my name isn't anywhere. Doesn't really help me as i'm slowing down my trading ;(

OMGosh kiss that ticket goodbye. BAD trader alert.
Laters mate bye for now.

 

[mikeeesf]

Why doesn't someone start a thread to iron out what people would like to see in a reputation thread, the other thread needed to go, many people didn't use it. the bogus ratings like mikeeesf +100 when I only traded one time is an example.

Another thought is there some kind of formula/spreadsheet that could make ratings/system more automatic than one person manually updating

 

[christara321]

Why doesn't someone start a thread to iron out what people would like to see in a reputation thread, the other thread needed to go, many people didn't use it. the bogus ratings like mikeeesf +100 when I only traded one time is an example.

Another thought is there some kind of formula/spreadsheet that could make ratings/system more automatic than one person manually updating

https://www.gtplanet.net/forum/showthread.php?t=238959
Your post debate.?

Has for the scoring system. My OPINION pretty useless all you need to see was you did a trade, FULL STOP.
Thats what speaks volumes. You can be trusted thats how the old thread should of and did work.?

It was more than self sufficient. It just didn,t need a score it just needed to show A traded with with B, Then people saw A and B could be trusted.?

 

[werty_56-1]

Why doesn't someone start a thread to iron out what people would like to see in a reputation thread, the other thread needed to go, many people didn't use it. the bogus ratings like mikeeesf +100 when I only traded one time is an example.

Another thought is there some kind of formula/spreadsheet that could make ratings/system more automatic than one person manually updating

That was me I think

 

[spikeyhairdude]

That is a really great idea, but I'm guessing they want to make it really simple for people. By making it so that all they have to do is go to the OP to check peoples trade status. but like Chris said simple is not always better, because you'll be missing a lot of important details.like people failing a trade but making up for it. So basically what it's going to come down to is that you still are going to have to do your research but hey at least it will be up to date 👍

Watch how it going to have so many names and it would be impossibe to find someones name.

If people search the thread then there would be no need of having someone edit this thread.

 

[crang08]

OMGosh kiss that ticket goodbye. BAD trader alert.
Laters mate bye for now.

well I don't see your name in here so you can kiss those cars I owe you goodbye as your not trusted

 

[christara321]

well I don't see your name in here so you can kiss those cars I owe you goodbye as your not trusted

Oh man thats it were going to have to start our own REP thread so we can get that trade done mate.
Chat soon bye for now.

 

[latoslapise]

I think you will find thats how the old thread worked.?

While I and others do not need to post while the move over takes place it seems that every one wants to still keep posting but thats just adding to the work load of Nicksfix.
I will also point out that with looking at Nicksfix RED name you have the power to open and close your threads.
So while the update is going and I suggest to speed up the process he simply puts a lock on it so a lot of people are NOT making it a longer process that it already is.
When are people just going to understand some one instead of reading between the lines.?
I really can not understand some people here at times.?
Tell you what why don,t we all just jump in the old thread copy all our crap and just paste it here saves a bunch off work or might just inundate him with more.
Bye for now.

OMGosh kiss that ticket goodbye. BAD trader alert.
Laters mate bye for now.

Well thanks for the info about closing and reopening threads 👍 but yea it would be a good idea, but then again the info still will need to be updated into the OP so regardless it still will need to be put on here. But yea like mike said why don't people make a thread or use the debate thread to address their issues or to seek clarification rather then turning our only rep thread into this. Which is only making it more difficult for Nick to update by making him sift through countless pages that have absolutely nothing to do with unsuccessful or successful trades. Just my opinion though

 

[latoslapise]

Watch how it going to have so many names and it would be impossibe to find someones name.

If people search the thread then there would be no need of having someone edit this thread.

True true but at least you'll have your name on the OP and the score will be current and that my friend is called "winning" just ask charlie