POLL: Rate GT5 on a scale of 0-10 (details inside)

  • Thread starter Thread starter XxOnLySBz4mExX
  • 263 comments
  • 19,234 views

On a scale of 1-10 I would give Gran Turismo 5 a . . .

  • Total voters
    1,041
This poll is a joke. It should be from 7-10 scale đź’ˇ

Anything less than it is BS because as far as content, variety, gameplay goes it is miles ahead of the competition
 
kimi123
This poll is a joke. It should be from 7-10 scale đź’ˇ

Anything less than it is BS because as far as content, variety, gameplay goes it is miles ahead of the competition
Click to expand...

That's an opinion and as such can't be wrong, great thing about that is neither can those that disagree with you.

Scaff
 
Scaff
That's an opinion and as such can't be wrong, great thing about that is neither can those that disagree with you.

Scaff
Click to expand...

I am not saying anyone opnion is wrong. I am giving my opnion on why this poll is a joke. Just like how is said in the other thread that best sim on consoles rather than best console physics.
 
With how much GT5 has changed with the updates, this poll is pointless. It shouldn't be taken seriously, because of people's "opinions" differing too greatly.

The 0/10's and 10/10's are opinions so if someone were to ask if this is a credibly tallied poll, I would say no. The voters can't justify how they rated a game 0/10 or a perfect score.
 
7

-1 sound accuracy issues and static premium car dials
-0.5 GT auto "animations' get annoying after the 1st 3 cars
-0.5 lack of premium Astons/Shelbys/Maseratis/Rufs etc and standard Veyron/XFR/Furai
-1 no time/weather on most tracks and many missing tracks

Like most long time GT players I find the design oversights in GT5 annoying despite the amount of GT games made. That said it still is my favourite car sim of all time (narrowly beating NFS5 - Porsche fan!).
 
G24
It's been a year already and I'm still playing GT5 2-4 hours everyday! Any game that keeps me this interested deserves a 10/10
Click to expand...

I'm the same (though only had the game for 9 months). Sure there are other things that would be nice but wouldn't necessarily make the game better. There are a couple of things that are keeping me going at the moment, currently lvl38 A and 36 B, working towards 40 for both. And I am also busy collecting cars, up to around 730 standard ones (I am leaving the premiums until last as they are always in the NCD.

Perhaps once I have levels 40 and all cars, I may not play as often. I have GTA4 waiting for me, I thought I would have played more than I have, but each time I have PS3 time I keep going back to GT...
 
Comparing it to other games, I would give it 10/10, 100/100, 1000/1000.
But it has flaws, especially the A-Spec/B-Spec career. So I voted 9.0-9.5
 
Bumpedie bump.

I think now that it is more or less known GT5 support regarding updates and DLC have come to a halt, and also because most of us have played it since 2010, it is opportune to give what is a final rating of the game.

My rating = 7.8.

The score mostly reaching that number due to the moments of joy driving a premium on circuits like spa, le mans or nur, with the great physics model.

2.2 deducted because it failed as a game, as nothing really changed or improved since GT's PS2 installments apart from the physics model and 300 cars being updated to premium class ...
 
Its still great after almost two years although it has been showing its age for the past few months.
 
8.5-9/10. It is a great game, but as we know, some of the things are just not there.

Edit: What trolls picked 0-0.5? :lol:
 
It's alright to post?

I've dropped my rating of 8.25 from 1 of the other threads to 7.125. (Yes, exactly that.)

I spammed the game during my holidays a while after setting up my account here. I tested each premo road car for about 10 minutes each on Route X.

I've long realised that there are flaws in most cars, both in the 'driving' and the 'visual' category. But for only this number of premos, I expect as close to perfection as possible.

Despite the high poly count, there are still problems with how some cars look. For instance, the diameters and offsets of wheels are off and specifications like wheelbases, track widths and ride heights being a bit too high or low. And specific cases like the R8 V10 having the wrong lights and the MP4-12C and LP560-4's spoiler not tilting up at speed. (The former works properly as the air-brake though.)

Then you have cockpits that look low poly even when they are actually not thanks to awkward camera positioning and gauges that work on some cars and don't on others. (Fuel, oil pressure, turbo boost, odometers, clocks etc)

Then there are some cars that have simulated dual clutch or torque converter automatics and others which should but don't.

Thus, the big problem with GT5 is inconsistency, even with its premiums. I do suspect some amount of mismanagement in development.

The really annoying part is that the only 'bug' in any of these categories fixed since launch is with the DLC GTR Black Edition's DCT.
 
Last edited:
I gave it a 6.5 -7 because its lacking alotta stuff i already have in other sim games that gt should have had and didnt like tire pressure adjustments... (need i say more)
 
kimi123
This poll is a joke. It should be from 7-10 scale đź’ˇ

Anything less than it is BS because as far as content, variety, gameplay goes it is miles ahead of the competition
Click to expand...

đź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Žđź‘Ž
 
8.5 - 9

The Good

Great physics improvement over GT4 that captures the different handling characteristics of all the cars from oversteer to understeer and all the little details.

The Nurburgring is amazing in GT5. The time and weather change are great to look at and enjoy when driving.

Life like graphics that can fool you into believing its real

The Bad

Big markoffs for being incomplete even to this day. Different cars show varying levels of damage detail that require stupid amounts of crashing to show, and the pit crews dont even fix visible damage. Roll over physics are so poor they probably shouldn't have been implemented.

The leveling system is awful. Its too easy to level up early on and too hard to level up later. Why only 40 levels instead of 100 we will never know. This system also forces an insane amount of grinding

A-Spec events lack any depth or variety. Its too easy to just walk in with a car twice as powerful and with half the weight of the competition and smoke everyone. The championships like NASCAR and Super GT just give you a small taste of each. At least make the races long enough to require a pit stop.

Numerous graphical errors and problems like the pixelating when it rains

The track editor is poor at best

Customization hasn't gotten any better. There is the paint chip thing but thats a pain.

Endurance Races are mostly copy paste from previous GT games and feature bizarre design choices like sportscars at the Indy 500 or prototypes at the Nurburgring, something that the real world hasn't seen in what, 35 years?

Almost endless amounts of bad design choices, like the credit limit and making license tests useless.

You really have to scratch your head and wonder what were they thinking.
 
My personal opinion is a 5/10. How can the game get any higher marks when it was released totally unfinished? The updates and patches still are a far cry from making this game even remotely complete. Too many complex problems that they cant and wont fix because it would take too much time away from other projects they have. It has its good points but what it lacks way outweighs its solid points imho.
 
Something that you enjoyed[1] every day/week for the past 20 months cannot be wrong[2].

[1]. Enjoyed not played. Because if you didn't enjoy it, you won't be playing it.
[2]. Since you are still playing it, it means you don't want to be right. So not only you enjoyed it, you LOVED it. (If loving you is wrong, I don't want to be right).

Then how can something you love is a fail[3]?

[3]. Anything lower than a 7 is a fail.
 
Although I love this game and recently I play it a lot of time... I give it 7-7.5. Graphics are nice but it's not a huge difference from GT4 (I don't talk about premium cars which are indeed very nice). Many tracks are taken from GT4. 800 cars are taken from GT4 (it's not a problem for me, but they could make them more detailed and with interiors - even in poor quality it still could be better than this black space around you when you drive a standard with interior cam).
What I mean is that GT5 is taking too much from GT4 without adding many new things. It's like GT4.5 converted from PS2 to PS3 with couple of new features so people can't complain it's the same game.
Also:
- too many asian cars (I don't say I don't like them, I just don't see a point in giving over 9000 Toyotas and Nissans and just one Seat. This is sick)
- menu. It can look nice and very distinguished but it's not very handy
- loading times

But it has a nice soundtrack :D

Probably I play it just because it's the only driving game for PS3 that simulates real drive. And I still like it very much. It's like playing Bethesda games - you know how many things are ****ed up and how many bugs it has, but you still love it :D
 
Just voted - It ain't perfect but I don't let the bad things get in the way of the Good STuff.

And Bethesda Games - After Skyrim I can't drive Eiger without wanting to pick the stupid track side flowers on the corner apex...
 
I've been playing Gran Turismo 5 now since November 2010 and so far it has become my all time favourite Gran Turismo game on any Playstation format and it's been my favourite because I get to drive some of the best cars on the planet and the ability to add more content is good but I think it needs a bit more improvement to give it a final bow before GT6 sometime soon.

I give it 9/10

I hope there is more in this game soon? I love the tracks and the cars but I wish there was a bit more.
 
2010 - 8.0/10

2012 - doesn't matter

I don't agree with people judging the game twice, with the second being a rating of what it eventually became after a couple years of updates. Games are and should only be rated on release day. If a movie hits theaters this weekend and it sucks, we can't judge it higher because maybe a couple years down the road a director's cut will be released on Blu-ray with edits making the film somewhat better. What it is upon release is what it is and what it gets judged on. Besides, if it's going to get judged post-updates, then it also needs the rating scale to adjust for comparison versus games released since its release, namely FM4, which improved upon FM3 pretty substantially, and FM3 rated above GT5. So, if GT5 is to gain fractions of a point because of its updates, at the same time it must lose points for falling farther behind the Forza series during that time period.

Why did I go with just an 8? Well, it only has 220+ GT5 car models, versus FM3 which had 400+ cars (not counting subsequent DLC), and note that this ignores FM4 and its 500+ cars (not including DLC) that came along a year later. Some of the tracks are last-gen models, too, which hurts. There were some graphic bugs holding it back a bit there. The menu design was horrid. Basic stuff like painting my car was unnecessarily made a tedious chore. They wasted the Top Gear license. Importantly, the game was missing features while only boasting (versus the other guys) stuff that was poorly implemented (track editor could produce tracks that we couldn't share with all 6+ million players). The game can't have all these strikes against it and still rate closer to Forza... unless we're going to score Forza higher than 10.
 
8-8.5 Very Good game, but needs more A-spec and some problems resolved. And the people who have given it 0-1 and are clearly trolling, even the harshest of critics would realistically rate it well above that.
 
finnracer
8-8.5 Very Good game, but needs more A-spec and some problems resolved. And the people who have given it 0-1 and are clearly trolling, even the harshest of critics would realistically rate it well above that.
Click to expand...

Likewise so are the people rating it 9.5 - 10. Because to claim this game was perfect or very near perfect is ridiculous.
 
8.5 - 9.0

Liked the game a lot, but it isn't the best. Needs more events and a broader car range.
 
7
Worst Gran Turismo title by far(excluding Prologues,GT:Tokyo Show HD whatever that **** was)
Huge disappointment,gets boring really quick.:indiff:
 

Latest Posts

Back