If it matters to you, there are plenty of movie fans at GTP who feel the way you do about the prequels. Just go back and read this entire thread. Duke and danoff in particular are not fans of Lucas' recent work and even though we agree on a lot of things, Star Wars is not one of them.
IMO, the reason why so many 20-30 somethings hate the prequels so much is because they had unreasonable expectations of what the experience should have been. This is because we ('we' as in an entire generation of people who grew up on the OT) went to the see the PT expecting the SAME kind of experience we felt when we saw the originals the first time.
That's foolish, IMO. The first time most of us saw the OT, we were children. Our standard of judging what constitutes good entertainment was woefully lower back then. In the 80s, I myself thought 'Knight Rider' was actually a good show. I wouldn't have been caught dead watching Citizen Kane or Casablanca, much less appreciating them.
20 years later should we expect to react to a movie the same way we did when we were 7 or 8? Of course we shouldnt. Our tastes change. They develop and grow. The OT was fun and entertaining, but not exactly high-class film-making. Lucas himself called them an homage to old B-movies. He didn't turn his back on us. He's telling the same old hookey space opera he's been for a quarter century.
We left him.
If you can honestly say this is a better decision than appeasing everyone, which would not be difficult to do at all in this case, then you are truly among the lost ones.
Save your condesending arrogance for some chump who buys it, pal. The only person lost here is you. I don't have a problem with the fact that you want the original films on DVD. I have a problem with the fact that you think Lucas owes it to you. Lucas doesnt owe you anything. He is not in the business of making you happy. Not selling you the original films on DVD doesnt make him a bad person. It doesnt make him "a schmuck" or "asinine" or "a con-man".
But what blows my mind is that you want a DVD set from Lucas so bad you make a series of personal attacks on him for not giving you what you want, but at the same time you call him a money grubber with dollar signs in his eyes. How convenient; if he sells something you want its cool. But if he sells something you dont want, you 'smell a scheme' and call him a greedy bastard. Gimme a break. If you don't think it's completely transparent what a childish attitude this is, you are wrong. 👎
Look, just leave it at this: You dont want this version of the OT, so dont buy it. Believe me, no one is going to lose any sleep over it but you. But dont bother coming in here and try to convince me that Im a fool or a slave for want a copy of this or that Lucas is some sort of bad guy because hes not giving you something you want. It just aint gonna fly.
M