What about Sakurasou and Tonari no Kaibutsu-kun? I notice that they're not on your list, and they're probably the best shows of the season IMO. I don't know how you'll feel about Sakurasou, but Tonari no Kaibutsu-kun is very much in the vein of "Say I love You," but I think it's the better show.
I need to check those two out, but it'll have to wait until January as I can't really fit in any more shows right now.
K 6: Oh look, a plot is finally beginning to surface...or not. Next episode preview shows Neko running around naked, oh joy, more stupid fanservice...
Magi 5: This show is beginning to fall apart, damn you pacing. As I heard, with just the first 3 episodes, they covered 17 chapters as they're trying to cover just about everything (150+ chapters) in the 26 episodes they're given... Please don't be another Black Cat.
Psycho-Pass 5: Do you want to be good again? The last couple of minutes are hinting towards going further into Kogami's backstory. Hopefully it happens, that's one thing this show has really struggled with, good backstory. We need more on all the main characters.
Almost done with Black Lagoon: The Second Barrage, and it's beginning to fall apart a bit with the final couple of episodes, sigh.
Seems the Reborn! manga has now truly ended. After more than 8 years, 409 chapters, and 42 volumes, it has come to an end. Heard things were rushed a bit, and that the ending is kind of open. I wonder if this meant that Amano wanted to continue the story further, but WSJ forced her to end it?
http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2012-11-07/reborn-manga-to-end-in-weekly-shonen-jump-on-monday
The series had been ranking low in the reader surveys for a while IIRC, but it did great in graphic novel sales (Another Psyren case?). Last year it placed 17th for best-selling manga of 2011.
http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2011-11-30/top-selling-manga-in-japan-by-series/2011
Anyway, whenever Amano's next series begins, definitely going to check that out on day 1. I really wonder what she has in store.