Would you rather?

  • Thread starter motortrend
  • 22,046 comments
  • 1,099,198 views
2013-audi-rs5-2011-bmw-m3-cadillac-cts-v-front-2.jpg


Or

2013-audi-rs5-2011-bmw-m3-cadillac-front-3.jpg


Or

2013-audi-rs5-2011-bmw-m3-cadillac-cts-v-front-4.jpg


I'm taking the Caddy, even though it's not the sedan.
 
Audi A2 vs Mercedes-Benz A-Class vs Lancia Y; Audi A2 without a doubt.

Luxury Sport Coupes; Cadillac CTS-V actually. Though, it's in a different class from the other 2 cars. Just saying.
 
2015 BMW M4:
2015-bmw-m4-convertible-images-35-750x500.jpg


2015 Audi RS5:

2015-Audi-Rs5-Release.jpg


2015 Cadillac CTS-V:

2015-Cadillac-CTS-Picture.jpg


Or 2015 Jaguar F-Type:
jaguar-f-type-coupe.654x436.Nov-19-2013_22.39.16.712349.jpg
Not including the CTS-V since it's a render, the M4.

Results:
1. BMW M4
2. Audi RS5
3. Jaguar F-Type

Luxury convertibles:

Aston-Martin-DB9-Volante-36-photos.jpg


ferrari-california-t-625x323.jpg


Bentley-Continental_GT_Speed_Convertible_2014_1600x1200_wallpaper_0f.jpg
That's really hard. I guess I'll take the Aston.

Results:
1. Aston Martin DB9 Volante
2. Bentley Continental GT Speed Convertible
3. Ferrari California T

American icons:

hrdp_1002_07_o%2B1967_ford%2Bmustang.jpg


69camaro.jpg


292001-870-0.jpg
Challenger, easily.

Results:
1. Dodge Challenger R/T
2. Ford Mustang GT
3. Chevrolet Camaro SS
American icons round 2:

47_163_1960_CHEVROLET_CORVETTE_1.jpg


ford__thunderbird_1960_1_lgw.jpg


1960_Plymouth_Fury.jpg
The Vette, easily as well.

Results:
1. Chevrolet Corvette
2. Ford Thunderbird
3. Plymouth Fury
American icons round 3:

cadillac-el-dorado-1975_1.jpg


1975_Lincoln_Continental_Mark_IV,_Dutch_licence_registration_05-YB-59_p1.JPG
The Lincoln.

Results:
1. Lincoln Continental Mark
2. Cadillac Eldorado
American icons round 4: final showdown.

2010shelbygt500fdp1_30_opta.jpg


2012-chevrolet-camaro-zl1-9_653.jpg
Extremely hard, but I'll take the Camaro.
Family sedans:

2014_nissan_altima_sedan_35-sl_fq_oem_6_815.jpg


2014-Accord-PHEV-550x308.jpg

Altima. The Accord PHEV is ugly.
I'll take the Megane RS, LaFerrari, the F-Type, the Vanquish Volante, the Challenger R/T, the C1 Corvette, the Lincoln Continental, the Camaro ZL1, and the Accord.



A Selection of Ungainly-looking Ferraris


Ferrari 330 GT Navarro Special
1966_Ferrari_330_GT_2+25DA.jpg



or


Ferrari 410 Superamerica Ghia Coupé
56ghia_ferrari_410_superamerica_31.jpg



or


Ferrari FZ93
Ferrari-FZ93_2.jpg
The FZ93. It actually looks pretty cool.

Results:
1. Ferrari FZ93
2. Ferrari 410 Superamerica Ghia Coupe
3. Ferrari 330 GT Navarro Special
Luxury hatchbacks:

Audi A3
View attachment 237644

BMW 1-Series
View attachment 237646

Mercedes Benz A-Class
View attachment 237645
A-Class, but the A3 was really close.
Tesla Model S P85D (691hp, 687 lb ft)
Model_S_P85D-sm.jpg


vs

Dodge Charger SRT Hellcat (707hp, 650 lb ft)
15-ld-ex-3.jpg.pagespeed.ce.xuPXOcb3LF.jpg
Tesla, and I'll make it look a bit less sleeper-ish.
Honestly I'm not interested in any of those, but I'll go with the Nissan.

Results:
1. Nissan GT-R
2. Lamborghini Gallardo
3. Dodge Viper SRT10 ACR
30's American luxury cars:

1930 Cadillac V16.
cadillac-v16-1930.jpg


1930 Buick Series 60.
30-Buick_Series69_num287_DV-07-MBA_04.jpg


Lincoln Zephyr. Exact year I don't know, but definitely 30's.
Zephyr-1.jpg


1940 (only one I could find) Mercury something.
Mercury_Sedan_Coupe_1940_Rick_Feibusch_2010.jpg
Cadillac. I can't pass up a V16 engined car.

Results:
1. Cadillac V16
2. Mercury
3. Lincoln Zephyr
4. Buick Series 60

Foreign 1930's luxury cars:

1930 Mercedes Type 770.
30_Mercedes_770K_VR_CL_DV-06_PB_01.jpg


1930-ish BMW 327.
BMW_Museum_2012_37.jpg
The Bimmer, looks smoother.
1930's Bentley vs Rolls Royce.

Phantom II:

30rollsphantomII4.jpg


Or

8 Liter.
1930-bentley-8-litre-1-lg.jpg
The Phantom, for the same reason as above.
Early 00s luxury superminis:

Audi A2
View attachment 237920

Lancia Y
View attachment 237921

Mercedes-Benz A-Class
View attachment 237922
The Audi. I love that car.

Results:
1. Audi A2
2. Mercedes-Benz A-Class
3. Lancia Y
2013-audi-rs5-2011-bmw-m3-cadillac-cts-v-front-2.jpg


Or

2013-audi-rs5-2011-bmw-m3-cadillac-front-3.jpg


Or

2013-audi-rs5-2011-bmw-m3-cadillac-cts-v-front-4.jpg


I'm taking the Caddy, even though it's not the sedan.
CTS-V, the RS5 is close.

Results:
1. Cadillac CTS-V
2. Audi RS5
3. BMW M3
 
I decided now to say what I would pick for some of the other WYRs.

I'll take the Megane RS, LaFerrari, the F-Type, the Vanquish Volante, the Challenger R/T, the C1 Corvette, the Lincoln Continental, the Camaro ZL1, and the Accord.



A Selection of Ungainly-looking Ferraris


Ferrari 330 GT Navarro Special
1966_Ferrari_330_GT_2+25DA.jpg



or


Ferrari 410 Superamerica Ghia Coupé
56ghia_ferrari_410_superamerica_31.jpg



or


Ferrari FZ93
Ferrari-FZ93_2.jpg
Badly Styled Ferraris; I'll pick the FZ93 since it's the least ugly to me.



Luxury hatchbacks:

Audi A3
View attachment 237644

BMW 1-Series
View attachment 237646

Mercedes Benz A-Class
View attachment 237645
I think I'll go with the Mercedes-Benz A-Class.


Dodge Viper SRT-10 ACR without question, it's so much faster than the other 2 around the race track and better looking. It's just so hardcore!


Luxury convertibles:

Aston-Martin-DB9-Volante-36-photos.jpg


ferrari-california-t-625x323.jpg


Bentley-Continental_GT_Speed_Convertible_2014_1600x1200_wallpaper_0f.jpg

Aston Martin DB9 Volante please.

American icons:

hrdp_1002_07_o%2B1967_ford%2Bmustang.jpg


69camaro.jpg


292001-870-0.jpg

Of all of the 1960s Mustangs, I'm the least fond of the 1967 year and that's a base model while the other 2 aren't base models; so that's out. Now it gets a tiny bit difficult; my favorite year of the Camaro & Challenger. Of course, I think I'll go with the Challenger just on looks alone here since my knowledge on the performance of the classic ponies is still very fuzzy.

American icons round 2:

47_163_1960_CHEVROLET_CORVETTE_1.jpg


ford__thunderbird_1960_1_lgw.jpg


1960_Plymouth_Fury.jpg
Chevrolet Corvette without question, because the Thunderbird at that point was aimed torwards Luxury and Luxury cars still bore me a bit and I just don't care for that many 1950s mopars. Except for the 1958 Plymouth Belvedere, that's a handsome car.

American icons round 3:

cadillac-el-dorado-1975_1.jpg


1975_Lincoln_Continental_Mark_IV,_Dutch_licence_registration_05-YB-59_p1.JPG
Lincoln Continental without question, simply for having hidden headlights and my preference to Ford.

American icons round 4: final showdown.

2010shelbygt500fdp1_30_opta.jpg


2012-chevrolet-camaro-zl1-9_653.jpg
Chevrolet Camaro ZL1 since it's the better performer of the 2 cars (though its visibility and trunk still suck). I would have picked the GT500 though if you picked the 2013 version.

Family sedans:

2014_nissan_altima_sedan_35-sl_fq_oem_6_815.jpg


2014-Accord-PHEV-550x308.jpg
Nissan Altima, but I would have picked the Honda Accord if you choose the normal version and not this ugly version.

------------------------------

Powerhouse Ponies

2014 Ford Shelby GT500
04-2013-shelby-gt500-top-speed-test.jpg


or

2015 Dodge Challenger SRT Hellcat
01-2015-dodge-challenger-srt-hellcat-fd-opt.jpg


Personally, I would go with the Mustang for just not being as bloated as the Challenger, but that's just me.
 
Last edited:
I'll take the A-Class, the Charger SRT Hellcat, the Viper SRT10 ACR, the Lincoln-Zephyr, the BMW 327, the Bentley 8 Litre, the A2, the E92 M3 Coupé, and the Challenger SRT Hellcat.



Limited-edition Ferraris that Honor the USA (only Ten Units Made/Will be Made)


528546.jpg

Ferrari 275 GTB/4 NART Spyder


or


2014_Ferrari_F60America-0-1536.jpg

Ferrari F60America



 
Performance coupes: M3, because E92 is still one of my favorite cars.
1. M3
2. CTS-V
3. RS5

Power muscle: Mustang, but Hellcat is really close.

Blue Ferraris: 275 GTB/4 NART
 
The Hellcat and the F60 America.

Rotary eXperimentals

Mazda Capella Rotary Coupe/RX-2

Mazda_Capella_001.JPG


Mazda Savanna GT/RX-3 (S102)

1280px-Mazda-rx3-1st-generation01.jpg


Mazda Savanna RX-7 (SA22C)

1280px-Mazda-rx7-1st-generation01.jpg


Mazda Savanna RX-7 (FC)

Rx7FC1.jpg


Mazda ɛ̃fini RX-7 (FD)

1280px-Mazda-rx7-3rd-generation01.jpg


There were a couple of others that have worn the RX- name (internationally at least) but I decided to go with the more well-known ones. I'd take the RX-3.
 
I'll take the A-Class, the Charger SRT Hellcat, the Viper SRT10 ACR, the Lincoln-Zephyr, the BMW 327, the Bentley 8 Litre, the A2, the E92 M3 Coupé, and the Challenger SRT Hellcat.



Limited-edition Ferraris that Honor the USA (only Ten Units Made/Will be Made)


528546.jpg

Ferrari 275 GTB/4 NART Spyder


or


2014_Ferrari_F60America-0-1536.jpg

Ferrari F60America



F60 'Murica. The 275 is a beautiful car, though.
The Hellcat and the F60 America.

Rotary eXperimentals

Mazda Capella Rotary Coupe/RX-2

Mazda_Capella_001.JPG


Mazda Savanna GT/RX-3 (S102)

1280px-Mazda-rx3-1st-generation01.jpg


Mazda Savanna RX-7 (SA22C)

1280px-Mazda-rx7-1st-generation01.jpg


Mazda Savanna RX-7 (FC)

Rx7FC1.jpg


Mazda ɛ̃fini RX-7 (FD)

1280px-Mazda-rx7-3rd-generation01.jpg


There were a couple of others that have worn the RX- name (internationally at least) but I decided to go with the more well-known ones. I'd take the RX-3.
RX-3. Can't pass that up.

Results:
1. Mazda RX-3
2. Mazda RX-2
3. Efini RX-7
4. Mazda Savanna RX-7 (SA22C)
5. Mazda Savanna RX-7 (FC)

2010 Marussia B2
2010-marussia-b2-2.jpg


or

2012 Tushek Renovatio T500
Tushek-Renovatio-T500-White.jpg
 
Back