Would you rather?

  • Thread starter Thread starter motortrend
  • 22,046 comments
  • 1,114,640 views
Miata NB vs. MR-2: The Miata wins hands down! Because roadster. ;)

Lambo LP570 Superleggra vs. SRT GTS TA vs. Lexus LFA: Ugh, tough one... I'll take them all! :D

M5s vs. S6/RS6: I'll take the BMWs E39 and E60 all the way. Because ///M. ;)
 
-> Ok, instead of me answering the questions...it's my turn to ask this time!

PART 1: B-Segment Brand New US-Spec Hot Hatches

Ford Fiesta ST - The new comer.
2014fordfietsastus-17.jpg


Fiat 500 Abarth - The cute one.
2012-fiat-500-abarth-01-1.jpg


MINI Hardtop Cooper S - The veteran.
2011-mini-cooper-s-vs-2012-vw-beetle-turbo-01-1.jpg


Hyundai Veloster Turbo - The odd-ball.
2013-Hyundai-Veloster-Turbo-1024x786-HD-Wallpaper-for-Desktop.jpg



PART 2: Mercedes-Benz's AMG Bad-Ass Coupes

[C209] CLK(55) DTM AMG
Mercedes-Benz_clk_dtm_amg-426-1024.jpg


[C209] CLK63 AMG Black Series
Mercedes-Benz-CLK63-AMG-Black-Series-2008-Wallpaper.jpg


[W204] C63 AMG Coupe Black Series
8469675589_bd42f6cd35_h.jpg


^ NOTE: I didn't include the SL65 AMG Black, SLS(63) AMG, & SLS(63) AMG Black simply because it would be too much/unfair for this comparo.
 
Last edited:
Hot Hatches: I'll take the 500 Abarth since it's the best looking. The Mini is old hat now, the Velsoter doesn't know what it is and the Fiesta will basically be everywhere in the UK.

Hot AMGs: All of them. I'm a sucker for big noise, big smoke and German lunacy.
 
Last edited:
-> Ok, instead of me answering the questions...it's my turn to ask this time!

PART 1: B-Segment Brand New US-Spec Hot Hatches

Ford Fiesta ST - The new comer.

Fiat 500 Abarth - The cute one.

MINI Hardtop Cooper S - The veteran.

Hyundai Veloster Turbo - The odd-ball.

PART 2: Mercedes-Benz's AMG Bad-Ass Coupes

[C209] CLK(55) DTM AMG

[C209] CLK63 AMG Black Series

[W204] C63 AMG Coupe Black Series

^ NOTE: I didn't include the SL65 AMG Black, SLS(63) AMG, & SLS(63) AMG Black simply because it would be too much/unfair for this comparo.

Fiesta (I'm a Ford fanboy!)

C63 Black Series, it looks like an absolute dream wit or without the aero.
 
-> ...
Hot Hatches: I'll take the 500 Abarth since it's the best looking, and use the money saved to get the EsseEsse kit. The Mini is old hat now, the Velsoter doesn't know what it is and the Fiesta will basically be everywhere in the UK.
^ Unlike you guys over the Atlantic, the US-spec 500 Abarth doesn't offer the EsseEsse kit available to order at the dearlership...neither does the Mountune kit for the Fiesta either. :indiff:
 
-> ...

^ Unlike you guys over the Atlantic, the US-spec 500 Abarth doesn't offer the EsseEsse kit available to order at the dearlership...neither does the Mountune kit for the Fiesta either. :indiff:

Edited my post
 
Fiesta ST and CLK63 Black. The CLK63 Black Series was the first car I ever started, so it holds a special place in my heart.
 
Hot hatches: I want to say the Abarth, but I've sat in a normal 500 once and didn't like it. So Fiesta for me!

AMG Mercedes: C63 no question.
 
Hot hatches: It was pretty tough with the Mini and the Abarth but i think it will be Abarth

Hot AMG: C63 Black edition.
 
Gallardo VS Viper VS LFA

The Gallardo's nice, but it's pretty long in tooth now. The Viper's also very nice, but I'm just not a Viper guy. The LFA, though it doesn't actually excite me, is the better car. It's overengineered, which is something you rarely see in new cars. It's built to meticulous details, and comes at a hefty price. The hefty price is worth it, though.

E39 VS E60 VS S6 VS RS6

The E60's immediately out, I'm starting to tire of its exterior, and I just don't like the interior. The S6 just looks too boring inside and out, especially to the much more expensive-looking '13 S6. It just looks like a big Passat, except without the old Passat's ugly interior. The old RS6 is a nice car, but it too is a little to bland inside, and that roofline just screams Passat. Not to mention, old Audis are a ticking time bomb for electrical issues. So that leaves the E39, which benefits from timeless styling, a conservative but elegant interior, rear wheel drive, and enough money left over to paint it a different color, because maroon is a terrible color.

Fiesta VS Abarth VS Mini VS Veloster

Could be biased on this one. I've driven three Minis, and the newer ones are by far more comfortable than '02-'06 models. The steering is lighter but still very direct, and they still handle very well. They're also more responsive than the supercharged '06 I'm used to driving. The Abarth is too feminine, and the Veloster just won't handle as good as these cars. The Fiesta's a solid choice, but it's no Mini. The Mini's got the better retro looks than the Fiat, has a fairly sporty driving position (you really do sit far back into the car), is more customizable from the factory, and is just a cooler car.

AMG VS AMG VS AMG

The two CLKs are out, they just look too ridiculous, which leaves the C63, which has aggressive styling to complement its ridiculous bodykit, and has a better interior.

2013 BMW 128i M-Sport - Brand New ~ $34,000

front%20&%20driver%20side%20view%20640


2008 BMW 335i Coupe - 30,250 Miles - $33,500

pic-36333.jpeg
 
I guess I would get the 335. I don't know a thing about either of them, though.
 
E39 VS E60 VS S6 VS RS6

...So that leaves the E39, which benefits from timeless styling, a conservative but elegant interior, rear wheel drive, and enough money left over to paint it a different color, because maroon is a terrible color.

But but Chiaretto Red is a rare color!
 
I'd actually have the 128i over the 335i, for more logical reasons. The 1 will have a warranty, BMW service plan, and of course will be better for fuel.
 
BMW 335 VS 1 Series

I"ll take the 335 Because it is faster and better looking and it has the I6

1 series. The 335 is just gonna be a pain in reality. A low powered One with small wheels will slither more, be more fun and be real-world more feasible.
 
Il take the Toyota MR2 Spyder/MR-S because I like the mid engine car. And the mad things you can do to them.
Also will take the 2011 Lamborghini Gallardo LP570-4 Superleggera because it was 4 wheel drive and got beautiful line

Ford Fiesta ST because I have a massive soft spot for them. Got a few in my area that are lush. Black on black

[W204] C63 AMG Coupe Black Series Because it was new and didn't look like it had a stupid body kit.

2008 BMW 335i Coupe because they are quite cool. Mum has the older shape and nothing ever went wrong with it in its 13 year life.
 
Looking at the BMWs I find it weird the US cars all need something orange in the headlights of front of the car. Started noticing this recently, doesn't really make them look better.
 
-> To answer my own question...on the US-spec Hot Hatches, I'd pick the Fiesta ST simply because of overall balance of price, practicality, and sportiness.

-> On the AMG coupes, I'll pick the CLK(55) DTM simply because of its 🤬 you factor. ;)

2013 BMW 128i M-Sport - Brand New ~ $34,000


2008 BMW 335i Coupe - 30,250 Miles - $33,500
^ The E82 128i is my choice. In a few years this car will highly desirable and by far, it's the simplest Bimmer you can own new right now.
 
Abarth, Fun little car to cruise around in and has a good sound.

Clk DTM, Rarity, good sound and Im a fan of the clk.

128i because its newer and probably its quicker than the 3 series.
 
PART 1: B-Segment Brand New US-Spec Hot Hatches

Ford Fiesta ST vs. Fiat 500 Abarth vs. MINI Hardtop Cooper S vs. Hyundai Veloster Turbo

PART 2: Mercedes-Benz's AMG Bad-Ass Coupes

[C209] CLK(55) DTM AMG vs. [C209] CLK63 AMG Black Series vs. [W204] C63 AMG Coupe Black Series

Part 1: Easy choice, MINI Hardtop Cooper S
Part 2: [W204] C63 AMG Coupe Black Series

2013 BMW 128i M-Sport - Brand New vs. 2008 BMW 335i Coupe - 30,250 Miles

I'd pick the 128i M-Sport just because, I know if I had the 335i, I'd want a M3 instead.
 

Latest Posts

Back