I agree, but I think there should be a lot less philosophizing by young Bruce Wayne.
They had a great chance to create a police procedural based in the DC universe, but instead they chose to make it Batman: Year One without Batman. Maybe its because I am a comic fan and know the stories already, but I clearly see where they took Year One stuff and then tried to cram it within their self-constrained framework. Their decision to include the pre-Batman Bruce Wayne as a regular character does it no favors, but you can't have Gotham without Batman apparently.
I'm sticking with it, but I think they had the opportunity to make this one of two great shows and chose to do something somewhere in the middle. I would love to see what the original concept for this was, because it feels like a good idea that is being overproduced.