Audi, BMW or Mercedes?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ryan81
  • 103 comments
  • 8,464 views
Probably, he wanted to say..... square, ribbed and uncomfortable :)
 
I have a weird issue with MB, BMW and Audi, and also Porsche, so I guess all the main German marques. I know many of them are awesome cars, and I have many favourites, though most of these are historic models. The issue I have nowadays, and I admit it must be just me, is that I find it so hard to tell the models apart, with one or two notable exceptions.

Look at any other car maker and each model *usually* has quite distinct styling, but I find with German makers so many models look very very similar, just longer, shorter, 4 doors, 2 doors, and so many iterations of what seems to essentially be the same car. Then every year or two they change them. Very slightly. So you have endless revisions of a lot of very similar looking models.

There's a very cool thread in these forums called "What did you see today" where people post pics of cool cars they saw recently. I spent some time working though that (some of the older pics are inevitably expired now) but each time I came to Mercedes CL-something or BMW M-something else, I just kinda switched off. I just don't get it, and I think a lot of them are stylistically very dry and boring too.

I'm not bashing German car makers, far from it, like I said, show me a Porsche 959 or a Mercedes 300SL, or a Z8 or an 82 Sport Quattro and i'll giggle like a schoolgirl, they are incredible, awe-inspiring cars. I guess I am an aesthete though, and get far more from the looks and presence of a car leaping out at me and slapping me around the face than I do from a bunch of numbers. Names for cars are nice sometimes too.
 
Well I find them a great place to be, it's all organised and just how a car should be.
I hated the 90-00's interiors for Mercedes but the current generation are very nice. (and yes Mercedes seats are very comfortable compared to BMWs)
Audi's interiors are very nice too and always have been I think.
 
I find with German makers so many models look very very similar

Yeah, it's part of the idea.... and it's followers, wanting to see the sign of the former model.

For exampel the Japan car have complitley different conception - new model = new design
 
Tyger
I shuddered a little when I read that, but each to their own I guess!

Haha yeh that is my honest opinion, but I'm sure you would like everything to be organised too in a car? For example i don't think you'd want the eject CD button all the way at the bottom of the centre console whereas the CD Player is at the top of the centre console.
You might not understand what I'm getting at there but i meant that everything is in it's appropriate place and I couldn't think of a way to improve it or place anywhere else in the car.
 
Last edited:
Just Imagine the last 3 letters in my name aren't there.

It's obviuos what side I would take and it;s mostly because of the Z4M and the both M3s.

But I can't argue that thee SLS AMG and SLR Mclaren are also amazing cars. Also the beautiful design of the Audi R8.

I love all these brands but if I had to put them in order first is BMW but the battle for second is hard Merc and Audi are both nice.
 
To me it depends what you're looking for:

Mercedes-Benz is the way to go if you want a luxury sports coupe with an atomic bomb under the bonnet (especially if you go for an AMG). How many times has the most powerful automatic car in the world been a Merc? :sly:

BMW is the king of super-saloons. Sure Mercedes, Audi, Lexus and many other companies have tried to match them over the years, and done a very good job, but BMW was still there first. They still kncok out the greatest fast saloons of the lot. 👍

Audi is the way to go if you want a car that is powerful but understated. Audi's don't have over the top styling, you might even say some of them are a bit boring. Take a look at the Audi RS6: it is a two tonne estate car with a 5L twin-turbo V10 producing more horsepower than a Ferrari F50! :nervous: And yet anyone who looked at you drive down the road would think you were an ordinary guy with an Audi estate car. :p
 
I cant decide.. but what i can decide on? BMW, Mercedes, & Audi > Lexus
 
Well. ive always thought of the C63 AMg as the bully of the three. All brawns and no brains...

BMW>Audi>Mercedes
 
I just can't choose between them.

I love bimmers (got 2nd in row). But Audi's and Merc's are great cars too. They're all different.
If You compare M3, RS4(RS5) and C63AMG for example. Bimmer has great suspension, RS4 has 4wheel drive and AMG more power then spaceship.

It's about what You're looking for car to have.
My dream garage includes M3/1M, S8 and E63 AMG.
 
BMW
Love: M5, M3, 1series Concept and the LMR Race Car

Audi
Love: R8, R10

Mercedes
Love: SLR McLaren, C63 AMG, SLS

ARGH! Can't decide...
 
Back