The ps3 I think will work, but it's not plug and play, and I think it's a real pain to get working.
The old wired 360 controllers work great. You just plug it in and your ready to go. I actually traded a wireless one for this one. I would like to have all wired controllers, because I am getting sick of all this battery charging, and 30$ packs going bad in 6 months.
The 360 one works great. You won't compete with people on the ground with guns. The pc has no aim assist like on consoles, and it is very apparent when you try to aim with the controller. I just set mine beside me, and pick it up when I go to the air.