Hypothetical Question: GT4 on XBox

  • Thread starter Thread starter Event
  • 106 comments
  • 3,631 views

Would you buy an XBox for GT4?


  • Total voters
    75
I think that most people here are missing that point. They are all not realizing that IF and ONLY IF it were released for X-Box, meaning NEVER RELEASED FOR PS2, meaning NO GT4 IF YOU DON'T BUY AN X-BOX. This is what he is asking. Not "Is it going to happen?".

And me personally would definately sell my ps2 and pic up a box. I couldn't wait this much and not not have gt4.
 
cobragt
What other racer has had its logo on a car besides gt3?

Read what he posted guys, didn't mention GT1 or GT2. Looks more like it's ripping off NFSU to me though. I'm gonna go out on a limb and say someone did it before GT3 though.

cobragt
Think about it.

You should too.
 
Eagle
Read what he posted guys, didn't mention GT1 or GT2. Looks more like it's ripping off NFSU to me though. I'm gonna go out on a limb and say someone did it before GT3 though.



You should too.
Back your claim up before you run your mouth.
 
robin2223
............but, alas...........rest asured............GT & XBOX it ain't gonna happen! so I don't care (unless Microsoft buy Sony)...........eek!

Uncle Harry
The only way this will hapen is if Microsoft buys PD and Sony!


YUP.................It aint gonna happen!!! :lol: :lol: :lol:

Robin :D

Xbox.....is just a small computer.......not a dedicated graphics pumping machine!!!
 
Cobra, you do realise that you made a total fan boy ass of your self again right? Good. Some of the points you made were utterly retarded, "ugh I don't like the box art, MOAN MOAN MOAN", Cobra, just chill, you and PD are not in a relationship.

"Back your claim up before you run your mouth."

Car off a cliff cobra? THE IRONY!!!!

Anyway, hmmmm would I buy it on the xbox, well geeee let me think, better graphics, better sound, in short yes. I don't give a crap about the wheel, I'm a pad person anyway.

"Xbox.....is just a small computer.......not a dedicated graphics pumping machine!!!"

Ninja Gaiden could have fooled me

Still I'm not too bothered, which ever machine GT was on, it would still own just as much, and hell, if the fact it's on the ps2 means the graphics are abit tattier, meh, long as it has LOADS and LOADS of cars and stuff too do, I couldn't care.

btw I loved cobras mini reviews of Forza

"Hmmm this forza game looks fun, good list of features, OMG OMG it's not on the ps2 *fan boy mode on*, UGH GUH UGH, PS2 PWNS YOUUU XBOX N00b, ummm HUMAN ELEMENT!!! FORZA IS BS!!!!!! It's just a wannabe! Ummmm XBOX SUCKS, not that I really have a clue about anything, GT4 4 EVAAAA IT LOOKS REAL"

Cobra, a tip, before a game review is done, you must PLAY the finished version of a game, and no, 5 minutes in your local HMV doesn't count.
 
You know........I recon this thread is going to be locked if you lot start getting angry bout it.......just calm down.........tis only a commercial!! :D

P.S. Me PS2 fan forever!!!...........Me hate XBOX cos it is a intel celeron bolted to a 4 year old nvidia graphics card!........"games console".......ha! I think not!
 
hypothetically... no force feedback - no XBOX.

Reality... this thread makes no sense since GT is a Sony exclusive seeing as they pretty much own PD and Kaz is on the SCE board (or is an exec there)... something like that.
 
cobragt
Back your claim up before you run your mouth.

That's what I get for actually defending your crap? Figures.

How about you back up any of your claims and then tell me how cover art has anything to do with a title. Do you want to know how many racing games use a car as part of their cover? Are they all ripping one another off then? Who cares anyway? Imitation is the highest form of flattery right? If the guys behind Forza can do things different or better, more power to them.
 
Code, why did you even mention NG? You mention that game in about every thread. Anyway, where is all this other idiocy coming from? gt4 pwns the xb? Xb sucks? Oh, I should have realized, this is code. Your name just screams idiocy. Forza is a gt wanna be and maybe if you could take those fanboy goggles off you would realise it. I know you would buy it on the xb, look who you are. Nuff said, I wouldn't because I need FFB and I doubt it would have better graphics, maybe sound but not graphics. Infact it might look worst seeing how the xb is good in making comperized graphics. Just look at its racers and that's enought said. What other racer has put its logo or title on a car besides gt3? How did any GT game copy NFS in box art? tattier graphics? You got to be kidding me. That tattier graphics out classes anything I've seen on a console. And yes, it looks soooooo realistic, have you seen the paris replay? After seeing that replay of the Alpine in paris, my confidence for gt4's graphics went up HIGH but it has been high anyway. I'm yet to see anything that looks nearly as impressive, visually. And code, you have to be MS's pet monkey, I refuse to believe there's a human typing with your name, I REFUSE!!! And playing gt4 at 30fps would be horrible. Imagine such a realistic looking game running 30fps :scared:
 
Cobra, while your little rant was funny, I shall now have to rip it to bits

"Code, why did you even mention NG? You mention that game in about every thread."

I used it as an example of good graphics

"Anyway, where is all this other idiocy coming from? gt4 pwns the xb? Xb sucks? Oh, I should have realized, this is code. Your name just screams idiocy."

umm yes

"Forza is a gt wanna be and maybe if you could take those fanboy goggles off you would realise it."

Unlike you I'm willing to give other games a chance, Gt didn't exactly invent racing games now did it. You on the other hand kiss sony's ass a little too much to be healthy, your willing to believe the ps2 is capible of doing anything, even if you know deep down your talking crap.

"I know you would buy it on the xb, look who you are. Nuff said, I wouldn't because I need FFB and I doubt it would have better graphics, maybe sound but not graphics."

Cobra, a shocking fact for you, more power and 3d hardware = better graphics. I know, it's confusing, but think of it like pcs, what's better, onboard graphics or an X800? If you look at allmost EVERY ps2 conversion that's made it's way to the xbox, it looks better and sounds better. Now I;m not saying my xbox is a better machine, as I like em both and it's down to games etc, but you can't argue with tech specs. For example games like riddick etc could never be done in the same way on a ps2 as it's hardware is too old.

"Infact it might look worst seeing how the xb is good in making comperized graphics."

I have no idea what you just said, but I know it's stupid.

"Just look at its racers and that's enought said."

*looks*Good games, your point?

"What other racer has put its logo or title on a car besides gt3? How did any GT game copy NFS in box art?"

no comment

"tattier graphics? You got to be kidding me. That tattier graphics out classes anything I've seen on a console."

Gt4s cars are good (even if the texturing is abit grainy up close, has no interiors), but the tracks are pretty terrible, flat low res textures, and clipping issues in the distance. I won't even mention the 2d trees and flat lighting. I do think Gt4 is pretty, as the over all effect is very good and gives a good sense of realism,but you do go abit over the top

"And yes, it looks soooooo realistic, have you seen the paris replay? After seeing that replay of the Alpine in paris, my confidence for gt4's graphics went up HIGH but it has been high anyway. I'm yet to see anything that looks nearly as impressive, visually."

Doom 3?

"And code, you have to be MS's pet monkey, I refuse to believe there's a human typing with your name, I REFUSE!!! And playing gt4 at 30fps would be horrible. Imagine such a realistic looking game running 30fps"

Oh you are the comic genius, where's this 30 fps thing come from??? RSC2 runs at 60, and in terms of pure graphic quality eclipses Gt4 from quite a height (don't get me wrong, GT4 will be better).

I'm not a fanboy cobra, I'm just not blinded with ridiculous brand loyalty like you are, but I do feel the need to respond when utter crap is said about a system I like.

Sorry for being such a flame whore btw, I don't like responding like this.
 
cobragt
Code, why did you even mention NG? You mention that game in about every thread. Anyway, where is all this other idiocy coming from? gt4 pwns the xb? Xb sucks? Oh, I should have realized, this is code. Your name just screams idiocy. Forza is a gt wanna be and maybe if you could take those fanboy goggles off you would realise it. I know you would buy it on the xb, look who you are. Nuff said, I wouldn't because I need FFB and I doubt it would have better graphics, maybe sound but not graphics. Infact it might look worst seeing how the xb is good in making comperized graphics. Just look at its racers and that's enought said. What other racer has put its logo or title on a car besides gt3? How did any GT game copy NFS in box art? tattier graphics? You got to be kidding me. That tattier graphics out classes anything I've seen on a console. And yes, it looks soooooo realistic, have you seen the paris replay? After seeing that replay of the Alpine in paris, my confidence for gt4's graphics went up HIGH but it has been high anyway. I'm yet to see anything that looks nearly as impressive, visually. And code, you have to be MS's pet monkey, I refuse to believe there's a human typing with your name, I REFUSE!!! And playing gt4 at 30fps would be horrible. Imagine such a realistic looking game running 30fps :scared:
OH MY GOD you'v gone back into super-retardedness again, I mean SUPER-retardedness looking at that post, you say your not a fnaboy yet you kiss Sony's ass all the time, your a much bigger fanboy to PS2 and GT than Code is too X_Box and PGR. Get a grip man, half, no most of what you just said is bull ****.
 
Good graphics? You opinion, I dont care for the cartoony look, you understand? Gt4 uses gobal illumination and colors correctly. That's why it looks so much more realistic than any racer out. Yes, the xb has teh power, couldn't tell by the looks of its racers but it has the power nonetheless. Gt4 on the xb would be bad graphically, I'm sorry but I just see it looking so unnatural on the xb. Everything would look computerized and run 30 fps, not cool. "Non fanboy code," what an oxymoron. Dont kid yourself code, denial is what you're on right? RSC2 doesn't even look all that realistic, it uses streaming texturing. And I thought the xb was so powerful lol but it is, no doubt. But that's the reason it runs 60fps, now if it had as much detail as pgr2, then you'd be saying good bye to 60fps. I have played rsc2, and I have noticed slow down and frame drops, guess it's the xb's cpu weak is a joke compared to the ps2's cpu.
rsc2.jpg

Sad.
 
oh god, i don't know how, but you've just gone and made your self look even more stupid!

time to get the wooden spoons out for cobra again!

I never said RSC2 was perfect either, shhheessshhh, get a grip man.
 
First off Cobra, a pic of a car doing 89Mph and sayiong a blurred road texture is sad is sad it'self. The car is moving at 89Mph, the road surface gets a little blurred at 89Mph, also your digging at RSC2 for having a little slowdown, so does GT4:P, go on, dig that too. Also you admit the X-Box is more powerful, yet you still deny that it can produce better graphics, it can and at a higher resolution too, just because you prefer GT4:P's gritty real look compared to PGR2's shiny clean look does not mean GT4:P has better graphics.
 
live4speed
First off Cobra, a pic of a car doing 89Mph and sayiong a blurred road texture is sad is sad it'self. The car is moving at 89Mph, the road surface gets a little blurred at 89Mph, also your digging at RSC2 for having a little slowdown, so does GT4:P, go on, dig that too. Also you admit the X-Box is more powerful, yet you still deny that it can produce better graphics, it can and at a higher resolution too, just because you prefer GT4:P's gritty real look compared to PGR2's shiny clean look does not mean GT4:P has better graphics.
GT4p is a demo, rsc2 is a full built game. I'm not denying xb being more powerful but I seriously couldn't tell with the looks of its racers. Blurred eh? Please, that game uses streaming texturing and that's why it runs 60fps. The pic isn't blurred, that's just an example of the tricks used to make the game.
 
Cobra, dude. You just made yourself look like the biggest retarded fool ever.

I'll be honest with you guys...I do believe that the box has more power. I also think that games like PGR2 and RSC2 have *smoother* graphics than most other racers. That's in part of the power of the system. I think that if GT4 were to be on the box, it would in fact have much better graphics than the ps2. PD knows what their doing. They could get the colors right, textures, they could impliment the lighting *sparkles* effects mentioned in another thread, and overall it probably would be a better game. I don't try to take credit away from the box, but I still like it on the PS2. I would get FFB, and analogue ps2 controls for when I'm not using the wheel. I don't believe that the box version would have computerized graphics. But for me, the ps2 if fine fine. :)

Peace 👍
 
RSC2 is a very nice looking game, graphics wise dispite GTs cars looking more realistic, RSC2s graphics are far better. Its one of the most beautiful racing games I've seen & you'd know that too if you'd ever actually played it cobra.

Even though people say GT : P is a demo, its still a full retail product, just like RSC2.

I've mostly avoided this thread, some people on this forum are diehard fanboys & its pathetic.
 
MUWHAHAHAHAHAHA! I allready have an xbox AND a Ps2 :P
So imma get GT4 AND Forza motorsports And OWN ALL OF YOU ON BOTH !
MUWHAHAHAHAHAHA!

Seriously now. If i dint have an xbox. yes i would

The Xbox's controllers shake (like the ps2's controllers) so iunno but why dosent the xbox support force feedback?

That needs to be look at by microsoft like a program update or sumthing
 
You are talking about rumble effect, any console can do that. We are talking about force feed back, the real deal. Where you actually feel the road.
 
Cobra, it's clear you don't know a damn thing.

Read these:
http://www.pcvsconsole.com/features/consoles/xbox.php
http://www.pcvsconsole.com/features/consoles/playstation2.php

If you're going to post outrageous and inflamatory crap then you sure as hell better have something to back it up with, and I'll be damned if I've ever seen you point at a decent reference that wasn't your own opinion.

You're in violation of the AUP, you manage to hijack and destroy any thread you 'contribute' to and you rarely raise a single sensible point amongst mountains of Sony loving bull****.

This is getting reported, you've gone on long enough.
 
I said that Project Gotham Racing 2 was a pretty fun game from the demo I played, and GT4 is a "rival" to it. But if I was going to buy an XBOX for GT4, I'd say no, and here's why.

I don't really like the concept of buying a complete game system... to play just one game. I mean, when you buy a game system, you buy a system to play other games. You buy one to examime its capabilities and the fun factor involved during gameplay. I don't buy a Playstation to just play Gran Turismo. I don't buy a Gamecube to play Super Smash Bros. Melee. I don't buy a Nintendo to play Super Mario Bros. 3. And I'm certainly NOT on the XBOX bandwagon.

Another thing to consider is that a game made for other consoles have to be as good as another. I played Burnout 2 on the Gamecube, and the gameplay was pretty fast-paced. It was fun, didn't have graphical glitches, that sort of thing. Even with the crashes in Burnout 2, nothing seemed to slow down. If GT4 was on XBOX, it would have to play as good as on the Playstation 2. I love the PS2 because it is a very good system that isn't dated if not seriously dated. The Gamecube is a little underrated because the graphical capabilities are pretty nice and pretty fast. I liked the N64 over Playstation because loading was almost nonexistant and graphics were a little better. But as my N64 days went away, I was full-on Sony gameplayer. But amid my rambling, no offense. I don't think GT4 on the XBOX would be impressive-looking and playing as on the PS2. The only thing GT4 on XBOX would have over PS2 is that damned XBOX Live, in which a game can be made good or bad with that feature.

So my answer to the hypothetitcal question: NO!!! PS2 is fine for me until the XBOX can stop looking like and pretending to be a hyped-up Alienware (with Nvidia) PC. By the way, I don't own one. Just this crappy... I won't name the brand.
 
i almost bought a Japanese PS2 and Prologue for $220 last weekend at an Anime show, i was broke and that was the only thing stopping me, the GT series is worth the purchase of another console IMO (and may open my eyes to games on that console i never thought of trying before, i owe my console allegiance to no one)
 
^Its good that you didnt buy the Japanese PS2, its not worth buying an out of region console for Prologue........recon that it would be better if you wait and get GT4 in NTSC UC with that regions console.....you will be thankful for it in the end because.

1. You didn't miss that much in Prologue
2. You would have regreted buying the console cos them you would have to chip it and risk the fact that it wouldn't play any regional games
3. The eventual release of GT4 would (if you didn't chip it) be all in Japanese seeing as gran turismo is becoming more and more complex.
4. You wouldn't be able to easily setup online and hard drive stuff with the US PS2 (same in Canada rite?).

Reason why...........I bought one of the first few Japanese consoles in 2000......cost me a shed load of money!.......Chipped it (loads more money, V1 chips are rare) and now its in the UK and I cross my fingers everytime I stick in a PAL disk! I also bought Japanese prologue.....I would have sooner waited and bought a UK console if I could have.....

Robin
 

Latest Posts

Back