Stick or Automatic?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Blix
  • 205 comments
  • 10,755 views
Messages
51
United States
Seattle, WA
Messages
iTry2Miss & BMVV-
Messages
PlayStation's Better!
Which is better to first start driving with? Stick shift right? I know you get more feel for the car with it, but is also a lot harder.
 
I don't like manual, and automatic is easier to learn on, all my friends, including myself have/are.
 
If you learn to drive in a manual, you can drive an auto later on in life. If you learn in an auto, you cannot drive a manual later on in life. At least, that's the rules here.
 
It honestly doesn't matter, unless you're going to need to drive a stick shift at some point. I say that if there is a stick shift car readily availible and someone to teach you stick, go for it. But if not, than chances are you won't need to drive a stick anyway. Of course it goes without saying that if you can drive a stick than you can drive an automatic.

And that whole "feel for the car" thing... It doesn't matter either. Driving is easy, it takes practically zero skill, just a bit of coordination and common sense.
 
If you learn to drive in a manual, you can drive an auto later on in life. If you learn in an auto, you cannot drive a manual later on in life. At least, that's the rules here.
LOL, what? Pretty sure anyone can be taught a manual after a few years in an auto. Just a longer process.
 
It's not just England, though of course they can pass the manual test later.

As for the question, if you think you will ever want to drive a manual car then start with a manual. Almost everyone does it in Europe.
 
In Sweden you have to learn driving with manual transmission, since most cars are manual over here.
 
Learn a stick. Just so you can drive one if you need to.

It's not terribly hard to learn stick, but better to practice and get it right before you start practicing on the open road.
 
I love u Swedish people! Make me a Koenigsegg! Lol sorry. Yeah, I really want to learn manual but NOBODY i know, knows how to drive manual.
 
mattythedog
If you learn to drive in a manual, you can drive an auto later on in life. If you learn in an auto, you cannot drive a manual later on in life. At least, that's the rules here.

What? I know how to drive a manual, but I learned to drive in an automatic first.

Are you saying people who learn how to drive in automatics most likely will never own a stick-shift car?
 
What? I know how to drive a manual, but I learned to drive in an automatic first.

Are you saying people who learn how to drive in automatics most likely will never own a stick-shift car?

What he's saying is that in this country if you learn and pass your test in an automatic, you can only drive automatic cars. You have an auto license.

If you learn in a manual, you can drive both. 👍
 
Encyclopedia, I am not familiar with stick shifts at all, not even the basics. The only things I know about them are from tv, movies, and video games. I just want to have the BEST performance out of my car while still including me.
 
FordMKIVJ5
What he's saying is that in this country if you learn and pass your test in an automatic, you can only drive automatic cars. You have an auto license.

If you learn in a manual, you can drive both. 👍

Thanks for clearing that up. That's an interesting way of doing things.
 
Oh and another thing is that I live in the city. Is that a problem with stick shifts? Lots of lights and stop signs.
 
In the UK and many other countries, the license is transmissions dependent, meaning that if you take the test with an automatic, you are only licensed to drive an automatic. If you take the test with an manual, however, you are licensed to drive both manuals and automatics. That is what mattythedog is saying.

In the US, however, that rule doesn't apply. Licenses don't make that distinction.

With that said, I would recommend you learn to drive an automatic first, then learn to drive a manual in a closed course until you are comfortable. I make this recommendation because you should get used to controlling a vehicle on the open road with other drivers first. The less stuff you have to worry about, and the more you can focus on just driving, the better the first couple of lessons will be. Once you've got a handle on driving a car, then you can learn to drive a manual. Especially in Seattle where there are tons of steep hills, you will have to learn good clutch control to start properly on the hills. I think it's better for you to not have to worry about that when you first start driving. Once you've got driving itself down, then you can start learning that and worrying about that.

If you were in a country where the license changes depending on the test transmission type, then by all means, learn a manual, but since it doesn't matter in the US, you can learn manual later, on your own time, after you are comfortable with driving. You should learn to drive a manual eventually (everyone should know how to drive one), but I don't think you need to do that in your first ever driving lesson. You'll have enough to worry about as it is. Plus, if you do take a driving school, I doubt that any of them will even have a manual car for you to learn on.

Learning to drive itself can be stressful enough, no need to add the starting-on-a-steep-hill-and-possibly-rolling-backwards-into-the-car-behind-you-so-you-either-give-it-too-much-gas-and-launch-like-some-lunatic-or-not-enough-gas-and-stall-and-roll-backwards-into-the-guy-behind-you stress anyways.
 
I live in Seattle !!!!!!!!!!

...and lol to ur st-utt-er-ing
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I live in Seattle !!!!!!!!!!

Yes, I am aware. I can see the location that you have entered, which clearly states "Seattle."

Hence, I am well aware of the challenges presented by the local geography, urban planning and driver ineptitude.
 
Lol sorry I forgot. Obviously I am new. :]

Why out Puget Sound? Why not the city?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It's not just England, though of course they can pass the manual test later.

As for the question, if you think you will ever want to drive a manual car then start with a manual. Almost everyone does it in Europe.
No, I don't!

Oops, you're talking about driving a manual. lol


:p



On topic:

You have to ask yourself what you prefer, what you want to drive. Or ask yourself what car you want.

Au contraire what another member said, it is always possible to learn how to drive a manual. Wheter you learned to drive an automatic in the first place has nothing to do with learning how to drive a manual.

Once you get the hang of it, it is not difficult at all. If I had to choose for you, I'd say learn how to drive a manual.

If you are interested in cars, learn how to drive a manual. If you consider a car as an object to get from A to B, learn how to drive an automatic.
 
In switzerland if you pass your driver licence with an automatic you'll have a automatic only driver licence.

I would honestly learn how to drive in manual if you like to drive. If for you driving is just another way to go to point A to point B then just use an automatic, but if you're really into cars learn how to operate a manual it's not that hard and it's much more rewarding. Then when you're getting old like me, switch to an automatic if you prefer that.
 
If you live in a city, especially a hilly one, go auto.

But it's still worth it to learn stick.
 
Oh and another thing is that I live in the city. Is that a problem with stick shifts? Lots of lights and stop signs.

Only if you are lazy.

If you learn with an auto, it's likely that you'll never bother learning manual. As others have pointed out, if you learn manual you'll always have that skill set, yet you can always drive an auto.

Learning manual is probably the hardest aspect of learning to drive, but why take the easiest route?
 
THIS is the answer.

You want to be a test driver, get an automatic. Real test drivers don't need a manual. :p
 
Get manual and practice in your neighborhood or parking lot

Here's advice for you.

First gear kinda balance the clutch and the gas.
(You slowly let off of it but not all the way and make sure your pressing the gas at a slow rate.)

Same for reverse ^

After that switch to second by pressing the clutch all the way and release off the gas. (Not all the way, unless you want to but to some degree). Then gas it. then repeat for other gears.

Trust me manual is so much fun. You have to get it. I dont think il ever get automatic. Hope I.helped you out.
 
Last edited:
If you want the most out of your driving experience then manual is the way to go.
 
Thanks JrDarknes
 
Last edited:
The auto will be easier of course, but if you want to eventually race then better learn as soon as possible with manual.
 
Back