The "Rate My Photo" thread! **Read the OP Before You Post**

  • Thread starter Thread starter MSD Drifter
  • 2,388 comments
  • 185,882 views
Hellopppp
I like it a lot, but the background just seems too blurry, maybe it's just me.
8/10

Here are some (very) old shots from me.



Click to expand...
These two seem quite similar; Both have focus on the front of the car, and have the entire car in view. 6.5/10
Hellopppp
Click to expand...
Nice sense of speed, while maintaining the car in sharp view. 7/10
Now mine:


And just for recreation:


The first picture was meant to be a standoff between the man on the bridge and the driver, with the car in view, but not being the subject.
 
CarloPlaya
url=http://www.flickr.com/photos/66062294@N08/6283309299/]
6283309299_51e3c47f58.jpg
[/url]
Nürburgring 24h von CarloPlaya auf Flickr
Click to expand...

It's got a good realistic feel to it. The sense of speed is very good and I think the lighting helps to give it a soothing atmosphere. The only thing I really would change would be to have more air to the left of the car, it's a bit too close to the edge of the photo. I give it a 8,5/10.


 
wow I wrote the same thing haha, good to see it's seen the same 👍
[Nor]MclarenF1;6106229
Click to expand...
Reflections in this shot = amazing! 9/10. It would get the 10 if it wasn't quite so central, very nice depth of focus and lighting :)

My shot:
 
matt-mtb

Mine?
NrburgringNordschleife_5.jpg
Click to expand...

New here :P

I think your photo is a bit under exposed, a bit more of brightness and it might be done, 7.5/10

Here go mines:

circuitdespafrancorchamlt.jpg


circuitdespafrancorcham.jpg


specialstageroute78.jpg

(This one finished the 1st in the Official Playstation Spanish Contest, so say me if you like) Excuse me for showing 3 :P
 
Last edited:
Third is a definate 9.5/10, just something lacking to make it 10.
second I'd say 7, maybe a bit closer would be nicer, and 7 for the first too, nothing too special, but it's a nice photo =)


Now for mine. It's been a LONG while since I've done this...
N%C3%BCrburgring%20Nordschleife_12_edit.jpg
 
^^^
1) Can't see the photo (Can see it now)
2) Meant to rate the person aboves photo first
3) Welcome to GTPlanet! =)
 
Last edited:
@ECGadget
That's a great picture, really brings out the black of that Lambo.
8.8/10
Here's some of my Alpha





Thanks to whoever rates these.
 
Here are my 5 pics to be rated

Lexus LFA '10 in Gion, Kyoto
Kyoto-Gion_3.jpg


Toyota Castrol TOM'S Supra '97 at the High Speed Ring
HighSpeedRing_1-1.jpg


Mercedes-Benz SLS AMG '10 in London
London_6.jpg


Audi quattro '82 at the Deep Forest track
DeepForestRaceway_5.jpg


And finally......

the High End Performance G37
CircuitdelaSarthe2009NoChicanes.jpg
 
matt-mtb
Very nice shot, I would prefer the camera to be a bit lower and more angled.

EigerNordwandKTrail_5.jpg
Click to expand...

9.9/10 - Don't really have any suggestions for it because I think it looks amazing! It would be especially cool if you could see the kicked up dirt and rocks but I think that's beyond your control 👍


I know the background is pretty washed out but it was the only way I could get the rest of it looking how I wanted it to,

 
lilmann73
Yes, you.
You must post 1 picture after rating the previous person's picture.
Click to expand...
You need to read it too, I quoted the rules from the OP and nowhere does it say only one picture after you have rated one....

MSD Drifter
Here are a few simple rules to follow:

Bold=Very Important

**If you don't rate the pictures before your post, Your photos are mostly not gonna be rated**

5 Photos maximum per post ONLY!!

Please re-size your photos to a reasonable size (about 800 pixels wide)

* If you're posting photos, please specify what you want to be critiqued. Composition? Overall image? Lighting?


o The aim of this thread is to help you, but we need to know what you want feedback on!


* If you're posting after someone requesting comments, please rate their photos in your post.


o Please try to keep comments constructive and true to the requests of the photographer. If they asked for something specific, try to answer their questions if you can :) This should have everyone covered, so there isn't a build-up of people asking for comments and not getting a reply
Click to expand...
 
trangurismo
The lighting is very nice but i think the picture is a little too dark. - 8/10


ToscanaTarmac-2.jpg


ToscanaTarmac_1-1.jpg
Click to expand...
Very good. I'm going to rate both of them 8.5 out of 10. The only thing that could be improved is the exposure so we can see the vehicle better.

Now that I have read the rules and rated a picture before posting, here's one of mine. It's my Nissan GT-R Proto '05 at Circuit de la Sarthe where they hold the 24 Hours of Le Mans.

CircuitdelaSarthe2009NoChicanes_8.jpg
 
ljjnico
Now that I have read the rules and rated a picture before posting, here's one of mine. It's my Nissan GT-R Proto '05 at Circuit de la Sarthe where they hold the 24 Hours of Le Mans.

CircuitdelaSarthe2009NoChicanes_8.jpg
Click to expand...
5 out of 10.
For my taste it's way to bright and a bit to much contrast.



1.
2.
 
Last edited:
Vinylshark
5 out of 10.
For my taste it's way to bright and a bit to much contrast.



1.
2.
Click to expand...

First one, I'd give it a 7.5 out of 10, needs a bit more exposure and the second one gets 8 out of 10, only problem I have with it is that it's a bit blurry on the eyes.

Got 2 to be rated this time

My Chevy Camaro on the Grand Valley East
GrandValleyEast_6.jpg


Nissan GT-R Proto '05 going toe to toe with its future successor the Nissan GT-R '07
CircuitodeMadrid-Mini_3.jpg
 

Latest Posts

Back