Virgin Australia Supercars Championship - Archive

  • Thread starter Thread starter DRIFT4EVA
  • 13,819 comments
  • 784,384 views

Holden or Ford

  • Holden

    Votes: 209 36.2%
  • Ford

    Votes: 175 30.3%
  • Ford and Holden

    Votes: 64 11.1%
  • Nismo

    Votes: 74 12.8%
  • Erebus

    Votes: 7 1.2%
  • Nismo and Erebus

    Votes: 6 1.0%
  • Volvo

    Votes: 43 7.4%

  • Total voters
    578
Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah baby, we got first and third!
 
I'd like to nominate James Courtney for the WORST DRIVER award for this race. First of all his move on Murph - the Kiwi's just as bad; he never knows when to give up and is therefore his own worst enemy - but what the hell was he trying to do with Lowndes? There was no way he could take back the position at the next corner ...

I'd also like to nominate Holden fans for the WORST SPORTSMANSHIP award. Ford fans don't cheer when the Holden drivers have accidents ...
 
... but what the hell was he trying to do with Lowndes? There was no way he could take back the position at the next corner ...

Actually, Lowndes hadn't completed passing Courtney. Courtney was not going to get back his position on that corner, but he was still fighting for the position so it makes no difference under the rules. Craig should have been the one to leave room for James.
 
Ford fans don't cheer when the Holden drivers have accidents ...

That's completely untrue. I've been to the Clipsal 500 for 6 years now and I've always heard Ford fans getting just as enthusiastic when a Holden driver has been in trouble.

I had a great few days, I was up on the Pirie Street Grandstand, just at the beginning of Brock Straight. Got a real good view of the cars.

I was really impressed by some of the younger drivers and smaller teams, this weekend, they all did a great job.
 
V8 Supercars Clipsal 500? Oh you mean that crappy Holden vs Ford thing that was distracting from all those nice actual Supercars? :p
 
That's completely untrue. I've been to the Clipsal 500 for 6 years now and I've always heard Ford fans getting just as enthusiastic when a Holden driver has been in trouble.
Well I didn't hear any of it (I watched the broadast, so they may have never shown it), but there was never any jeering going on when Kelly or Tander overcooked it and found themselves in the run-off areas. It's a far cry from a three-way pile-up, but I'm reading your statement as saying the fans get enthusiastic when there's any kind of trouble.

I tend to shy away from the whole Ford vs. Holden thing nowadays as I think it's counter-productive to good racing when fans start sugging each other over choice. Although my favourite drivers are Ford drivers, I honestly think the actions of the Holden fans today were enough for me to side with the Blue Oval if I were completely neutral.

Four drivers were hospitalised in the past three days, and one of the critically. That was a big accident involving Lowndes, Courtney and Winterbottom, regardlss of blame (though I think Courtney should have known he couldn't re-take the position at the next corner and should therefore have backed off), and naturally everyone would be a little bit fearful for the drivers. But to cheer when three of them are take out in an accident? That just reeks of bad sportsmanship; and this coming from fans who consider themselves the epitome of Australian values like good sportsmanship!

However, I suspect it's largely because Craig Lowndes was involved: he's one of the best drivers in the field - probably the best - and I think it still hurts Holden fans that he crossed to the Blue Oval banner. No-one really cared too much when Russel Ingall went from Larry Perkins' outfit to Stone Brothers Racing, but Ingall had to wait an extraordinary amount of time before he notched up his first Championship victory. Lowndes, on the other hand, has been a serious title contender for a while now, and has really turned the Triple Eight team into a formidable force on the grid. And because of that Holden fans will never forgive him. So to the Holden fanboys out there - and this ain't aimed at anyone on the forums in particular - I say this: get over yourselves. You're getting in the way of great racing with all your semantics and poor sportsmanship. Though after that disgusting display at the 2005 Season Finale, and again at Bathurst after Peter Brock's death (I actually heard people say the race should have been rigged), I expected no less.
 
However, I suspect it's largely because Craig Lowndes was involved: he's one of the best drivers in the field - probably the best - and I think it still hurts Holden fans that he crossed to the Blue Oval banner

lowndes is by far not the best driver in v8 supercars he was very dangerous this weekend,he rammed off about 4 cars in that second race and it was inevitable that he was gonna finish that race in the wall sooner or later.
 
lowndes is by far not the best driver in v8 supercars he was very dangerous this weekend,he rammed off about 4 cars in that second race and it was inevitable that he was gonna finish that race in the wall sooner or later.
I assume you're referring to that pass on Winterbottom that didn't go according to the script? It was a legitimate move - and was deemed as such - even if it was rather untidy. Both Lowndes and Winterbottom were off the racing line and out on the dirty parts; if anything was inevitable it was that he' never make the pass the way he had intended.

And he's far better than anyone Holden has behind the wheel.
 
I assume you're referring to that pass on Winterbottom that didn't go according to the script? It was a legitimate move - and was deemed as such - even if it was rather untidy. Both Lowndes and Winterbottom were off the racing line and out on the dirty parts; if anything was inevitable it was that he' never make the pass the way he had intended.

And he's far better than anyone Holden has behind the wheel.

no im refering to every pass he made going into turn 9 (i think) all he did was point and aim his car into whatever car was there,he didnt even attempt to make that turn.i think he noticed morris was out of the race do decided to make up for it.

better than anyone holden has behind the wheel? sorry but how many championships has lowndes won for ford?
 
no im refering to every pass he made going into turn 9 (i think) all he did was point and aim his car into whatever car was there,he didnt even attempt to make that turn.i think he noticed morris was out of the race do decided to make up for it.
Do you have any idea how passing works? Diving down the inside line in an effort to force your opponent to take the corner wide is a perfectly legitimate move. In fact, almost every single pass or passing attempt that was made at turn nine over the weekend was done that way. It's a high-risk, high-reward move because other drivers can take advantage of it, as Courtney did when Lowndes made that move on Winterbottom. And often as not, the defending driver would go over with the attacking one, putting both of them on the dirty line where there was no grip. The only difference was that Lowndes was further over than any other driver.
better than anyone holden has behind the wheel? sorry but how many championships has lowndes won for ford?
One. I don't care what you say: Craig Lowndes won in 2006. Rick Kelly might have been the first man home, but at least Triple Eight didn't need to cheat in order to try and win. And they didn't need to call anoter team in to do it for them, either. Between Garth Tander deliberately blocking Lowndes so that Kelly could catch up, Todd Kelly riding shotgun for his brother, Mark Skafie all but running Lowndes off at one of the fastest sections of track and Rick Kelly punting Lowndes off in the final race (if Kelly was as good as the number one he won claimed, he would have known that his track position at the time would end with him off the road or kissing Lowndes' bumper), Lowndes won. And I know more than one Holden fan who not only agrees with me on that count, but decided to start supporting Ford because they were so ashamed of their former drivers' actions.
 
Do you have any idea how passing works? Diving down the inside line in an effort to force your opponent to take the corner wide is a perfectly legitimate move. In fact, almost every single pass or passing attempt that was made at turn nine over the weekend was done that way. It's a high-risk, high-reward move because other drivers can take advantage of it, as Courtney did when Lowndes made that move on Winterbottom. And often as not, the defending driver would go over with the attacking one, putting both of them on the dirty line where there was no grip. The only difference was that Lowndes was further over than any other driver.

yes i do have some idea how passing works but when you are coming from x amount of car lenths back with the brakes locked with no hope in hell of making the corner than that is not a passing move,that is ramming people off the track and when he rammed of winterbottom he took is time to try and get back on the track.

One. I don't care what you say: Craig Lowndes won in 2006. Rick Kelly might have been the first man home, but at least Triple Eight didn't need to cheat in order to try and win. And they didn't need to call anoter team in to do it for them, either. Between Garth Tander deliberately blocking Lowndes so that Kelly could catch up, Todd Kelly riding shotgun for his brother, Mark Skafie all but running Lowndes off at one of the fastest sections of track and Rick Kelly punting Lowndes off in the final race (if Kelly was as good as the number one he won claimed, he would have known that his track position at the time would end with him off the road or kissing Lowndes' bumper), Lowndes won. And I know more than one Holden fan who not only agrees with me on that count, but decided to start supporting Ford because they were so ashamed of their former drivers' actions.

pretty sure rick won in 2006 ;) yep he did have number 1 on the side of his car last year.kelly had his car on the inside lowndes didnt give him the room plus lowndes was riding his brakes all the way along that straight(watch the in car footage youll see the brake lights are on all the way along) then didnt wait for the rest of the field to pass so parked his car on the racing line forcing himself to be crashed into by another car then claiming if that never happened he would have won the championship even though rick isnt a slow a driver and had a faster car all weekend and im guessing you missed lowndes ramming off todd kelly in the last race last year too :rolleyes:
 
yes i do have some idea how passing works but when you are coming from x amount of car lenths back with the brakes locked with no hope in hell of making the corner than that is not a passing move,that is ramming people off the track and when he rammed of winterbottom he took is time to try and get back on the track.
Oh, so he was sabotaging Winterbotom by taking as long as possible to get onto the circuit? Turn 9 is taken at a very pedestrian speed, but Lowndes and Wintrbottom were forced to make such a sharp turn that they made everyone else look quick by comparison.
pretty sure rick won in 2006 ;) yep he did have number 1 on the side of his car last year.kelly had his car on the inside lowndes didnt give him the room plus lowndes was riding his brakes all the way along that straight(watch the in car footage youll see the brake lights are on all the way along) then didnt wait for the rest of the field to pass so parked his car on the racing line forcing himself to be crashed into by another car then claiming if that never happened he would have won the championship even though rick isnt a slow a driver and had a faster car all weekend and im guessing you missed lowndes ramming off todd kelly in the last race last year too :rolleyes:
Kelly wasn't on the inside. He was in the centre of track at best, and his racing line at the time would have taken him off the circuit if he continued it, so what the hell was he doing there? Lowndes couldn't give him any room on account of the fact that A) he had the right to defend his racing line, just like any other driver (there is, however, a difference between defending and bloking, so don't argue Tander was in the right) and B) there was another car directly in front of Lowndes and to give Kelly room would be to hit them. Lowndes was forced to ride the brake pedal as Todd Kelly was dictating the speed of the field, and he certainly wasn't going as fast as he could. And as for Lowndes pushing Todd Kelly off, did you notice how he wasn't exactly in control of the car at the time? Rick tapped him into a spin and Lowndes collected Todd. There was no way he could have avoided it.
 
Oh, so he was sabotaging Winterbotom by taking as long as possible to get onto the circuit?

no im saying that lowndes was far too aggressive in that race,in fact a few hardcore lowndes fans i know argue he was heading for a crash in race 2.

Kelly wasn't on the inside. He was in the centre of track at best, and his racing line at the time would have taken him off the circuit if he continued it, so what the hell was he doing there? Lowndes couldn't give him any room on account of the fact that A) he had the right to defend his racing line, just like any other driver (there is, however, a difference between defending and bloking, so don't argue Tander was in the right) and B) there was another car directly in front of Lowndes and to give Kelly room would be to hit them. Lowndes was forced to ride the brake pedal as Todd Kelly was dictating the speed of the field, and he certainly wasn't going as fast as he could. And as for Lowndes pushing Todd Kelly off, did you notice how he wasn't exactly in control of the car at the time? Rick tapped him into a spin and Lowndes collected Todd. There was no way he could have avoided it.
did you even see that race :confused:

todd was at least 3 car lenths ahead,rick wasnt going off the track in fact you can see the contact was made on the right rear panel as rick was down the inside but lowndes didnt give him any room and on the in car footage you can clearly see he was on the brake all the way down the straight and then tried to get back into the race but parked his car right on the racing line (if you watch you see him start to move forward parking the car on the race line then braking).

and in reference to the 2007 incident


heres something else
V8 Supercar fan favourite Craig Lowndes has been labelled the dirtiest driver in the sport and accused of causing carnage yesterday in a chaotic Clipsal 500.

He was involved in a huge accident that took out fellow Ford drivers James Courtney and Mark Winterbottom on lap 56 of the 78-lap race in Adelaide.

Lowndes was trying to pass Courtney for second and forced his way alongside at the hairpin.

As the pair raced to the next corner, Lowndes cut across the front of Courtney's car and set both spinning into the concrete wall.

Winterbottom was left with nowhere to go and slammed into Lowndes.

"I've always rated Craig as one of the dirtiest drivers in the field but he has a big cheesy grin that hides it," Winterbottom said.

"He's a smiling assassin, I guess.

"He's the king of tapping people up the backside to push them wide.

"If you ask 29 people in pitlane - Jamie probably won't say it - they will agree he is one of the dirtiest drivers, but he gets away with it.

Lowndes blamed Courtney for the crash.

"I think he should have backed off," he said. "He was struggling with his tyres. I felt I was three quarters of a car length in front of him."

But Courtney was just as angry as Winterbottom after fighting he way through the field following a disappointing Saturday race.

"He (Lowndes) came out and got up beside and then just turned in on me," he said. "I don't know if he thought my car was going to disappear or what."

He said Lowndes had struggled to match the driving of teammate Jamie Whincup who dominated with two wins.

"It's disappointing for a guy of that experience to drive like that but I think he's under a bit of pressure," Courtney said.

Lowndes wasn't the only target for the fury of Winterbottom and Courtney.

New series driving standards observer Tomas Mezera came under heavy fire for allowing such rough tactics.

"You've got guys out there pushing people off the track and our stewards deem that legal," Winterbottom said. "This is the consequence of a new driving prosecutor.

"Yesterday I got pushed out of the lead and you've got to cop it.

"But when you get a heap of damage and you are out of the race, it's hard to take.

Winterbottom said it would be a costly and violent season with plenty of crashes if the standards weren't changed.

"You want the racing closer for better TV - that's way Tomas has been employed - but then to have cars in the wall with this amount of damage. I wouldn't deem that good racing," he said.

"He set a standard yesterday by what he did, taking no action on the move.

"Today is has caused three cars to be damaged with over 50 grand worth of damage.

"It's going to be interesting to see how he sees it because if he sees that as OK, its going to be a hell of a long season.

Asked if Mezera was the wrong man for the job, Winterbottom said: "It's not looking good at the moment".

Courtney agreed that V8 Supercars was set for a hard season of push and shove.

"Yeah, definitely," he said.

"You could see Craig was spearing guys halfway through the corner because you are allowed to hit guys in the side but not the back.

"That's the new rule now.

Unsurprisingly, Lowndes had a different take on Mezera's driving standards.

"I think people don't understand the rules," he said.

"Tomas has made it clear what he is going to accept and what he isn't going to accept.

"I think its just the nature of the track If you go off, you go into the wall.
 
You know why Lowndes didn't give Kelly any room there? Because you couldn't fit a bicycle between him and the side of the track! But the way you put it, a driver should yield to another if the attacking driver gets so much as a look up the inside, even when there's no hope of a pass. If Kelly were on the other side of Lowndes car, it would be a very different story. To me, Kelly would never have made it around Lowndes without taking a trip into the landscape, and any driver would know that. Which begs the question: what was Kelly doing there when there was no chance of a successful pass around the outside?

I see what I see an you see what you see. Ford fans will always see Kelly tapping Lowndes and see Kelly being imaptient and not having the sense to back off when he sould have. Holden fans will always see Lowndes stubbornly holding his racing line and being his own worst enemy. Personally, I believe Rick Kelly cheated, and I don't think there's anything that could persuade me otherwise. It's like the time when Ambrose and Murphy had that coming-together on the Mountain a few years ago that put both of them out. If you watch the playback frame-by-frame you can see what looks like Murphy's front wheels turning so that he deliberately hits Ambrose in retaliation for passing him, but it's not entirely clear and could therefore be anything. You read into it what you will, but I personally think Rick Kelly was the least deserving champion in the series history, regardless of what happened at the Island, if only because he won overall without taking a single round victory.

And for the record, I haven't actually seen the 2007 indicent until just now. It looks like a bit of paint exchange: Lowndes made his move and probably found he had understeer at the wrong place and in the wrong time and it just went from there.

And as for that article, Winterbottom was obviously upset over the fact that he was the innocent bystander and stood a very real chance of winning the round.
 
Guys, give it a rest.

Especially given the news of Ashley Cooper.
 
Guys, give it a rest.
I felt is was still relevant to discuss it, given that Lowndes was once again in a racing incident. Going back over other ones seemed to be the best course of action because we may have spotted a pattern. However, I won't keep debating the issue. I've made my arguments, clear as day. To continue would just mean repeating myself.
VTRacing
Especially given the news of Ashley Cooper.
I only just heard about that half an hour ago. He came from the (fairly) small town I grew up in - though I didn't know him at all, and nor will I claim to - but I know the town will be deeply upset, and I'm with them.
 
wow i missed clipsal 500 and all this happened...RIP Ashley Cooper...
 
Yeah sad to hear of another passing in the developement series.

On a lighter note all this talk about the accident that took out 3 of fords top drivers kinda overshadowed the fact that Cameron McConville got second in the 2nd race. Now this is something that noone expected, turn back the clock to the last round and the BJR (Team BOC) were struggling and First round of the new year with a new manufacturer and a new driver they get second! Not to mention the speed of the PMR cars, running in the top 10 while they lasted (Ingall) and the drive by Lee Holdsworth clean calm and he was rewarded with top Holden in the first race and 3rd in the second.

Yes i am a die hard holden supporter but i do have a soft spot for DJR
 
Swap McConville and Holdsworth around there mate. Lee got Cameron a few laps from the end.

Sad news about Ashley Cooper but he was a registred organ donor and has saved a few lives with his organs. This accident might force some changes to turn eight next year.
 
Yeah sorry my screw up

Is it just me or is craig lowndes complaining a lot more about slower cars in his way? It seems in every race that is televised he whinges to his race engineer at least once. Suck it up and get past him!

Watching the V8Extra show the other day brought up some valid points, for to long now there have been some light tap and the driver gets a drive through penalty it ruins the race for those guys that get blocked lap after lap. Now it seems that the new driving standards observer Tomas Mezera is going to let them race. Also he was saying that drivers need to blame themselves for incidents. For example the accident at Adilade (sp) no driver was said to have blamed themselves for the crash. As a race driver you can see what your movements do to other drivers you can race fairly and give each other racing room.
 
I think you hear Lowndes whinge the most because the telecast listenes in on his radio the most. I don't think any of the other drivers would be any different over the radio to their engineer.

I don't think you will ever hear a driver blame themselves for an Adelaide type incident. Lowndes probably thought he was past far enough or underestimated the amount of room he left Courtney and Courtney may have thought he could keep his boot on the accelerator and keep the inside line fot the next left hander. I didn't see V8 Xtra but considering how Crompton kept telling us about the 20 minute drivers briefing that ended going for two hours and how the new interpretation of the rules wouldn't tolerate any rubbing that results in a change of position I was surprised that some of the drivers didn't get penalties for some of their moves, Courtney and Whincup in particular in saturdays race.

Lowndes and Ingall have been named as assistants to Mezera to give him advice on some of the different characteristics of the circuits this year.
 
Well, that was an interesting round ... the Hamilton race was always going to be very good or very messy; it turned out to be both. A shame Jamie Whincup is out for the weekend, though. That's going to no favours for his title bid, especially with Tander winning the race today.

The circuit seems pretty good, but they've put the Start/Finish line in the wrong place. I think that was the major problem with the start of the race today: the first two corners are simply too tight and narrow to be conductive to good racing. They should kill that stupid fiddly little chicane on the back straight for next year and re-locate the Start/Finish line there as the turn at the end of that straight is much smoother and has a run-off area rather than simply an escape road. Pit Lane would also have to move; the entry should be just before what is now turn three and run down that side of the roundabout, though it may be a little narrow. Doing that would make what is currently the main straight (which would subsequently become the back straight) wider in the lead-up to what is currently turn one, which would make it a much safer corner.
 
I think that was the major problem with the start of the race today: the first two corners are simply too tight and narrow to be conductive to good racing.
That's a general issue with any street circuit, regardless of the types of corners in the first part of the lap ;)

Even if the first corner at Hamilton was a sweeper instead of the 90 that it actually is, you'd still get pileups into turn 2 :|

While on the whole I like the circuit, I can't help but feel it could've done with some more corners - do us Kiwis have an inherent fear of putting more than seven corners on a track used for V8 Supercar racing? :indiff: (the old Wellington circuit only had 11 or 12)

Honestly:
hamilton_map.gif

How boring is that?

The V8s should've either gone to Ruapuna (3.33km):
ruapuna_map.gif
(go Christchurch, w00t!)
or stayed at Pukekohe until the Hampton Downs (3.70km) track was finished:
hamptondowns_map.gif


I also find the chicane on the back straight pointless - all it's doing is popping tyres and chucking mufflers all over the track :| The chicane at Surfers' Paradise is a lot more effective than the one at Hamilton.
 
Honestly:
hamilton_map.gif

How boring is that?
I know it doesn't look like much, but there's no real detail in there; turn three is actually made up of a right-left-right combination, and there's no turn four on the map. I agree that chicane is fiddly at best, but all it has to do is slow the cars down for the sweeper. It's also very bumpy, there's a whole host of surface chagnes, and the drivers seem to like it, which must count for something. If they came out and said it was no good and that they hated it, then we'd be in trouble, but Hamilton is honestly a far better circuit than the likes of Barbagallo (where you can see your own bumper vanishing around the corner ahead when you're on a good lap). Maybe there will be a second New Zealand round at Hampton Downs once the circuit is finished ...
 
YEAH! Tander and Skaife win the Phillip Island 500km.:dopey: Such a better race than Sandown, Phillip Island is just a better and more interesting track, not to mention more globally recognised.
 
Oh shoot. I sorta forgot about that race.:yuck: RanhammerR34 and I usually get to watch the races online from the V8 Supercars website, but he had to go to bed early for the MotoGP race and I was too tired to watch it myself given where we are(US EDT).

I'll make a note of it to watch the Bathurst 1000 next month provided anything unforeseen comes up at my end. ;)
 
It was mental in the rain, they had a short shower but it belted down so most teams stayed on slicks, knowing it would pass soon, absolute mayhem.:crazy:
 
Wasn't as much mayhem as in the past though until the BOC car rolled
 
Wasn't as much mayhem as in the past though until the BOC car rolled

That's because they all slowed to like 80km/hr on the straights, they were practically crawling.
 
While watching the race i kept a mental tab on Gizzy (Van Gisbergen) and for im to catch and pass Whincup in those changing conditions shows his wet weather talent. I think the commentators summed it up nicely by saying he's the next Jimmy Richards.

Mayhem???? During the wet weather there was more cars going off than a whole season of F1
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back