Games I can see upsetting GoW:
- F.E.A.R
- Battlefield 2
- Half-Life 2: Episode One
- Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter
...None of those, IMO, could even touch GoW in most circumstances...
If I may clarify, these are the console versions of some of the older games that have become available on XBOX or 360. I'm wondering now if I meant to say Battlefield 2142, not Battlefield 2... I don't recall for sure. 2142 has had its fair share of "so-so" press, so I really wouldn't call it a "headline" contender in any way, added to that, it isn't even on 360 (yet).
GRAW and RS: Vegas are indeed strong competitors, particularly Vegas. I haven't played a RS title in years because they just weren't what I wanted to play, but this time around I may actually spend some money on it.
Maybe.
As for Half-Life, who knows. Isn't there another Half-Life 2 sequel out there as well? I haven't been paying much attention really, as I've been busy, but there was a lot of hype going into all of them.
---
To be honest, there isn't much out there to compete. On the 360 alone, there isn't a whole lot to out-class it in its genre, much less others as well. Test Drive Unlimited could be in the running for best 360 title, but it won't get it. There just haven't been many titles with the level of polish and "fun" as there has been with GoW. Next year, it will be a VERY hard year to pick though. When you have Bioshock going up against Halo 3, it is going to be a battle-royale for the top-spot, no questions there.
...If we want to go multi-platform for a second, again there isn't a ton of competition. Maybe...
- Dead Rising: Maybe GoW's best competition on the 360?
- Resistance: A long shot really, as sure it is a great game, but nothing too far beyond what we have already seen (if we follow Rici's rules...)
- Rayman Raving Rabbits: Innovative controls, fun games, good humor... Still a long shot though
- Zelda: Twilight Princess: Yeah, its a Zelda game alright
- Okami: Long-awaited, great game, but didn't get the recognition that it deserved. Too bad, awesome game.
- Guitar Hero II: I don't think I have to explain that one...
---
Thats about all I can think of...