Gran Turismo 7 Physics

  • Thread starter Thread starter Shingo_civic
  • 7,103 comments
  • 868,752 views

Do you want more detailed and realistic physics on the next GT


  • Total voters
    203
  • Poll closed .
Here's the thing, if you want true to life, you need to be iRacing. This is a console game for console gamers, it's mean to be accessible. And I am not a fan of the physics right now with race cars but I do like having a safer rear end where i can use TC1 instead of TC2, because TC2 is absolutely brutal and slow.
 
Last edited:
Well…hmm thats kinda the thing. Using a generic game specific tc setting. As opposed to what a manufacturer built into a car during a specific generation and then making comments about accuracy and realism is confusing. Most cars arent super skittish, which is what gt7 has been in the past. Nor are they super grippy monsters. I kinda think a good use for ai would be to find a way to create a physics system which would simulate the normal forces at work and then let it play out for each car. Heck. Maybe it would be able to model each cars tcs etc system. Sure it would be great if humans could do it but they have proven unable, or unwilling, and certainly not ever in a reasonable time frame

Right now i would love it if each car simply performed as it would in the real world with ffb matched to that. Presently the ffb is better, as least for fanatec, than its ever been. Driving across a range of cars is more visceral and sensory drive than before and i don’t want to loose that. What i really don’t want to see is a return to the tack away from the michelin debacle where the game became full of overly skittish messes. It was like ice skating with dull blades and if cars actually were like that i would have been dead years ago.
 
Not to mention that of course they don't like it when what they've been training with, no matter if realistic or not, is changed. They were good at how it was and now have to do things differently and it's understandable but in the end it's their problem, not the game's. A similar example (which is never going to happen) would be adding actual bullet ballistics to Counter-Strike - at the moment it doesn't have proper gravity drop, wind, or even travel time - and seeing the amount of outrage among the esports guys when they'd have to adapt to that.
I do agree with this, and while I did mention SuperGT I am also conscious he has real world experience that means his opinion is worth considering.

At the same time yeah, a good chunk of aliens in sim racing do not have that experience, or experience in the applicable cars they play in online sims. It’s totally valid to note that if someone spends 800hrs in a physics model that changes substantially and becomes detrimental to their performance the easy scapegoat is to say the physics now suck. Their perception of car physics is fundamentally isolated to their experience in sport mode.

It’s like how we get that consistent argument that good physics means ‘hard’ or ‘difficult’ to drive.
 
I'm out of GT7 after a huge amount of time in there.

All I can say is, that I hope for a GT8 that it features a lot of new things and is not just a refinement of 7 and that the physics will feel great on controller. At this point I don't really care any more for the opinions of influencers, "pros", real life drivers and the lot.

Make the game fun for the overwhelming majority. With Kaz's focus on Sports Mode and GTWS a filthy casual like me always fears the worst.
 
Last edited:
It would be cool if there were two physics models. One for controller and one for wheels. It could be an in-game toggle you select. Thus avoiding the need for middle ground appeal. But, I have no clue how difficult that would be to implement.
 
I've found it interesting how few people have picked up on the default setting change, forced on by BOP and therefore in all the Daily Races and Time Trials, compared to how many people commenting on the terrible horrible no-good bad physics only (or predominantly) experience the game in these modes.
BoP has not addressed the fundamental problem of excessive coupling, that's what everyone is talking about.
 
excessive coupling
Close Up Flirting GIF


In the meantime, whatever that means, a frightening majority of people commenting on how bad the physics are now experience it only with the newly introduced default settings for the various racing car categories, because BOP forces them on and that's all they drive.
 
It would be cool if there were two physics models. One for controller and one for wheels. It could be an in-game toggle you select. Thus avoiding the need for middle ground appeal. But, I have no clue how difficult that would be to implement.
You don't need two physics models for that, you just need good optimisation. GT7 already handles inputs vastly differently from a controller compared to a wheel.
 
Close Up Flirting GIF


In the meantime, whatever that means, a frightening majority of people commenting on how bad the physics are now experience it only with the newly introduced default settings for the various racing car categories, because BOP forces them on and that's all they drive.
Ya, great point. It's a shame that tuning has diminished somewhat because of Sport Mode forcing the same tune, but a few moments of tweaking and things drive really well.
 
Well…hmm thats kinda the thing. Using a generic game specific tc setting. As opposed to what a manufacturer built into a car during a specific generation and then making comments about accuracy and realism is confusing.
This is an interesting problem I think we'll continue to run into with cars that have heavy computer controls influencing handling. Take the simple example of the R35 GTR and its ATTESA AWD system. There is NO way Nissan will divulge the algorithm of how ATTESA decides to send power to the wheels, and therefore this will not have been modeled within GT (or any SIM for that matter). And since electronic systems are closed doors, sadly I'm afraid SIMs (all of them) can only approximate to some degree, but never actually simulate those systems and thus how those cars drive will always only just be a good guesstimate.

It's a good thing I prefer RWD older cars anyway, I guess.
 
Last edited:
Close Up Flirting GIF


In the meantime, whatever that means, a frightening majority of people commenting on how bad the physics are now experience it only with the newly introduced default settings for the various racing car categories, because BOP forces them on and that's all they drive.
sports mode A DR, time trial 53 gold finishes, 24 silver finishes, assignments 100%, school 100%, tracks 100%, racing events 90%

A lot of people say that physics needs to be corrected, it's stupid to deny it and blame everything on the sports regime.
 
Last edited:
I do agree with this, and while I did mention SuperGT I am also conscious he has real world experience that means his opinion is worth considering.
It's a real missed opportunity that we can't get more meaty contributions from people with the access and resources to real cars and tracks toward the realism discussions with focused data points or very specific reflections from real life.

For example, if it were me, I'd be like: "In my IRL 911 GT3R, I tried going full throttle in 1st gear out of La Source at SPA and the tires immediately went up in a cloud of smoke and sent me 180 oversteer into the barrier. Here is my data trace from the real car showing what happened. Now compare this to me doing the exact same thing in GT7 and you can see where GT7 is wrong...."

Or: "Watch as I trail brake IRL into this corner and see how the car slips into oversteer immediately and I'm correcting using X degrees of counter-steering, and Y% of throttle to maintain a steady drift. Now let me do the exact same thing in GT7 and you can clearly see how in GT7 it understeers straight into the wall... PD should fix this clear deviation from real life based on my cold hard facts."

If I had access to the Nurb, or access to Tsukuba... Calling folks who regularly drive Streets of Willows, Watkins Glen, Redbull Ring, come help us out.
 
Last edited:
sports mode A DR, time trial 53 gold finishes, 24 silver finishes,
All under BOP conditions, yes.
A lot of people say that physics needs to be corrected
As has been the case since... all of the games.

And to reiterate, a large proportion of them are experiencing the game largely or exclusively under BOP conditions wherein the new default Gr.1-4 vehicle settings are forced on, and a much smaller proportion of which are paying any heed to this.

It's stupid to...
... not read posts and attack imaginary points in a combative fashion.

Yet...
 
All under BOP conditions, yes.

As has been the case since... all of the games.

And to reiterate, a large proportion of them are experiencing the game largely or exclusively under BOP conditions wherein the new default Gr.1-4 vehicle settings are forced on, and a much smaller proportion of which are paying any heed to this.

... not read posts and attack imaginary points in a combative fashion.

Yet...
The fact that the braking distance has become twice as short is a fact, but here they just blindly ignore the facts.

Relevance 0%
Show me the relevance
 
The fact that the braking distance has become twice as short is a fact,
Okay. The word you're looking for is "half", but okay.
but here they just blindly ignore the facts.
What is "here", who is "they", and what facts are being ignored "blindly"?

If this is in some way a response to my post, I'll note you clearly haven't actually read the post pointing out that you haven't read the post you're responding to before making stuff up to respond to. Which would be interesting.
 
Okay. The word you're looking for is "half", but okay.

What is "here", who is "they", and what facts are being ignored "blindly"?

If this is in some way a response to my post, I'll note you clearly haven't actually read the post pointing out that you haven't read the post you're responding to before making stuff up to respond to. Which would be interesting.
you're saying that only those who deal with BoP are unhappy with physics, then explain to me how does BoP affect tire grip?
 
you're saying that only those who deal with BoP are unhappy with physics
As I noted, you are not reading my post and are instead making up something else. This isn't even close to what I actually said.

Go back and actually read it before your next response. It's not possible to have any kind of conversation when you're making up my part of it.

then explain to me how does BoP affect tire grip?
Again, I didn't say that it did. I haven't even mentioned tyres. This is something that you have made up and ascribed to me.

However, once again, BOP forces the cars into their default suspension and differential settings (which very much affect mechanical grip) which, once again, are new in 1.72 in Gr.1, Gr.2, Gr.3, and Gr.4 cars.

Edit: While I'm hesitant to add another concept, since you're already having difficulty with the first ones, it's also entertaining to manually set the cars to the same numbers as the default settings.
 
I do agree with this, and while I did mention SuperGT I am also conscious he has real world experience that means his opinion is worth considering.
He has experience, but the question is: with what. Even if he's driven a real GT3 car it doesn't help much as the BoPed Gr3 in the game is a bad joke, they're running nearly real life GT4 power and weight figures with GT3 aero and grip - no wonder everything has masses of traction as there's a truckload of weight pushing the tyres down but no power to spin them. And the setups can be anything from really close to not even from the same solar system with the real cars, and somehow I'm leaning on the latter. PD has always been hopeless at getting even road car gear ratios right, let alone actual race car suspension settings.
 
The fact that the braking distance has become twice as short is a fact, but here they just blindly ignore the facts.
On which cars? Because it's not all cars throughout the game. I don't know where you were braking before, but I sure have not seen braking distances drop by half.

So, this "fact" seems a little suspect.
This is an interesting problem I think we'll continue to run into with cars that have heavy computer controls influencing handling. Take the simple example of the R35 GTR and its ATTESA AWD system. There is NO way Nissan will divulge the algorithm of how ATTESA decides to send power to the wheels, and therefore this will not have been modeled within GT
Games are systems.

In real life, each manufacturer designs a single car, that sometimes shares parts or tech with other cars in it's range.

In games, especially car games, it's a system. It starts with "the chassis", and then builds up from there. Adding in specific modelling on a per car basis would be a collection of special cases, and a disaster of a code base.

What they have is a core "assist" system that is common to all cars, which is why the stability control is in an assists menu rather than in a car's settings sheet.
 
Hey guys, I wonder if someone can help me here:

I've a friend who's beyond-frustrated with certain behaviours of the new physics. AFAIA he keeps losing control "randomly" (crashing out) and is at the point where he's considering other games.

He's not tech-savvy so I'm researching this for him. What I've said is all I know.

IIRC, wasn't there a standard set of parameter tweaks in either of or both of the suspension and diff sections that peeps came up with immediately after the physics update that effectively returned the general handling to pre-update characteristics?

I'm hoping that someone can share the tweaks or point me to a post where they're specified.

This is the only thing I can think of that might ensure my buddy stays in-the-fold. He's loved GT since GT4 and this is the first time he's "talked like this", so I take it the situation is kinda-desperate.
 
Hey guys, I wonder if someone can help me here:

I've a friend who's beyond-frustrated with certain behaviours of the new physics. AFAIA he keeps losing control "randomly" (crashing out) and is at the point where he's considering other games.

He's not tech-savvy so I'm researching this for him. What I've said is all I know.

IIRC, wasn't there a standard set of parameter tweaks in either of or both of the suspension and diff sections that peeps came up with immediately after the physics update that effectively returned the general handling to pre-update characteristics?

I'm hoping that someone can share the tweaks or point me to a post where they're specified.

This is the only thing I can think of that might ensure my buddy stays in-the-fold. He's loved GT since GT4 and this is the first time he's "talked like this", so I take it the situation is kinda-desperate.
Suggest next time your friend has a random loss of control he saves the replay and shares in the Showcase, then we can maybe identify the issue.

You can certainly adjust the suspension and diff but you cannot change the overall physics to what they were pre-update.

If I was trying to fix a car without seeing it I'd probably raise the suspension by 10-20 and raise the diff braking sensitivity by 20-40. But that is a wild guess.
 
Thanks for that mate.

When I said he's not tech-savvy I wasn't kidding so we can forget about uploading incidents. He lives way out woop woop and I don't have a car so there's that.

If I had to guess I'd say it's that he's getting caught out by snap oversteer. He loved the physics pre-update so I know if I can get him roughly to where he was he'll be happy.

I appreciate your response. 👍
 
So can nobody remember the situation where a few days after the update someone or some peeps came up with some basic tweaks, applicable to all cars and consisting of only 2 or 3 parameters (AFAICR), that took one back to a rough approximation of the previous handling characteristics?
 
Back