Joey D
Premium
- 47,885
- Lakes of the North, MI
- GTP_Joey
- GTP Joey
I've been around solid axled cars all my life and have been around new cars with IRS and I have to say the solid axle cars had a much better ride quality to them except for maybe something that's brand spanking new. I was impressed the first time I rode in a solid axle classic Mustang. I almost couldn't tell.
Personal observation doesn't really work though, especially since you or I probably haven't been around enough cars to sufficiently say. When looking at it from an engineering perspective, independent suspension will be better for NVH than a solid rear axle, it's why just about every car uses them now days. The only reason trucks still have solid axles is because they are stronger and can tolerate additional weight better.
Someone with an actual engineering background can probably explain it better and with better evidence than I can, I'm going based on what I know from the industry.