Favorite Beer - Domestic or Import

  • Thread starter Thread starter barryf1fan
  • 255 comments
  • 24,389 views
Sorry to necromance here, but, has anyone tried Sam Adams Octoberfest? Man, what an awesome beer.

I love Sam Adams Octoberfest. It is hands down the best beer they make. I don't like their traditional Boston Lager or a lot of their beer, but the Octoberfest is nice and malty without the excessive hoppy after taste that is a Sam Adams trademark.

Now, I will say that it is not comparable to a real German beer, but it is the best American imitator I have ever had. If you enjoy this I suggest trying a few German hefe-weizens. My favorite is Warsteiner, but Lowenbrau and Spaten are very good as well.

After immersing myself in Octoberfest beer specials I believe I have decided that German beer is my favorite, followed closely by Irish and British. The American craft brew imitators can be good as well, but I will take the original imports if I have the money to splurge.
 
Kingfisher - India (perfect with a Vindaloo! :drool: )
Tsingtao - China
Singha - Thailand

Wooooo I have a big bottle of Singha sitting in my fridge, they keep putting it on special offer at tesco and I keep buying it because it has this odd taste to it that makes it awesome while eating a meal. Apart from the above three other favorites are Peroni (both types), Asashi, san miguel and Corona with a lime. Oh man i'm gonna have to find some Staropramen though.

Also in the summer i'm partial to that Magners cider.

You know i've never realy had a Domestic beer in my entire life, so what the hell is a good one?
 
Also in the summer i'm partial to that Magners cider.
Is that anything like Woodchuck Cider? Woodchuck tastes almsot like apple juice. I haven't had any other ciders, but want to try them so I can have a "beer" that my wife will drink too.

You know i've never realy had a Domestic beer in my entire life, so what the hell is a good one?
Coors is probably the only one that I will drink willingly. If you like Killian's or Blue Moon you will like Coors. As far as I am concerned all the rest taste like dirty water.
 
I really enjoy Granville Island Pale Ale (Granville Island brewery in western canada) and (Y)Ebisu beer here in Japan. mmm. Sapporo is good too.
 
Coors is probably the only one that I will drink willingly. If you like Killian's or Blue Moon you will like Coors. As far as I am concerned all the rest taste like dirty water.

I should put my location back i'm from England btw.
 
Bitburger.

Its hard to find here in the states, so I usually stock and extra case or two when I do find it.
great choice! bitburger is my favourite domestic beer.
when i spent time in berlin, i enjoyed the local potsdamer rex pils, but i can't get it here in frankfurt...

but if i want to get drunk on a bargain, nothing beats 5.0 Original. 29 cent for half a litre and it actually tastes good, unlike all the other cheap ones on the market.

as for imported ones, i like irish beers, kilkenny or guinness.
 
I know it's not a 'beer', but I've been drinking a bit of Magners recently as well... you have to be careful though, since some places (esp. Irish bars, for some odd reason) can really rip you off with it... one pub I was in sells it in half bottles too, but they charge you over £2 for a half... (but with the ice in the glass, it 'looks' like a pint once you've poured it... perhaps their argument is that you drink it as quickly (or as slowly) as a normal pint and therefore they charge you more for it)... but the full bottle is over £4... considering that I pay just £2.50 for a pint bottle for it in my local should say something about the mark-up the Irish bar is making on the stuff :irked:
 
As for imports, Guinness is good. (as long as you're only drinking one)
Guinness has an undeserved reputation for being a "heavy" beer.

It's not a heavy stout at all. I can go to the pub and knock back 7 or 8 pints over the course of a night without a problem. It's quite mild and very drinkable.

Young's Luxury Double Chocolate stout on the other hand...

I like a nice stout or porter. I bought a case of Cooper's Extra Stout recently. It's really nice. I had Fuller's London Porter on a trip to England last year and was well impressed. I can get a Russian beer called Baltika Porter in a local shop and I really like it.

I can't get much of a selection of decent American beer here. I've had the Sierra Nevada Pale Ale, Anchor Liberty Ale and Goose Island IPA and was impressed by all of them, but I rarely see good American beers for sale here. Pity, because there seems to be a huge range of great American beer out there from what I've been reading.

Hefeweizens are nice for drinking in the summer - Franziskaner, Paulaner and another one called something like Schosserhofer I see in the shops here and they're all nice.

I see nice English ales from time to time too - Black Sheep, Fuller's London Pride, etc.

Sadly, there's not much in the way of decent Irish beer. A few ales and stouts, but nothing very special and rarely seen in the pubs here. You usually only get a Guinness tap, an ale (Smithwick's/Kilkenny) and a few crappy lagers (Bud, Harp, etc.)

Harp Lager is brewed in my hometown, but I think it's nasty.

What I'm trying to say is that I don't really have a favourite beer, but there's some great stuff out there.

The worst beer I've ever drank is either Tennent's Lager or Coors Light. The Tennent's tasted like fizzy vomit and Coors Light doesn't qualify as beer. Coors is already as thin and watery as beer gets, but they still made a light version? It's like carbonated water with yellow food colouring and alcohol.


KM.
 
considering that I pay just £2.50 for a pint bottle for it in my local should say something about the mark-up the Irish bar is making on the stuff :irked:
In the US I can usually buy a six pack of imported beer for $8 but one bottle in the local bar/pub/restaurant will run close to $4, if not more in some places. It gets even worse if you compare the price of a keg to the cost of a pint on draft.

Guinness Young's Luxury Double Chocolate stout on the other hand...
You shouldn't have to chew your beer.

I can't get much of a selection of decent American beer here. I've had the Sierra Nevada Pale Ale, Anchor Liberty Ale and Goose Island IPA and was impressed by all of them, but I rarely see good American beers for sale here. Pity, because there seems to be a huge range of great American beer out there from what I've been reading.
If you like anything by Sierra Nevada or any IPAs for that matter then we definitely have different tastes in beer.

Most of the American beer you are looking for aren't even considered American beer because anything outside the Budweiser, Miller, Coors, etc type beer is called a craft brew and many times charged as an import, apparently because it is using a non-American recipe. A perfect example of this is Killian's. I see way too many places charge import prices when it is just an Irish style Coors and is brewed in Colorado in the same facility as Coors.

You might enjoy Samuel Adams. This is a big might. Their seasonal brews are more to my liking, but they still don't hold up to imports in my opinion.

Coors Light doesn't qualify as beer. Coors is already as thin and watery as beer gets, but they still made a light version? It's like carbonated water with yellow food colouring and alcohol.
And this is what is considered traditional American beer, Coors being the "best" of the bunch in my opinion. Trust me, you are better off with your local Irish brews or imports from other countries. My favorite bar has a three page beer menu and I immediately flip to the import section. The only time I willing drink traditional American beer is if there is nothing else or at $1 beer night at a baseball game. They had Budweiser Select and it went down like nasty water. I thought if I drank enough it would affect me to the point that I wouldn't notice but it is so watered down that I never even felt a buzz. At least with imports I can feel something by the fourth beer.

If you really want to try the American craft brews I wish you luck. It is a long list of bad stuff to find a few choice good beers and then there are a lot of local mini-brewery styles that are hard to come by unless you live near the brewery. Locally I have Bluegrass Brewing Company (BBC) but that has to be some of the nastiest stuff out there. Even their Octoberfest beer sucked.
 
How'd I miss this thread after all these years? I suppose much of this has been said, but here goes...

Import:
Bass Ale (still my favorite)
Heineken Tarwebok (sometimes called "Dark" sometimes in these parts)
Stella Artois (just tried it 6 months ago; there's been a massive ad campaign for it in the past year or so here...it seems to have worked)
Guiness Draught (the only canned stuff I'll drink)
Amstel Light (if I want a beer after being outdoors)

Domestic:
Anchor Steam Beer
Samuel Adams (most varieties)
Killian's Red (good all-purpose beer for those who aren't fans of imports, works for parties); is this an "import", though?

I'm not of big fan of the "Big 3" American brands; Michelob Dark or Heffenweisen (sp?) might be the best of them all, in my opinion. Miller used to make a beer called "Miller" (duh!) with a red label, but they discontinued it after a few years, it wasn't too bad for a plain-jane domestic.

Two other imports I'd like to mention are Warsteiner and Bitburger; I like both, the the problem is that a lot of the time the quality of it varies. Maybe the bottles sit in a warehouse for too long, because sometimes it's delicious, other times it tastes like puke. I usually go the safe route, and look for them on tap only in these parts.
 
Most of the American beer you are looking for aren't even considered American beer because anything outside the Budweiser, Miller, Coors, etc type beer is called a craft brew and many times charged as an import, apparently because it is using a non-American recipe.
I don't agree. Most of the macro brews in America are lagers loosely based on recipes that would have been imported from Europe in ye olde days. If anything, the American craft beers are more American than Coors and Miller - they're American because they use American hops and barley and because they've gone their own way and produced styles that aren't traditional in Europe. American Pale Ale is recognised style of beer because it's distinct from an English Pale Ale, though it evolved from it, but nondescript lagers like Budweiser, Coors, etc. is just the same style of crap as the macro lagers over here.

I've no problem paying more for good beer. Considering how much wine lovers pay for a good bottle of plonk, even expensive beer is relatively cheap. Just drink less but better beer if price is an issue.


KM.
 
I'm not much of a beer drinker, but the only one I have found that I do like would have to be an import cause I had it while traveling in Vietnam.
It's called Tiger beer. But I have not been able to find it in any stores here... I think I would have to special order it.:boggled:
 
I'm not of big fan of the "Big 3" American brands; Michelob Dark or Heffenweisen (sp?) might be the best of them all, in my opinion.

The widmer bros. hefeweizen? I hate that crap. german wheat is just different.
 
Truth be known, I've tried a couple of IPA's and found them to be too bitter.

I know it's cheap beer, but I like Corona (with or without lime).
I have developed a taste for Tecate.
I really like Blue Moon Belgian White Ale. Read about it in a Spenser novel.
If it's good enough for Spenser...

I have recently discovered a little brewery out of Colorado called Flying Dog. Their "Tire bite" brand is quite good.

I'm currently out of beer, and may have a go at "Red Stripe" just cause I like the commercials. If I hate the beer, I can refrain from buying it again.
 
I know it's not a 'beer', but I've been drinking a bit of Magners recently as well... you have to be careful though, since some places (esp. Irish bars, for some odd reason) can really rip you off with it... one pub I was in sells it in half bottles too, but they charge you over £2 for a half... (but with the ice in the glass, it 'looks' like a pint once you've poured it... perhaps their argument is that you drink it as quickly (or as slowly) as a normal pint and therefore they charge you more for it)... but the full bottle is over £4... considering that I pay just £2.50 for a pint bottle for it in my local should say something about the mark-up the Irish bar is making on the stuff :irked:

The pub I go to they give you the pint bottle and a glass full of ice.

Also i'm drinking my last bottle of singha with my steak. I swear this beer tastes better while eating stuff.
 
Also i'm drinking my last bottle of singha with my steak. I swear this beer tastes better while eating stuff.

Try one with a red-hot Thai curry dish. :drool: :drool: :drool: :drool: :drool:

As far as domestic British recommendations for you go, I mentioned some of the best ones in my original post a couple of pages back, here's a recap though!

Samuel Smith's (Oatmeal Stout, Nut Brown Ale and Old Brewery Pale Ale) I can get in bottles here in California and they're excellent, but still nothing compared to a handpulled pint from a real Samuel Smith's pub. You may have to travel "oop north" a bit from where you're at to find one, but I don't think you'd be disappointed. My personal favourites are The Falcon and Ye Olde Boot Inn in Chester. 👍

Belhaven Scottish Ale. I can get it in draughtflow cans here in California too, so I can only assume it's widely available everywhere in UK! Smooth, creamy, and a taste quite unlike any other beer I've ever supped. 👍

You can't ever go far wrong with Timothy Taylor real ales either, try looking on the CAMRA website for a pub near you with a good real ale selection. You may have to try a few until you find one you really like, but it's fun trying new things. And you'll get drunk doing it, which is an added bonus!

There's a time & a place for most types of beer. A handpulled pint of Bitter sometimes just doesn't cut it on a hot summer day, a cold pint of lager or bottled beer seems to fit the bill. However, on a wintery evening in front of a fire in the pub there just seems something wrong with sitting with a cold bottle, when a pint of Guinness or Bitter would fit so well!
Kingfisher, Cobra, Flying Horse or Taj Mahal are perfect accompaniments to a vindaloo of course, and Sushi wouldn't be the same without an Asahi, Kirin or Sapporo for good measure! (and maybe a few glasses of cold sake too!) Mmmmmmmmm! :)
And if you're going to insist on sticking to bottles after you've experimented a bit, don't forget to do it after you've experimented with a few of the Belgian Trappist beers. They come in big 750ml bottles and some have a hell of a kick! :D They'd be good bottles to stick to!!!!
 
I've no problem paying more for good beer...even expensive beer is relatively cheap. Just drink less but better beer if price is an issue.


KM.
Exactly; although I don't really search much further than a liquor store or the local supermarket (a decent variety in multi-cultural South Florida, quantity rather than quality in the rural areas, maybe Heineken can be found).

I can buy a 6-pack of Stella for $8 (probably the most expensive "major distributor" 6-pack in the area), whereas if you go to ballgame or a bar, a single bottle or a plastic cup of Budweiser can run you $5-7. I'd rather enjoy the good stuff at home with a meal, and keep a 6-pack of something a little cheaper when my buddles are over to play dominoes and video games.

Or just break out the scotch for special occasions.
 
How can anyone drink beer? :yuck: It's disgusting! But, I guess if you get drunk, you won't be able to tell what it tastes like... :lol:
Wow, what a difference a year would make. :lol: I love the stuff now. :) I prefer Bud Light, but I'll drink whatever is in the keg. I can't taste the difference between domestic and imported, so whatever. Anything is better than Keystone Light, though. :yuck:



Oh my... 2 years can make a lot of difference... Beer is the nectar of the gods for me now. I love it.

Favorite Domestics: Goose Island Honkers Ale

Imports: Pilsner Urquell, and to a much lesser extent Heineken.

I've had a few exotic beers recently. I had this St. Peters Cream Stout which was delicious! Also, the Belgian beer called Fat Tire which had even more flavor than Pilsner Urquell, if that's possible. They were $4 and $6 per bottle, respectively, so a rare treat.

For keggars, I prefer Coors Light over other common keg Beers. If only Goose Island did Kegs...
 
I want a beer, NOW!!! Nah, I'm way too young, but I like root beer!

Stewarts is good, and MUG cream soda looks like a watered down cup of pee-beer, I scare my sister by saying it is beer!

What a maroon...
 
Also, the Belgian beer called Fat Tire which had even more flavor than Pilsner Urquell, if that's possible.

Seems like your tastes are evolving well, but you still have a little to learn, young ale-connoiseur!

Fat Tire is actually a domestic beer for the US, but brewed by the deceptively named New Belgium Brewing Company of Colorado, not sure exactly where, Fort Collins perhaps?
It's Belgian inspired (by a bike ride around Belgium) and brewed in a Belgian style, but has no Belgian connection other than that. The brewers of the New Belgium company take pride in the fact that they brew beers that taste like imports, while they maintain a policy of not importing their beers anywhere else! ;)
It is indeed a great beer! 👍

And now you know! :)

*edit* Came across another truly excellent domestic beer that's not widely available on our roadtrip last month. Can't seem to buy it anywhere else though. :grumpy: Brewed by the small brewery in Mammoth Lakes, CA. their Mammoth Double Nut Brown Ale is absolutely wonderful! 👍
 
I don't drink much beer anymore, for obvious reasons most of you know why. But, I'm still not completely enjoying my re-found friend Heineken. It's too sweet. I like the thick, rich taste and finish, but it's just too darn sweet.

What is sort of like Heineken, but a lot less sweet? I'm sure you can understand why I don't go on a drinking taste test binge, so any help would be appreciated. I'd like a thick, hearty beer with a strong finish and lingering aftertaste. It's not that I don't like a crisp beer, but I always find them to be a bit too light and thin.

Any beers I should try? I had one Samuel Adams, don't know which one it was, but it was crap. It tasted like bitter cocoa and gym sock water.
 
Killian's Red (good all-purpose beer for those who aren't fans of imports, works for parties); is this an "import", though?
I don't agree. Most of the macro brews in America are lagers loosely based on recipes that would have been imported from Europe in ye olde days. If anything, the American craft beers are more American than Coors and Miller - they're American because they use American hops and barley and because they've gone their own way and produced styles that aren't traditional in Europe. American Pale Ale is recognised style of beer because it's distinct from an English Pale Ale, though it evolved from it, but nondescript lagers like Budweiser, Coors, etc. is just the same style of crap as the macro lagers over here.
I agree that craft brews are American. There is no doubt, they don't stand up to the imports they are imitating. But depending on the bar/liquor store you will pay import prices for it. Killian's "Irish Red" is about $20 more for a six pack than Coors and their Blue Moon "Belgian White Ale" will run about $3 more. The craft brews are a tricky way for American companies to make more money with little extra effort. They taste better than traditional American beer and can be good to drink but are far from a good import.

I've no problem paying more for good beer. Considering how much wine lovers pay for a good bottle of plonk, even expensive beer is relatively cheap. Just drink less but better beer if price is an issue.
The only beer I avoid due to price are the lambics. They aren't good enough to justify the prices.

Gil
I have recently discovered a little brewery out of Colorado called Flying Dog. Their "Tire bite" brand is quite good.
Flying Dog is interesting and I enjoy their beer, but I rank them as moderate as far as good does. They are about like Old Leghumper and Elliot Ness Pale Ale. Good, but I can find better for my money, in my opinion.

I'm currently out of beer, and may have a go at "Red Stripe" just cause I like the commercials. If I hate the beer, I can refrain from buying it again.
Red Stripe is a love it or hate it beer. If they are on a special I will drink a lot and love it. I've also picked up a six pack for a party before. It is the only beer tasting beer that my wife will drink. It is crisp and goes down easy, but if you want something a little heavier or darker you might not enjoy it.

If only Goose Island did Kegs...
I think they do. They have it on tap at my local bar. The tap handle is a big goose head. It looks funny amongst all the other beer brands typical looking handles.

Here it is (My local bar has Honkers Pale Ale, not this):
goose_island_tap.jpg


Any beers I should try? I had one Samuel Adams, don't know which one it was, but it was crap. It tasted like bitter cocoa and gym sock water.
You just described my opinion of about 90% of their line. They have enough variety so that everyone can find something they like, but sometimes it requires a lot of bad taste-testing. I suggest the Octoberfest or try some of their holiday brews at Christmas. Judging by the cocoa flavor you described I think it may have been their dark lager.



And out of curiosity, has anyone tried Cave Creek Chili Beer? It comes with an actual chili pepper in the beer. Imagine drinking a Corona, only to have it turn to liquid fire as it goes down. I can best describe the experience as drinking beer flavored chili juice. If you manage to drink the whole beer you will feel it for days to come.
 
What is sort of like Heineken, but a lot less sweet? I'm sure you can understand why I don't go on a drinking taste test binge, so any help would be appreciated. I'd like a thick, hearty beer with a strong finish and lingering aftertaste. It's not that I don't like a crisp beer, but I always find them to be a bit too light and thin.

Any beers I should try? I had one Samuel Adams, don't know which one it was, but it was crap. It tasted like bitter cocoa and gym sock water.

I suppose it depends on how strong you like your beer to be. If we're talking 5% stuff like Stella (which i hate - it's so full of chemical crap :yuck: ) Try Peroni (Nastro Azuro) or San Miguel for that mediterranean vibe. Or if you like your beer a little sharper go for the East European Staropramen or Pilsner Urquell. If its a strong beer that you want to enjoy at home not just chuck down your neck, than you can't go wrong with the trapist style Belgian offerings like Leffe (around 6.5%) or Duval (about 8.5%) - they're an aquired taste, but a taste well worth aquiring :sly:

This is what's available in the UK, i don't know if you can get all of these in the US.

I went a few years back to Busch Gardens in Tampa, Florida where i tasted some of Busch's less familiar, low-volume offerings most of which were quite enjoyable. If you can track any of these down you probably won't be disapointed. I've always liked Michelob when i've seen it here in the UK - i don't know what sort of 'image' it has in the US.

http://www.anheuser-busch.com/
 
....or San Miguel for that mediterranean vibe.....

:confused: Mediterranean? When did they move the Philippines there? Despite it's Spanish sounding name, San Miguel is about as European as Kangaroos. :lol:

Solid Lifters is lucky, being in California we have an excellent store called Beverages & More (or BevMos! for short) which has a great selection of domestic craft brews, and a lot of good imports from around the globe. You should check one out sometime! Stock your fridge up with a hundred different bottles and go at it! You're bound to find something that you can acquire a taste for! 👍

And out of curiosity, has anyone tried Cave Creek Chili Beer? It comes with an actual chili pepper in the beer. Imagine drinking a Corona, only to have it turn to liquid fire as it goes down. I can best describe the experience as drinking beer flavored chili juice. If you manage to drink the whole beer you will feel it for days to come.

I have, you can get that one at BevMos! too! I rather like it oddly enough. Especially if I can persuade the beer soaked chilli to leave the bottle at the end so I can chomp on it! Although to anyone who's ever read my profile that probably won't come as too much of a surprise! :trouble:
 
:confused: Mediterranean? When did they move the Philippines there? Despite it's Spanish sounding name, San Miguel is about as European as Kangaroos. :lol:

:irked:

Wiki
San Miguel in Spain has the same origins as San Miguel in the Philippines. However, since 1953 the brewery in Spain has been under separate ownership and no longer has any connections with San Miguel Corp Philippines. The beer in Spain is brewed by San Miguel Fabricas de Cerveza y Malta S.A., part of the San Miguel-Mahou group.

This is the proper San Miguel we get in Europe and blighty - not that Pilipino rubbish you must get in the US.
 
Back