Ok, my study is complete, and I tried to be careful doing it. Here's my report:
PRIMITIVE LIST
(as quoted by myself in Page 4, post #70)
1 - mhm66
2 - AlanG184
3 - new_soul
4 - jjaisli
5 - MannyMoenjack
6 - GTP_Hun
7 - arvore
8 - kemp333
9 - Simcoeace
10 - fingers&thumbs
11 - bullie77
12 - Wnabm3
13 - GTP_CarlPKY
14 - ShaneMcane
15 - Redgate
16 - lpb-nissan-gt
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1st MATCH
Challenger - Simcoeace (9th place)
Challengee - arvore (7th place)
Winner - Simcoeace
REVISED LIST
(CarlPky and ShaneMcane meanwhile removed
vompatti and PhantomI - Fourwheelbrow - added)
1 - mhm66
2 - AlanG184
3 - new_soul
4 - jjaisli
5 - MannyMoenjack
6 - GTP_Hun
7 - Simcoeace
8 - kemp333
9 - arvore
10 - fingers&thumbs
11 - bullie77
12 - Wnabm3
13 - vompatti
14 - Redgate
15 - lpb-nissan-gt
16 - PhanTomI
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2nd MATCH
Challenger - AlanG184 (2nd place)
Challengee - mhm66 (1st place)
Winner - AlanG184
REVISED LIST
1 - AlanG184
2 - mhm66
3 - new_soul
4 - jjaisli
5 - MannyMoenjack
6 - GTP_Hun
7 - Simcoeace
8 - kemp333
9 - arvore
10 - fingers&thumbs
11 - bullie77
12 - Wnabm3
13 - vompatti
14 - Redgate
15 - lpb-nissan-gt
16 - PhanTomI
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3rd MATCH
Challenger - arvore (9th place)
Challengee - Simcoeace (7th place)
Winner - Simcoeace
REVISED LIST
(also, vitormazzi added)
1 - AlanG184
2 - mhm66
3 - new_soul
4 - jjaisli
5 - MannyMoenjack
6 - Simcoeace
7 - GTP_Hun
8 - kemp333
9 - arvore
10 - fingers&thumbs
11 - bullie77
12 - Wnabm3
13 - vompatti
14 - Redgate
15 - lpb-nissan-gt
16 - PhanTomI
17 - vitormazzi_
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4th MATCH
Challenger - GTP_Hun (7th place)
Challengee - jjaisli (4th place)
Winner - jjaisli
REVISED LIST
(Manny, due to continued absence, meanwhile moved to bottom of list)
1 - AlanG184
2 - mhm66
3 - jjaisli
4 - new_soul
5 - Simcoeace
6 - GTP_Hun
7 - kemp333
8 - arvore
9 - fingers&thumbs
10 - bullie77
11 - Wnabm3
12 - vompatti
13 - Redgate
14 - lpb-nissan-gt
15 - PhanTomI
16 - vitormazzi_
17 - MannyMoenjack
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5th MATCH
Challenger - bullie77 (11th place)
Challengee - kemp333(8th place)
Winner - kemp333
REVISED LIST
1 - AlanG184
2 - mhm66
3 - jjaisli
4 - new_soul
5 - Simcoeace
6 - kemp333
7 - GTP_Hun
8 - arvore
9 - fingers&thumbs
10 - bullie77
11 - Wnabm3
12 - vompatti
13 - Redgate
14 - lpb-nissan-gt
15 - PhanTomI
16 - vitormazzi_
17 - MannyMoenjack
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6th MATCH
Challenger - Redgate (14th place)
Challengee - fingers&thumbs(10th place)
Winner - finger&thumbs
REVISED LIST
1 - AlanG184
2 - mhm66
3 - jjaisli
4 - new_soul
5 - Simcoeace
6 - kemp333
7 - GTP_Hun
8 - fingers&thumbs
9 - arvore
10 - bullie77
11 - Wnabm3
12 - vompatti
13 - Redgate
14 - lpb-nissan-gt
15 - PhanTomI
16 - vitormazzi_
17 - MannyMoenjack
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
7th MATCH
Challenger - PhantomI (16th place)
Challengee - vompatti (13th place)
Winner - vompatti
REVISED LIST
1 - AlanG184
2 - mhm66
3 - jjaisli
4 - new_soul
5 - Simcoeace
6 - kemp333
7 - GTP_Hun
8 - fingers&thumbs
9 - arvore
10 - bullie77
11 - vompatti
12 - Wnabm3
13 - Redgate
14 - lpb-nissan-gt
15 - PhanTomI
16 - vitormazzi_
17 - MannyMoenjack
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Comparing this to your list, as posted in the OP, I detect two mistakes: you moved kemp up twice (this was your doubt), and also you forgot to move fingers&thumbs up one slot for his win against Redgate. Also, don't forget to check post #60 and add GTP_Justin to the list.
EDIT: Hey Biggles, keep the "move one up" rule, without it the 1st half of the table will freeze. And I know what I'm talking about, I already lost two positions (to you and kemp) because of it!