It's frustrating for sure. Just like you, I sit and fantasize about all the ideas I think they could do that would be very much inline with Kaz and GTs vibe.
A weird, sad, and dumb thought I've had in the past is that I often don't post them on here cause I figured Turn 10 was probably combing the internet for design ideas and they'd steal mine and do a crappy job of it lol But now it seems like they are gone so..
Also, like Music Rally, I believe "Rally" in general needs to be ditched. Maybe some other people disagree. It's a big waste of resources. How many dirt/snow/rally courses are in the game? Those could've been original tarmac courses at least. Keep putting rally cars in the game, but just in their Tarmac setups. I've seen Famine say this has (or will now have) the biggest track list in the series but it feels so small to me. I don't like many of these new original courses. Maggiore & Dragon Trail are good I guess. I still never drive on them.
Off on another rant tangent..
Might be going a little off topic here but since you brought this up...
Interesting... a few weeks ago, during an ongoing Rally Time Trial where pretty much only a few select aliens can make it into the Gold range I found myself wondering about PD making the bold (and probably VERY controversial) decision of getting rid of all things rally in GT.
How about making a (spin-off) Gran Turismo exclusively dedicated to Rally instead? 👀 From the oldies to the very latest machines out there, the classics, the most famous tracks... a proper Gran Turismo for the die-hard rally fan, huh?
As much as I don't love it, I also don't hate it as well so I think it's probably excessive to remove rally altogether from the series.
One thing I like about Gran Turismo is that the game actually gives you the chance to try many different things, things you weren't expecting to do at first, like driving on dirt/snow for example.
Some people might actually prefer this type of racing over the "standard" tarmac racing, despite being just a "tiny diversion" from the main focus of the game... personally I just try to do my best every time, but the tarmac is definitely where I'm comfortable at.
One thing I'd very much love to see someday is something in the lines of the Legends DLC for NFS Shift 2 were we get the chance to drive on very iconic tracks from the 60's and 70's (with their layouts accurately recreated) so we could actually use/recreate some very legendary races with all of those expensive beauties from the LCD, hell I'd even go further back all the way to the 30's, imagine a grid filled with "Silver Arrows", Auto Union vs Mercedes, huge V16 engines revving... this is the kind of stuff that makes my heart pump!
We already had Monza and Brands Hatch in their 80's layout in GT6 so... one can dream.
Anyway, this isn't a wishlist thread so I'll see myself out...