What has PD ever done for us?

  • Thread starter Thread starter MeanElf
  • 155 comments
  • 8,556 views
I'd also like to point out that you didn't respond to my post either in which I very plainly pointed out to you that there are indeed BUGS in GT5. I directly pointed out (2), one of which is fatal for the game save. The other, which developed after the 1.06 update, is annoying and locks the game up solid during game play requiring you to exit the game completely. They are both serious bugs, not quirks! You initiated a conversation with me by responding to my original post, then you didn't even bother to read or acknowledge my response back to you.

No I thought your counter argument was a little weak, to be honest.

A bug caused by viewing the museum multiple times (something we've all done right?), a strange one but in fairness not something that could easily have been foreseen through playtesting etc, and the other "bug", whatnow? My game isn't locking up, explain please, as to be a genuine bug it needs to be universal and caused purely by the software. Thanks :)
 
You still haven't replied to both my posts directed at you, lost for words?

Neeewp not really, this is a general discussion and not all about a couple of naysayers, who are now clearly floundering in their "arguments" and having to counter everyone else individually.

The Sonic example was just that, an example. It doesn't matter how hard the game is. Same with any game, the argument that purchasing the game gives you some right to be able to access all of its content from the off is frankly ridiculous. You bought the game Gran Turismo 5, not a set of virtual cars that you then somehow "own". I've discussed this in another thread too. I would perhaps agree with you if some of the content was genuinely "locked" with no means of access, but that isn't the case.

And as for you posting here, I was just illustrating that you have made well over 600 posts on these forums, despite being apparently disgusted with the game these forums are dedicated to (was it you who branded Kaz a "liar"? I need to check that) so yes I do wonder what you are actually getting out of all this. If it entertains you, presumably this is so, that's nice but many of the rest of us are getting royally fed up of the whiners and negativity the same select people are bringing to a forum dedicated to a game we enjoy.

By all means think of something else you don't like, or were dissappointed by, and find a forum about that and bash that too. Or do something positive and worthwhile.
 
Last edited:
PD has produced a fantastic series for us all to enjoy (although we all enjoy it at different levels)

GT is still in good standing as a flagship series for the console. Just look up a list of other PS3 exclusives that have long histories. First off, there aren't many that date back to PS1, and second, those that do haven't produced many games, but all have received critical acclaim (including GT5, although everyone has their own opinions)
 
No I thought your counter argument was a little weak, to be honest.

A bug caused by viewing the museum multiple times (something we've all done right?), a strange one but in fairness not something that could easily have been foreseen through playtesting etc, and the other "bug", whatnow? My game isn't locking up, explain please, as to be a genuine bug it needs to be universal and caused purely by the software. Thanks :)

The fatal bug is caused by having a game save file at or greater than 4165 kb. The other (post 1.06 update) causes the game to lock up solid at random times. It's happened to me personally several times and others here on the forum (there are posts regarding the bug), only since the v1.06 update. These are bugs not quirks.
 
Last edited:
OK potentially your save can reach that size without viewing museum cards (pre-fix) but the consensus seemed to be that it would take a heck of a long time to reach it some other way.

Anyway I guess we should be thankful for those unfortunate few people who did discover it via the museum card route. I agree that it's a nasty bug, but such a random one i'm not sure we can really get mad at PD about it, and i've still not seen evidence of much else, but will look into the apparent freezing bug that seems to be affecting you BLuesky and some others as I hadn't heard about that before.
 

Lol. Touché... Glad There are other Flying Circus fans here... Cleese is pure comedy...
"alright aside from the lack of damage models, just added remote BSpec, grinding, BSpec Bob mode, long load times, mishmash UI, just added gear ratios, PP system, hundreds of premiums, online play, gifting, lack of profile saves or endurance saves, just added replay controls, photomode, 800+ standard cars, GT Life, awesome simulator, karting, stock cars AND rally? What has PD really given us!?!"

"Uhm... The GT series?"

"oh piss, shaddap!"

I gripe about the game because I wish it were better. I still enjoy playing it too!
 
Hmmm, what has PD ever done for us, what a dumb question..
Go and look at the vid link...eh? I don't think you understand what I'm saying.

I like GT5 and I'm fed up of the complaints too - just go and look at the Monty Python clip.
 
1. Given us the GT series
2. Kick started the whole driving simulator genre
3. Given us the most criticized developer and game ever seriously I don't think I have ever seen so much vile hatred for PD and GT5 :lol:
 
Go and look at the vid link...eh? I don't think you understand what I'm saying.

I like GT5 and I'm fed up of the complaints too - just go and look at the Monty Python clip.

Oh, my apologies, I may have just looked at the title and rolled my eyes and typed, sorry.
 
1. Given us the GT series
2. Kick started the whole driving simulator genre
3. Given us the most criticized developer and game ever seriously I don't think I have ever seen so much vile hatred for PD and GT5 :lol:

I couldn't have said it better myself.
 
Facile arguments all round, sadly. You can cheat in GT5 (for now anyway) to progress more quickly, it's called duping. I never said there's anything "immoral" about using cheats either, you made that up out of thin air. But for people to claim they have been ripped off because they can't unlock all the cars within 3 months of release is ridiculous.

I also never said you had no right to criticise GT (again you imagined that too), my beef was with you crying that there are fans of GT5 on a GT-dedicated forum. Well duh. It's all too easy to mark them all off as fanboys isn't it? And yes per my other post I do find it odd that people join a dedicated forum just to knock a game, you don't see that so much in things like band forums, where typically you are more likely to find people who enjoy the band and want to share the experience. Don't be criticising those people.

Also they are updates, not "patches", some minor issues were fixed but they are changes to the game, not fixed for fundamental bugs because unlike many other games/patches, there are actually very little in the way of true "bugs". Just because you don't like something doesn't make it a bug, son.

Lastly, I love a lot of racing games, all different types, I loved Forza too though only played the first one. And I wish a few things were different about GT also and think PD made some odd decisions, as well as some that are really their call and not for me to imply it should have been done differently based on how *I* might do it. This does not make me an "insane fan" but if you want to keep falling back on that (see above) just keep going, it will wear out eventually.

I would be interested to know if you actually play GT5 or just bash it on here. I'm guessing you don't play it or like it at all, it being such a "mess" and all, so you just bash away at it in a dedicated forum. Sad.

Let's see...
Why it's ridiculous to drive the cars in the game you bought? If GT5 had a good progression and career mode it wouldn't be a problem. But it doesn't! Employing tactics like:
  • Rubberband Grinding
  • B-Spec 24 Races
  • Remote B-Spec Races
  • Running multiple times oval races with the most overpowered car to gain the most ammount of money in the least ammount of time
  • Birthday Glitching
  • Duping
are all workarounds that people in this forum use to have a chance to drive the cars of this game. If you don't use any of this you may forget driving any of the expensive cars in this game in the next 10 years! Do you find career progression rational in GT5? I don't, I find it ridiculous! You said it is ridiculous to expect to drive the cars of this games in 3 months! Wasn't GT5 advertised that it contains 1000+ cars? I expect to be able to at least buy the most expensive ones in a reasonable amount of time, that is in less than 3 months! You don't consider 3 moths a reasonable amount of time to be able to buy the Ferrari 330P4 without playing every day of the week? Then we have a completely different idea on what is gaming...

Do I use any of this tactics, I mentioned? No, I only use duping because it takes the least amount of time! I don't plan on playing forcing punish myself to grind through B-Spec! But I would prefer to be able to unlock all cars in Arcade mode! I am playing GT5 for about 2 months, in other racing games I would be able to drive most cars in Arcade mode! PD doesn't allow that, instead they are going to make duping so difficult and time consuming that I don't find worth doing anymore!

About fans...
I am aware that this a GT fan-site. But in my opinion it's one thing to be a fan and a completely another to be a blind follower!
For example many here behave like that:
  • PD introduces gifting in GT5: "Great job PD, you are the best!"
  • PD limits gifting: "Great job PD, you are the best!"
  • PD temporarily removes gift limit: "Great job PD, you are the best!"
  • Whatever they do: "Great job PD, you are the best!"
  • To all the others: "Why are you criticizing PD? They are the best and everything they do is the best!"
Do you find this behavior rational? Check out the poll on this forum! 40% of the voters thing that it's a good thing that PD limits/takes-way a feature that was in the Game and people were using and praising! They are happy that PD makes the game more limiting! This is blind-faith in my book!

You distinction between updates and "patches" is wrong otherwise "Windows Update" would be called "Windows Patches"! The same for Mac OS X and Linux! Updates or minor-versions fix bugs/problems with a program and introduce minor enhancements! New/Major versions introduce new features!

What we have seen till now (and what we will continue to see) in GT5 are minor versions! Unless of course you consider Seasonal events with their much higher payouts a feature and not an attempt at a fix for the awful career progression! Or the so-called updated AI (I haven't seen it) a feature and not a bad attempt at a fix. Remote races could be a new feature, but since it doesn't introduce a new gameplay element it's in reality a new grinding opportunity.

But I am not irrational, I don't expect new features in GT5! I don't believe for example that standard cars will ever be updated to premium! But I would like some fixes, like better shadows, better smoke effects, better tire balance, better career progression etc. But what do we get in return in 1.07? More limits and more restriction in the car gifting system! Or do you consider limiting gifting a feature? OK then, have fun with the new feature...

Lastly you doubt that I even play GT5....
I bought GT5 expecting to become extremely disappointed by the handling of the cars but it would at least have good graphics. On the contrary I found the graphics to be mediocre to bad but I found the handling of some cars to be exceptional. I was pleasantly surprised with GT5!

But the more I played I found more problems in GT5 like lack of mechanical damage, not enough credits, bad AI. Then with some fixes like seasonal events and save-game-backup I managed to purchase some good cars in GT5 and have some more fun. But while the handling was great I found the racing to become more and more sterile and boring. I have stopped playing GT5 for some time and I was hoping for an update that would fix some graphical glitches and introduce an option to drive all cars since it's the only thing I find fun in GT5.

Instead we got more restriction, limits and "new features" like Remote Races that have nothing to do with driving! So I guess that's the end of GT5 for me and the only reason I post (but won't continue to do so) is because I once had fun with GT5 and I was hoping it could get better with some simple fixes!

I have moved on to better, more fun racing games, that don't try to limit what I can do, they don't take away features, they don't force me to grind to drive some decents cars. And thankfully even better games are coming! :)

And in my opinion GT5 is a mess because PD is spending development time on B-Spec, Remote Races, Car-Gift-Limits and doesn't fix the graphical glitches, doesn't enhance the driving/racing mechanics of the game, nor do they introduce a way to get away from the awful grinding!
 
Last edited:
OK potentially your save can reach that size without viewing museum cards (pre-fix) but the consensus seemed to be that it would take a heck of a long time to reach it some other way.

Anyway I guess we should be thankful for those unfortunate few people who did discover it via the museum card route. I agree that it's a nasty bug, but such a random one i'm not sure we can really get mad at PD about it, and i've still not seen evidence of much else, but will look into the apparent freezing bug that seems to be affecting you BLuesky and some others as I hadn't heard about that before.

Right, but like you said, it seems the museum cards are the easiest way for the file size to increase. I didn't realize that. Thanks for pointing it out.

Well, I'm sure eventually they'll fix the bugs that aren't patched yet and continue improving GT5 so ALL of us can get the same level of enjoyment from it. :)

Also, I certainly understand that some people are much more happy with GT5 than others. That's great! The reason I have been posting my grievances with the game is in the hope that someone from PD will listen and improve upon GT5. Improvements that hopefully all of us will find desirable. As I said earlier, I really WANT to like this game more than I do.

I have made posts expressing some of the things I really like with GT5 as well. My posts are not all negative.

I'm confident that if enough people post their concerns, some of the issues will be resolved and all of us will have a better experience with GT5.

Cheers!
:cheers:
 
Last edited:
@vroom:
But this is the problem, people seem not to realise that you can drive those expensive cars without doing that. Special events and Seasonal events give you great amount of cash (a bit too much infact) and you can get up to 2 mil for just doing about 5 races.
Online racing also gives you good cash now and theres a variety of different lobbies you can join which will suit your taste (jgtc, nascar, road cars, compact cars).

Everyones jumping on the bandwagon about how you have to grind now to do everything when they havent even checked for themselves.
I earned 800,000cr in total by just doing rally in special events. And they even awarded you cars which you could use in the next level of events.
AMG driving accademy also gives you a great deal of cash and you learn the track aswell.

I seriously don't see the big grinding fuss people are making. The only time I grind is when I need money fast (say I need to get a car and join a lobby with my friends) and thats for only like 2 times of one track (sometimes madrid sometimes indy). You're making out like you have to go around the track 300 times to get good money.

Stop making false statements and jumping on the bandwagon.
 
Birthday glitching... lol. I think that is suppose to be a present from PD to us on our birthdays? Its not their fault people decided to take advantage of it.
 
@Afro1: I really think the problem is that the game simply doesn't give enough things for the player to do. I hate to bring in Forza, but I have to in order to prove my point.

There are plenty of cars in Forza 3 that I really want to own that I have yet to get. But I am in no rush to get them, because the game has plenty of diffrent events to keep me occupied so I can earn money torwards the cars I want. The same thing went for previous GTs.

I can't say the same for GT5. The Special events and the Seasonals can only be done once and seasonals aren't even what I consider to be races. You're just trying to catch up with the leader. I am also level 33 A-spec and I have nothing left to do other than endurance races. Not to mention, a lot of the cars I want are in the UCD, so that combined with the lack of events, often leads me to repeating events and grinding, because there's really nothing left for me to do but collect cars now.

And I can't deal with online right now. I hate having to hunt down rooms everytime I want to race. And there have been times when I joined rooms during a race, and after it's over, the host suddenly decides to turn the room into a free run, and I'm waiting for a race that isn't going to happen.

This is why I'm barely playing the game now until we at least we get matchmaking. The fact that we don't have as many different things to do in GT5 like in previous GTs is my #1 complaint with this game. That's why I'm deeply depending on matchmaking to keep me entertained with GT5. That and GT Driver's Club that was mentioned in the news section of GT5. Once these two things come (and hopefully are implemented well) I will finally be satisfied with this game, and since I also own Forza 3, I will be one happy guy knowing that I have access to both of these great racing games.
 
Last edited:
The fact that we don't have as many different things to do in GT5 like in previous GTs is my #1 complaint with this game. That's why I'm deeply depending on matchmaking to keep me entertained with GT5. That and GT Driver's Club that was mentioned in the news section of GT5. Once these two things come (and hopefully are implemented well) I will finally be satisfied with this game, and since I also own Forza 3, I will be one happy guy knowing that I have access to both of these great racing games.
I would add that we should be lobbying for more A-Spec as well as B-Spec events. PD could make race series forever with the basic building blocks they put in this game. I think they used half the tracks they made in single player! On top of that, someone had the excellent idea to make One Make Practice races into Manufacturer Cup events with credit and XP rewards. Just doing that one thing would add tremendously to the game.
 
Tenacious D
I would add that we should be lobbying for more A-Spec as well as B-Spec events. PD could make race series forever with the basic building blocks they put in this game. I think they used half the tracks they made in single player! On top of that, someone had the excellent idea to make One Make Practice races into Manufacturer Cup events with credit and XP rewards. Just doing that one thing would add tremendously to the game.

Exactly.

I'm a bit surprised they didn't use all tracks in the game for GT Life. Where's High Speed Ring with rain and Eiger with rain for example? And I think using SSR7 for Like the Wind would've been great.

And I also agree there should be some more B-spec events. I even made a poll in the Seasonal Event forum to see if people wanted to see them as a counterpart for the A-spec seasonal events races. B-spec isn't my most favorite mode, but if they have big payouts, I'm sure people will be more likely to do them.

We'll wait and see what they do, I guess. Just going to have to be patient for now.
 
I seriously don't see the big grinding fuss people are making. The only time I grind is when I need money fast (say I need to get a car and join a lobby with my friends) and thats for only like 2 times of one track (sometimes madrid sometimes indy). You're making out like you have to go around the track 300 times to get good money.

Stop making false statements and jumping on the bandwagon.
Bingo.

Frankly, it's so rarely necessary to grind, that I think the ones who do simply aren't very good at the game. It's easy enough to obtain whatever you want in the game.
 
I seriously don't see the big grinding fuss people are making. The only time I grind is when I need money fast (say I need to get a car and join a lobby with my friends) and thats for only like 2 times of one track (sometimes madrid sometimes indy). You're making out like you have to go around the track 300 times to get good money.

Stop making false statements and jumping on the bandwagon.

You should jump off your bandwagon as well. Listen, just because you enjoy running around in slow JDM stuff that cost 20k at most doesn't mean there's not a money problem in the game for others. All I want is all the race cars in the game. And whether childish fanboys that will never admit anything is wrong with their precious toy will ever admit it or not, there's no other way to obtain all those cars without grinding.

That is a fact, and there is no refuting it.
 
"Where has this expectation that developers should continue to bring massive updates and additional content to a game come from? We aren't paying a monthly fee."

Part of it may be that PD failed to deliver on content that was confirmed/promised, i.e., all tracks from GT4 would be in GT5.
 
What has PD ever done for us? Well, nothing actually. You see, PD is a corporation owned by Sony, an even bigger corporation. And corporations exist for one purpose only, to make money. Sure, they make money by producing a product that we want, but they don't make GT for the purpose of making us happy, they make it for the purpose of making money. Is GT a labor of love, sure, but the primary motivation for producing GT is selfishness, and I don't mean that in a bad way. PD makes GT for PD and Sony, to make them money. PD has clearly heard the dissatisfaction with GT5 in forums like these and in the critical reviews, and that is why they are making such an effort to fix the game, because they are afraid that people won't buy GT6, they are afraid that next time they won't make as much money.

Also, it should be noted that a new Forza game comes out approximately every 2 years. PD had six to put out GT5 and look at all the complaints about it not being finished. Now, I've played both games, and I still like GT better, even with all the flaws GT5 has, but I don't think PD can afford to do this again.
 
All I want is all the race cars in the game. And whether childish fanboys that will never admit anything is wrong with their precious toy will ever admit it or not, there's no other way to obtain all those cars without grinding.
Well, lookie now. No racing game remotely like Gran Turismo, from Toca through Ferrai Challenge and Forza, gave you all the race cars in the game without a lot of racing. And this usually includes grinding. Forza 1 was the first game to use a level based system to my recollection, and guess what? Cars were level locked. You couldn't even look at them until you were high enough level.

That is a fact, and there is no refuting it.

I wonder how many people still want PD to check out other racing games. :sly:
 
What has PD ever done for us? Well, nothing actually...
Once more, I do wish people would read the OP and watch the little film...it's a tongue-in-cheek poke at all the complaints.

Of course PD have done something for us...given us all the GT titles and a lot of gaming pleasure in the past. Okay, this one didn't go so smoothly, for whatever reason - they have listened (a bit too much I think) and released patches in an attempted to fix this...but people still act as if PD have murdered Mickey Mouse or something like that.
 
Well, lookie now. No racing game remotely like Gran Turismo, from Toca through Ferrai Challenge and Forza, gave you all the race cars in the game without a lot of racing. And this usually includes grinding. Forza 1 was the first game to use a level based system to my recollection, and guess what? Cars were level locked. You couldn't even look at them until you were high enough level.

That is a fact, and there is no refuting it.

I wonder how many people still want PD to check out other racing games. :sly:

I wish PD would look to other games!

Most of these other games have a quick race mode! In that mode you can drive most cars and in any color. And the more you progress in the career mode, more cars become available in the arcade mode. This way you can have a casual quick race! And you can test a car prior to buying it!

GT5 doesn't offer that! It offers some cars from the beginning but other cars are not unlocked as you progress. Every car you want to drive you have to buy it! Sometimes the car you buy may not be as good as you thought and you can't even sell it if it's expensive!!

And if you want to have it an different color most times you have to buy it again, and again! And if you upgrade it (weight reduction, engine update) and you want to drive it as stock, you have to buy it again! And if it's a standard car, and you are lucky to find it, the color is random! And the paint items (duh!!) can only be used once! And if you want to drive a casual quick race with random roughly similar performance opponents you have to add it to your favorites, go back to main menu (loading...), arcade mode (loading...), quick race! And you can have only 100 favorites so you must constantly check and uncheck favorites with a cumbersome, slow interface. And I could go on and on....

But soon you would find that you don't have enough money to buy the other cars you want so you would force yourself to "grind" through awful A-Spec races without mechanical damage and with slow, bad AI! But then you stop playing the game to have fun, but you are "working" and hope that in the future you will be able to drive an expensive car which will hopefully be good and have some fun! Why should a game be so punishing and time-demanding?

In my opinion you can't deny that you can't just have a casual quick race with the car you want in GT5! You are forced to keep repeating the buy/upgrade/buy again/don't upgrade/you can't change color/buy/grind cycle!

"Duping" was the only workaround to get away from this cycle. Now (or very soon) it won't be possible! Was it a good workaround? Not really, but there wasn't another option! I would like PD to offer an option to unlock all cars corresponding to your A-Spec level in arcade mode! But then the "elitists" would revolt against the "casual scum" that destroy their game and "steal" their "glory and bragging rights" by driving the expensive cars without "working" for them! So I am sure that PD won't offer that option since these elitists are their faithful consumer base that doesn't see anything wrong with their game...

You may say that GT5 game is not a game for "casual" players, that GT5 is a game for "serious" virtual drivers, who want to "live the life" of a professional driver by repeatedly racing playing bumper-cars against slow AI, with no mechanical damage and buying cars just to change the color of their car! And they find all that a good gameplay mechanic! And then they are happy when PD takes away a feature (gifting expensive cars) that was available in the original game! I can't argue with that.... have fun.... :)

Me, as I play games to have some non-frustating moments of fun, I will play other driving games which don't take their selfs so seriously that demand their users to "work" to have the "right" to drive the cars they bought! Thankfully there are many other games which I find to be more realistic and more fun than GT5! And even better driving games are coming! So, honestly, have fun with GT5! I don't anymore and I don't care anymore! :)
 
Last edited:
Back