Agree with the first part.
100 percent disagree with the second part. A racing game of gt5/Forza caliber with the current technology of PCs would NOT suck.
Sorry but in myhumbleannoying opinion PC gaming trumps consul gaming always. A current PC destroys PS3 or XBOX360 in a way that makes them both pretty sad. I love my PS3 for the fun it allows me online with friends, but every time I switch it on I know I'm nowhere near the potential of what a processing computer can do.
This is the reason I would never buy crossover games for a consul. Think about it. Halo was better on PC in multiple ways, including the ability to mouse/keyboard, graphics, etc. And that game defined xbox, so what is that saying? I would have never bought Alice Madness Returns for PS3. For one, the PS3 version lacks the detailed physics engine of the PC version and the graphics are better. Not to mention the original Alice (my favorite video game ever released on anything) was on PC originally. And while I appreciate them broadening their audience, no thanks. Battlefield 3? Duke Nukem Forever? Cry-anything? Portal 2? All much, much more phenomenal on PC. What's to say GT or FMS wouldn't be just as epic? Your PC and PS3 are pretty much the same thing except one you can add parts to.
But I am extremely biased. Like, extremely biased. Grew up on DOS games throughout my childhood. So, feel free to disagree with prejudice.
But yeah, it would never happen.
I agree about the PC thing. Console games are like tarts with a tonne of makeup slapped on to look nice, remove the makeup and the next morning it's like WOAH I slept with THAT?!!
PC games are naturally attractive and give you WAY more in the detail department.
The cost argument is a crock as well. I still have my PC that I got in 2007 and only had a small recent GFX card upgrade for 100 pounds (in that time I've bought a 360 and PS3 for around 500 quid).
Also my PC does WAY more than my 360 and PS3. A HUGE part of the cost of the PC is it does WAY more than just play games.
BTW Tower Turn, have you signed up to the C.A.R.S. project? I'm going to push for elements of the GTs and Forzas in that.