After another hour or two here's my final take: Power Pack should 100% be the core of the base game. It's perfect for introducing new players to the GT franchise.Same difference....
Let's say they went with your proposal,
That's why it is a DLC, you can think of it as you want.
In previous GT, there was an Arcade section.
I would say this very much belong to GT.
Here is what I gather GT8 should be:
A - licenses, missions and menus (cafe section?)
B - arcade (pick up and play) with local players (multiplayer) and music rally (just mindless fun)
C - car collecting, history and appreciation (cafe)
D - single player mode - career mode
E - live sanctioned racing against the community (GT Sport)
F - free roam open world with side quest like Forza Horizon everything else...
G - community and social interaction (livery, share photos and videos)
H - customs races and map/track creations (that can be accessible for B, F and G
I - photography (scapes), technically this should be in C.
All that can coexist in one single game....
Limited cars, no options to adjust or tweak things other than Traction Control and Brake Balance, lots of practice time, qualifying, no resets.
Add on to that the mix of racing, challenges/skill tests, credits, tickets, and prize cars and you've got the best Base GT Game ever made.
THEN you expand on that with GT as we have come to know and love it. Tweaks, setup changes, tire options, enter your own car into races, all that kind of thing.
Sport is functionally irrelevant to me, I have online racing it's all garbage all of the time. Photos/livery editors/paints/etc are all nice to have but I could care less if they exist.
To use your list AND rank them:
A - licenses, missions and menus (cafe section?)
B - arcade (pick up and play) with local players (multiplayer) and music rally (just mindless fun)
C - single player mode - career mode
D - customs races and map/track creations (that can be accessible for B, C, H)
E - car collecting, history and appreciation (cafe)
F - community and social interaction (livery, share photos and videos) / G - photography (scapes), technically this should be in C. Agreed this is why it's on the same line for me.
H - live sanctioned racing against the community (GT Sport)
I - free roam open world with side quest like Forza Horizon everything else...
I'm not saying this is what everyone wants, it's just my wishlist order.
My final thought is that the Power Pack is great as a core to start with. It's very bad as "End Game Content" and DLC this late in a games lifecycle should be "End Game Content". Power Pack is "Start of Game Content" and that's my biggest gripe about it.